nhaliday + forum   66

Is the bounty system effective? - Meta Stack Exchange
could do some kinda econometric analysis using the data explorer to determine this once and for all: https://pinboard.in/u:nhaliday/b:c0cd449b9e69
maybe some kinda RDD in time, or difference-in-differences?
I don't think answer quality/quantity by time meets the common trend assumption for DD, tho... Questions that eventually receive bounty are prob higher quality in the first place, and higher quality answers accumulate more and better answers regardless. Hmm.
q-n-a  stackex  forum  community  info-foraging  efficiency  cost-benefit  data  analysis  incentives  attention  quality  ubiquity  supply-demand  multi  math  causation  endogenous-exogenous  intervention  branches  control  tactics  sleuthin  hmm  idk  todo  data-science  overflow  dbs  regression  shift  methodology  econometrics 
21 days ago by nhaliday
About - Project Euler
I've written my program but should it take days to get to the answer?
Absolutely not! Each problem has been designed according to a "one-minute rule", which means that although it may take several hours to design a successful algorithm with more difficult problems, an efficient implementation will allow a solution to be obtained on a modestly powered computer in less than one minute.
math  rec-math  math.NT  math.CO  programming  oly  database  community  forum  stream  problem-solving  accretion  puzzles  contest  🖥  👳 
june 2019 by nhaliday
HN: the good parts
HN comments are terrible. On any topic I’m informed about, the vast majority of comments are pretty clearly wrong. Most of the time, there are zero comments from people who know anything about the topic and the top comment is reasonable sounding but totally incorrect. Additionally, many comments are gratuitously mean. You'll often hear mean comments backed up with something like "this is better than the other possibility, where everyone just pats each other on the back with comments like 'this is great'", as if being an asshole is some sort of talisman against empty platitudes. I've seen people push back against that; when pressed, people often say that it’s either impossible or inefficient to teach someone without being mean, as if telling someone that they're stupid somehow helps them learn. It's as if people learned how to explain things by watching Simon Cowell and can't comprehend the concept of an explanation that isn't littered with personal insults. Paul Graham has said, "Oh, you should never read Hacker News comments about anything you write”. Most of the negative things you hear about HN comments are true.

And yet, I haven’t found a public internet forum with better technical commentary. On topics I'm familiar with, while it's rare that a thread will have even a single comment that's well-informed, when those comments appear, they usually float to the top. On other forums, well-informed comments are either non-existent or get buried by reasonable sounding but totally wrong comments when they appear, and they appear even more rarely than on HN.


I compiled a very abbreviated list of comments I like because comments seem to get lost. If you write a blog post, people will refer it years later, but comments mostly disappear. I think that’s sad -- there’s a lot of great material on HN (and yes, even more not-so-great material).
hn  forum  subculture  list  contrarianism  community  dan-luu  top-n  🖥  techtariat 
october 2016 by nhaliday
LessWrong 2.0 - Less Wrong
The people still on the LW site are not a representative sample of anything. With the exception of a few people like Stuart Armstrong, they’re some kind of pack of unquiet spirits who have moved in to haunt it after it got abandoned by the founding community members. At this point it’s pretty much diaspora all the way down.
subculture  postmortem  rationality  forum  lesswrong  ratty  diaspora  schelling 
august 2016 by nhaliday
Links 10/15: Bride of Linkenstein | Slate Star Codex
Study predicts that US average IQ will rise 2-3 points in the next fifty years, driven by finding that minorities are catching up very quickly. Haven’t investigated their numbers yet, but excellent if true. [EDIT: more discussion here]

Omnilibrium is a social site that tries to improve online filtering. Instead of a big pot of Reddit-style karma that shows everyone the most upvoted posts, it tries to show everyone posts upvoted by people whose opinions have previously been correlated with theirs, with various customizable options to decide how much you want to be exposed to differing opinions. It needs more users for a good trial run, so check out their FAQ and then join in.

Female education decreases teenage fertility, but does not have a more general lifetime effect on fertility.

Michigan leads the nation in routing around democracy. The pessimistic view is that democracy shouldn’t be routed around. The optimistic view is that democracy should rarely be routed around, the catastrophes in Detroit and Flint are among those rare times, and this proves that people are good at limiting this extreme remedy to the times when it’s needed.

Chanda Chisala at Unz Report is on a roll. He’s been talking a lot about how the success of African immigrants to the US confounds a lot of simplistic explanations of the black-white achievement gap. Everybody figured this was just a result of those immigrants being heavily selected, but now he’s back with two posts arguing that it’s not selection effects. First, he points out that the immigrants’ children don’t seem to be regressing to the mean in a very specific Jensenian way that we would expect if they had been selected – this is more complex than I originally thought and not answered simply by “the offspring of two equally extreme parents will not regress”. Second, he points out that even the children of Somali refugees – an unselected population if ever there was one – seem to be doing better than native-born African-Americans. Some attempts at counterargument from James Thompson and Human Varieties. It’s good to see these issues being debated by such civil and mathematically sophisticated people, and also a sign of change how many people on both sides are black. Also by Chisala: book about Barack Obama debating Ayn Rand

Very large randomized controlled preschool study finds abysmal results of pre-K education; recipients of pre-K do better in kindergarten, but by third grade the trend reverses and they have worse behavioral and academic outcomes (hey, remember that study from last month how entering school too early may exacerbate ADHD)? This echoes results from the last few large randomized well-conducted preschool studies, so even the educational establishment is vaguely starting to notice a trend. James Heckman leads the pro-pre-K response, saying that past studies have found the same lack of advantage in later school performance but then later found better adult employment and prosociality outcomes; his explanation is that preschool doesn’t necessarily increase IQ but does increase “social and emotional skills that are greater determinants of late-life success”. But then how come the pre-K children had worse behavior in school in the new study? Possible explanation: the old studies Heckman cites were preschool plus a bunch of early life care and parenting help; maybe the latter helped and the former was at best neutral? Vox has a really excellent summary.
links  yvain  iq  politics  forum  race  education  usa  trends  ssc  ratty  multi  midwest  democracy  pop-diff  flynn  rindermann-thompson  prediction  regularizer  africa  migration  selection  albion  scitariat  regression-to-mean 
july 2016 by nhaliday
A Family-Friendly Policy That’s Friendliest to Male Professors - The New York Times
Evidence of a Toxic Environment for Women in Economics: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/18/upshot/evidence-of-a-toxic-environment-for-women-in-economics.html
lmao, Borjas:
Some economists say they find the discourse on econjobrumors.com to be a breath of fresh air. George Borjas, an economics professor at Harvard, wrote on his blog last summer that he found the forum “refreshing.”

Professor Borjas said: “There’s still hope for mankind when many of the posts written by a bunch of over-educated young social scientists illustrate a throwing off of the shackles of political correctness and reflect mundane concerns that more normal human beings share: prestige, sex, money, landing a job, sex, professional misconduct, sex … ” In an email sent on Wednesday, after he received a copy of Ms. Wu’s paper, Professor Borjas said his views have not changed.
academia  career  gender  study  economics  labor  news  higher-ed  data  summary  org:rec  multi  borjas  econotariat  lmao  sex  identity-politics  westminster  forum  community  chan  internet  commentary  media  propaganda 
june 2016 by nhaliday
Imzy - Home
reddit replacement w/ an agenda of friendliness
community  tools  software  social  forum  hmm 
april 2016 by nhaliday
poll-based comments - people write short disputable statements "Workers in Moscow don't make enough" and then other commenters can up or down-vote them, so that they can provide instant feedback without having to type anything
d3  community  forum  ai  organization 
august 2014 by nhaliday

bundles : interwebmeta

related tags

academia  accretion  acm  acmtariat  advice  africa  aggregator  ai  ai-control  albion  algorithms  alignment  analysis  announcement  anonymity  anthropology  aphorism  art  asia  attention  audio  backup  best-practices  big-picture  blog  borjas  branches  brands  business  c(pp)  calculator  career  causation  chan  checking  china  clever-rats  cocoa  commentary  communication  community  comparison  confidence  config  confusion  contest  contrarianism  control  cooking  cool  coordination  cost-benefit  cracker-prog  crux  cs  culture-war  curiosity  d3  dan-luu  data  data-science  database  dataset  dbs  debate  decentralized  deep-learning  democracy  devtools  diaspora  dirty-hands  discipline  discussion  distribution  diy  documentation  dotnet  drama  driving  DSL  dynamic  econometrics  economics  econotariat  ecosystem  editors  education  effective-altruism  efficiency  electromag  email  endogenous-exogenous  engineering  ensembles  entrepreneurialism  epistemic  essay  evidence-based  exocortex  experiment  expert  expert-experience  explanation  feynman  fiction  fitness  fitsci  flux-stasis  flynn  food  foreign-lang  form-design  forum  fourier  frameworks  french  frontend  functional  futurism  gedanken  gender  get-fit  giants  gnu  golang  government  grad-school  growth-econ  gwern  haskell  health  heavyweights  higher-ed  hmm  hn  howto  human-capital  identity-politics  idk  IEEE  incentives  info-dynamics  info-foraging  interdisciplinary  internet  intervention  interview-prep  intricacy  ios  iq  japan  jargon  javascript  jvm  labor  language  law  learning  lesswrong  let-me-see  letters  libraries  links  linux  list  lmao  lol  long-short-run  longform  machine-learning  maker  maps  math  math.CO  math.NT  measure  measurement  media  meta:prediction  meta:reading  meta:rhetoric  methodology  metrics  microbiz  microsoft  midwest  migration  mindful  minimalism  miri-cfar  mobile  multi  music  network-structure  news  nibble  nostalgia  notation  notetaking  nutrition  objektbuch  oly  oly-programming  opsec  org:com  org:data  org:davos  org:gov  org:med  org:popup  org:rec  organization  organizing  os  oss  overflow  parsimony  pdf  people  performance  phd  philosophy  physics  plan9  planning  pls  plt  policy  politics  pop-diff  postmortem  prediction  prepping  priors-posteriors  pro-rata  problem-solving  profile  programming  project  propaganda  proposal  puzzles  python  q-n-a  qra  quality  quantum  quantum-info  quixotic  quotes  r-lang  race  ranking  rationality  ratty  reason  rec-math  recommendations  reddit  reference  regression  regression-to-mean  regularizer  research  retention  rhetoric  rindermann-thompson  rust  scale  schelling  scifi-fantasy  scitariat  search  security  selection  sequential  sex  shift  signal-noise  simplification-normalization  sinosphere  skunkworks  sleuthin  social  software  speculation  spock  sports  spreading  ssc  stackex  startups  static-dynamic  stats  stories  stream  study  subculture  summary  summer-2014  supply-demand  sv  system-design  tactics  tcs  teaching  tech  techtariat  terminal  time  time-series  tip-of-tongue  todo  tools  top-n  traces  tradecraft  transitions  transportation  trends  trivia  truth  tutoring  ubiquity  usa  vcs  visualization  visuo  vulgar  web  westminster  wiki  wire-guided  workflow  working-stiff  worse-is-better/the-right-thing  writing  yak-shaving  yvain  👳  🔬  🖥  🤖 

Copy this bookmark: