nhaliday + acm + ideas   13

Prisoner's dilemma - Wikipedia
caveat to result below:
An extension of the IPD is an evolutionary stochastic IPD, in which the relative abundance of particular strategies is allowed to change, with more successful strategies relatively increasing. This process may be accomplished by having less successful players imitate the more successful strategies, or by eliminating less successful players from the game, while multiplying the more successful ones. It has been shown that unfair ZD strategies are not evolutionarily stable. The key intuition is that an evolutionarily stable strategy must not only be able to invade another population (which extortionary ZD strategies can do) but must also perform well against other players of the same type (which extortionary ZD players do poorly, because they reduce each other's surplus).[14]

Theory and simulations confirm that beyond a critical population size, ZD extortion loses out in evolutionary competition against more cooperative strategies, and as a result, the average payoff in the population increases when the population is bigger. In addition, there are some cases in which extortioners may even catalyze cooperation by helping to break out of a face-off between uniform defectors and win–stay, lose–switch agents.[8]

https://alfanl.com/2018/04/12/defection/
Nature boils down to a few simple concepts.

Haters will point out that I oversimplify. The haters are wrong. I am good at saying a lot with few words. Nature indeed boils down to a few simple concepts.

In life, you can either cooperate or defect.

Used to be that defection was the dominant strategy, say in the time when the Roman empire started to crumble. Everybody complained about everybody and in the end nothing got done. Then came Jesus, who told people to be loving and cooperative, and boom: 1800 years later we get the industrial revolution.

Because of Jesus we now find ourselves in a situation where cooperation is the dominant strategy. A normie engages in a ton of cooperation: with the tax collector who wants more and more of his money, with schools who want more and more of his kid’s time, with media who wants him to repeat more and more party lines, with the Zeitgeist of the Collective Spirit of the People’s Progress Towards a New Utopia. Essentially, our normie is cooperating himself into a crumbling Western empire.

Turns out that if everyone blindly cooperates, parasites sprout up like weeds until defection once again becomes the standard.

The point of a post-Christian religion is to once again create conditions for the kind of cooperation that led to the industrial revolution. This necessitates throwing out undead Christianity: you do not blindly cooperate. You cooperate with people that cooperate with you, you defect on people that defect on you. Christianity mixed with Darwinism. God and Gnon meet.

This also means we re-establish spiritual hierarchy, which, like regular hierarchy, is a prerequisite for cooperation. It is this hierarchical cooperation that turns a household into a force to be reckoned with, that allows a group of men to unite as a front against their enemies, that allows a tribe to conquer the world. Remember: Scientology bullied the Cathedral’s tax department into submission.

With a functioning hierarchy, men still gossip, lie and scheme, but they will do so in whispers behind closed doors. In your face they cooperate and contribute to the group’s wellbeing because incentives are thus that contributing to group wellbeing heightens status.

Without a functioning hierarchy, men gossip, lie and scheme, but they do so in your face, and they tell you that you are positively deluded for accusing them of gossiping, lying and scheming. Seeds will not sprout in such ground.

Spiritual dominance is established in the same way any sort of dominance is established: fought for, taken. But the fight is ritualistic. You can’t force spiritual dominance if no one listens, or if you are silenced the ritual is not allowed to happen.

If one of our priests is forbidden from establishing spiritual dominance, that is a sure sign an enemy priest is in better control and has vested interest in preventing you from establishing spiritual dominance..

They defect on you, you defect on them. Let them suffer the consequences of enemy priesthood, among others characterized by the annoying tendency that very little is said with very many words.

https://contingentnotarbitrary.com/2018/04/14/rederiving-christianity/
To recap, we started with a secular definition of Logos and noted that its telos is existence. Given human nature, game theory and the power of cooperation, the highest expression of that telos is freely chosen universal love, tempered by constant vigilance against defection while maintaining compassion for the defectors and forgiving those who repent. In addition, we must know the telos in order to fulfill it.

In Christian terms, looks like we got over half of the Ten Commandments (know Logos for the First, don’t defect or tempt yourself to defect for the rest), the importance of free will, the indestructibility of evil (group cooperation vs individual defection), loving the sinner and hating the sin (with defection as the sin), forgiveness (with conditions), and love and compassion toward all, assuming only secular knowledge and that it’s good to exist.

Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma is an Ultimatum Game: http://infoproc.blogspot.com/2012/07/iterated-prisoners-dilemma-is-ultimatum.html
The history of IPD shows that bounded cognition prevented the dominant strategies from being discovered for over over 60 years, despite significant attention from game theorists, computer scientists, economists, evolutionary biologists, etc. Press and Dyson have shown that IPD is effectively an ultimatum game, which is very different from the Tit for Tat stories told by generations of people who worked on IPD (Axelrod, Dawkins, etc., etc.).

...

For evolutionary biologists: Dyson clearly thinks this result has implications for multilevel (group vs individual selection):
... Cooperation loses and defection wins. The ZD strategies confirm this conclusion and make it sharper. ... The system evolved to give cooperative tribes an advantage over non-cooperative tribes, using punishment to give cooperation an evolutionary advantage within the tribe. This double selection of tribes and individuals goes way beyond the Prisoners' Dilemma model.

implications for fractionalized Europe vis-a-vis unified China?

and more broadly does this just imply we're doomed in the long run RE: cooperation, morality, the "good society", so on...? war and group-selection is the only way to get a non-crab bucket civilization?

Iterated Prisoner’s Dilemma contains strategies that dominate any evolutionary opponent:
http://www.pnas.org/content/109/26/10409.full
http://www.pnas.org/content/109/26/10409.full.pdf
https://www.edge.org/conversation/william_h_press-freeman_dyson-on-iterated-prisoners-dilemma-contains-strategies-that

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game

analogy for ultimatum game: the state gives the demos a bargain take-it-or-leave-it, and...if the demos refuses...violence?

The nature of human altruism: http://sci-hub.tw/https://www.nature.com/articles/nature02043
- Ernst Fehr & Urs Fischbacher

Some of the most fundamental questions concerning our evolutionary origins, our social relations, and the organization of society are centred around issues of altruism and selfishness. Experimental evidence indicates that human altruism is a powerful force and is unique in the animal world. However, there is much individual heterogeneity and the interaction between altruists and selfish individuals is vital to human cooperation. Depending on the environment, a minority of altruists can force a majority of selfish individuals to cooperate or, conversely, a few egoists can induce a large number of altruists to defect. Current gene-based evolutionary theories cannot explain important patterns of human altruism, pointing towards the importance of both theories of cultural evolution as well as gene–culture co-evolution.

...

Why are humans so unusual among animals in this respect? We propose that quantitatively, and probably even qualitatively, unique patterns of human altruism provide the answer to this question. Human altruism goes far beyond that which has been observed in the animal world. Among animals, fitness-reducing acts that confer fitness benefits on other individuals are largely restricted to kin groups; despite several decades of research, evidence for reciprocal altruism in pair-wise repeated encounters4,5 remains scarce6–8. Likewise, there is little evidence so far that individual reputation building affects cooperation in animals, which contrasts strongly with what we find in humans. If we randomly pick two human strangers from a modern society and give them the chance to engage in repeated anonymous exchanges in a laboratory experiment, there is a high probability that reciprocally altruistic behaviour will emerge spontaneously9,10.

However, human altruism extends far beyond reciprocal altruism and reputation-based cooperation, taking the form of strong reciprocity11,12. Strong reciprocity is a combination of altruistic rewarding, which is a predisposition to reward others for cooperative, norm-abiding behaviours, and altruistic punishment, which is a propensity to impose sanctions on others for norm violations. Strong reciprocators bear the cost of rewarding or punishing even if they gain no individual economic benefit whatsoever from their acts. In contrast, reciprocal altruists, as they have been defined in the biological literature4,5, reward and punish only if this is in their long-term self-interest. Strong reciprocity thus constitutes a powerful incentive for cooperation even in non-repeated interactions and when reputation gains are absent, because strong reciprocators will reward those who cooperate and punish those who defect.

...

We will show that the interaction between selfish and strongly reciprocal … [more]
concept  conceptual-vocab  wiki  reference  article  models  GT-101  game-theory  anthropology  cultural-dynamics  trust  cooperate-defect  coordination  iteration-recursion  sequential  axelrod  discrete  smoothness  evolution  evopsych  EGT  economics  behavioral-econ  sociology  new-religion  deep-materialism  volo-avolo  characterization  hsu  scitariat  altruism  justice  group-selection  decision-making  tribalism  organizing  hari-seldon  theory-practice  applicability-prereqs  bio  finiteness  multi  history  science  social-science  decision-theory  commentary  study  summary  giants  the-trenches  zero-positive-sum  🔬  bounded-cognition  info-dynamics  org:edge  explanation  exposition  org:nat  eden  retention  long-short-run  darwinian  markov  equilibrium  linear-algebra  nitty-gritty  competition  war  explanans  n-factor  europe  the-great-west-whale  occident  china  asia  sinosphere  orient  decentralized  markets  market-failure  cohesion  metabuch  stylized-facts  interdisciplinary  physics  pdf  pessimism  time  insight  the-basilisk  noblesse-oblige  the-watchers  ideas  l 
march 2018 by nhaliday
New Theory Cracks Open the Black Box of Deep Learning | Quanta Magazine
A new idea called the “information bottleneck” is helping to explain the puzzling success of today’s artificial-intelligence algorithms — and might also explain how human brains learn.

sounds like he's just talking about autoencoders?
news  org:mag  org:sci  popsci  announcement  research  deep-learning  machine-learning  acm  information-theory  bits  neuro  model-class  big-surf  frontier  nibble  hmm  signal-noise  deepgoog  expert  ideas  wild-ideas  summary  talks  video  israel  roots  physics  interdisciplinary  ai  intelligence  shannon  giants  arrows  preimage  lifts-projections  composition-decomposition  characterization  markov  gradient-descent  papers  liner-notes  experiment  hi-order-bits  generalization  expert-experience  explanans  org:inst  speedometer 
september 2017 by nhaliday

bundles : academeacmcrframefrontiergood-vibesmetathinking

related tags

academia  acm  acmtariat  adversarial  agriculture  ai  algorithms  alignment  altruism  analysis  analytical-holistic  announcement  anthropology  antiquity  aphorism  apollonian-dionysian  applicability-prereqs  applications  approximation  arrows  article  ascetic  asia  atoms  axelrod  bayesian  behavioral-econ  behavioral-gen  benchmarks  big-picture  big-surf  bio  biodet  bioinformatics  bits  books  bounded-cognition  broad-econ  calculation  characterization  charity  chart  checklists  china  christianity  clever-rats  coarse-fine  cohesion  commentary  competition  composition-decomposition  compressed-sensing  compression  concentration-of-measure  concept  conceptual-vocab  confluence  conquest-empire  convexity-curvature  cooperate-defect  coordination  cost-benefit  cultural-dynamics  curvature  cybernetics  darwinian  data  data-science  debate  decentralized  decision-making  decision-theory  deep-learning  deep-materialism  deepgoog  density  detail-architecture  differential  dimensionality  discrete  discussion  distribution  diversity  domestication  early-modern  ecology  economics  eden  EEA  egalitarianism-hierarchy  EGT  elite  emotion  ends-means  enhancement  entropy-like  envy  equilibrium  estimate  europe  evolution  evopsych  examples  expectancy  experiment  expert  expert-experience  explanans  explanation  exposition  extrema  faq  farmers-and-foragers  finance  finiteness  flexibility  formal-values  fourier  free-riding  frontier  game-theory  GCTA  generalization  generative  genetics  genomics  giants  gnon  gnosis-logos  government  gowers  gradient-descent  graph-theory  graphical-models  graphs  group-selection  GT-101  guilt-shame  GWAS  gwern  hari-seldon  hashing  heavyweights  henrich  heterodox  hi-order-bits  history  hmm  homogeneity  honor  hsu  ideas  ideology  IEEE  iidness  illusion  impact  incentives  individualism-collectivism  industrial-revolution  info-dynamics  information-theory  insight  integral  intelligence  interdisciplinary  interests  intersection-connectedness  intricacy  investing  iron-age  israel  iteration-recursion  justice  knowledge  latent-variables  learning-theory  lecture-notes  levers  leviathan  lifts-projections  linear-algebra  linear-models  linearity  liner-notes  list  local-global  long-short-run  love-hate  machine-learning  magnitude  manifolds  market-failure  markets  markov  martingale  math  math.CA  math.CO  math.GN  mathtariat  measure  medieval  mediterranean  mental-math  meta:math  meta:rhetoric  metabuch  metameta  methodology  metric-space  model-class  models  monte-carlo  motivation  multi  n-factor  neuro  new-religion  news  nibble  nietzschean  nitty-gritty  noblesse-oblige  norms  number  occident  off-convex  optimization  order-disorder  orders  ORFE  org:bleg  org:edge  org:inst  org:mag  org:nat  org:sci  organizing  orient  outliers  overflow  p:***  PAC  papers  parasites-microbiome  patho-altruism  pdf  peace-violence  pessimism  phase-transition  philosophy  photography  physics  pigeonhole-markov  piracy  popsci  population  population-genetics  pragmatic  pre-2013  preimage  preprint  prioritizing  probability  problem-solving  prudence  public-goodish  putnam-like  puzzles  q-n-a  quantum  quixotic  random  ratty  reduction  reference  regression  regularization  reinforcement  religion  reputation  research  research-program  retention  rigor  ritual  roadmap  robust  roots  rot  s:**  s:***  sapiens  scale  scaling-up  scholar-pack  science  scitariat  selection  self-interest  sequential  series  shannon  signal-noise  signaling  similarity  simplex  sinosphere  skeleton  smoothness  social-norms  social-science  sociality  sociology  soft-question  sparsity  spearhead  spectral  speculation  speedometer  spock  stanford  stats  stochastic-processes  strategy  street-fighting  study  studying  stylized-facts  summary  synthesis  tails  talks  tcs  telos-atelos  the-basilisk  the-classics  the-great-west-whale  the-trenches  the-watchers  theory-practice  theos  tidbits  tightness  time  toolkit  top-n  topology  track-record  tribalism  tricki  trust  truth  unit  us-them  valiant  vampire-squid  video  visualization  volo-avolo  war  westminster  wiki  wild-ideas  yoga  zero-positive-sum  🌞  🎓  👳  🔬 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: