davebriggs + report   15

MPs get in a funk over open source
The Conservative's open source technology strategy may have reached its culmination at a low water mark with the coalition government's renegotiated contract with Computer Sciences Corporation.Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude and chancellor George Osborne presented open source software as the antidote to the Labour government's "catastrophic" NHS National Programme for IT - and a recipe for cheaper and less botched government computing all round - when they launched their technology strategy in 2009.Now four years on, what they have done instead is reconfirm £2bn the £2.9bn contract CSC originally signed under Labour, and dropped that bit of it that would have given them the means to open source the goods.But the original Conservative tech policy was floated on a stream of opportunistic press leaks and anchored with a fishy tie-in with the then Conservative Parliamentary Public Accounts Committee chair Edward Leigh.The coalition government's lack of progress since raises questions about whether it is prepared to put its weight behind the policy.SpinA party insider told Computer Weekly the NHS element
of Conservative open source policy was spun to latch on to then current
news about NPfIT - the National Programme, Labour's NHSIT disaster.Osborne floated his open source policy on 27 January 2009, the same day the Public Accounts Committee published a report warning NPfIT wouldn't be delivered till 2015, four years late and at a cost of £12.7bn, because of BT and CSC in particular.The weekend before the Public Accounts Committee released its report, Osborne's team did a last minute edit of his unpublished 2007 open source policy backgrounder.The day the committee report came out, Osborne leaked his backgrounder to the tech press.It had in fact been gathering dust in Osborne's draw for nearly two years. It was now unofficial Conservative policy: open source software would cut IT costs and "free government bodies from long-term, monopoly supply situations" such as its NPfIT contracts with BT and CSC.A week later, The Times newspaper and Computer Weekly scooped the nethermost reserves of poop from the bottom of the Conservative policy headquarters' mudslinging barrel and slung them right in the then Labour government's bullseye.It was a big bullseye. IT bodges had been par for the course since Labour took office in 1997.The Times' had done an exclusive investigation of government IT bodges. But it was old news. The paper had dug right down into the archives, dragged up a clutch of rotten old IT bodges and slapped them up as an exclusive investigation.OutrageLeigh was so gullibly outraged he told The Times: "As a result of The Times' investigation I am going to immediately ask the Comptroller and Auditor-General [the head of the NAO] to investigate the whole matter of government IT spending and in particular the contracts highlighted in the paper."The old dog must have had a short memory, because he forgot to mention he had already handled most of these IT bodges as chair of the Public Accounts Committee. And that's how The Times and Computer Weekly new about them in the first place.The Times' investigation, published on 2 February, involved simply taking a bunch of old stories about IT budget over-runs and adding up the numbers. It said the total cost of Labour IT budget over-runs was over £18bn.But £10bn of that came from the NPfIT cost over-run the NAO recorded in a report it had submitted to Leigh's committee three years before, in 2006. The NAO reviewed the situation again in May 2008 and stuck it in another report to Leigh's committee. After conducting its usual hearings into the 2008 NAO report, the committee then produced its usual report about the NAO report. That's the report the committee had published on 27 January - one that Leigh had been talking about in all the papers.Now a week later, he was calling for the NAO to produce a report about The Times' report about his committee's report about the NAO report about NPfIT, as though it was the first he had heard of it. It was an outrage. It really was.More outrageMost of the rest of The Times' £18bn budget over-runs had come from HMRC's Aspire contract with Capgemini. The NAO had reported on this one in 2007. So had Leigh's Committee. So had the press.Leigh had said in a 2007 committee press statement "the forecast figure is some £8.5 billion...compared with the original estimate of nearly £3 billion". Now two years on, The Times had reported it again. Leigh was outraged.And most of the rest of The Times' £18bn came from the publication just 18 days before of Leigh's own committee report into the Ministry of Defence's Defence Information Infrastructure. That was about £5bn over-budget - a terrible state of affairs, really. But The Times' had learned about it from Leigh's committee, and they had both got it from the NAO about six months before. Now The Times was regurgitating it again, and Leigh was outraged like it was the first he'd heard of it.Most of the rest of the £18bn came from Leigh's Committee's 2003 report into the Courts Service Libra project. Libra's cost had more than doubled to £400m, said Leigh in 2003, drawing from NAO numbers given him earlier. The cost had more than doubled to £500m, said The Times in January 2009, drawing from Leigh's earlier work. Leigh was outraged.The rest of The Times' investigation regurgitated old news about three cancellations: a DWP benefits processing system from 2006, and police and passport websites from 2007. Ah and there was the National Offender Management Information System - then still work-in-progress for the NAO. Leigh was outraged.InvestigationLeigh was so forgetful that no sooner had he called for an NAO investigation of The Times' investigation of the committee report on the NAO report than the whole idea of an NAO investigation was forgotten, like it had never even been officially proposed at all.It hadn't. The NAO recorded no official request from Leigh for such an investigation. The NAO in fact never conducts general studies. So it says. So Leigh's committee would have been surprised if the NAO had done a general report into government IT bodges, because it has for the last 30 years worked to a Standing Order by which it examines about 40 of those non-general NAO reports every year.This was all nevertheless important enough for Osborne to pitch in with a commentary in The Times on 3 February.Osborne said: "Yesterday's report in The Times that government...IT is running nearly £19 billion over budget was genuinely shocking".It seemed nobody had read any of Leigh's old committee reports. Or they were so far back on his shelf that everyone else had forgotten about them as well.But at least Osborne had an answer to this old problem that he had known nothing of till The Times regurgitated it.The solution, he said, was to stop handing out big IT contracts to the same old big suppliers and break them up into manageable chunks using open source software and open standards. Maude, then head of the Conservative Party's Implementation Unit, was to lead the work.Now nearly four years on, the coalition government has still to reach a significant milestone on either its open source or open standards policies.The big departments of state have continued to sign large contracts with the same old large suppliers. The same old large suppliers have opposed the coalition's open source and open standards policies, just as they oppose the contract transparency the coalition government promised as well.The Tory top team may have been so desperate to put nails in Labour's coffin in 2009 that it would have said anything to get the vote - even that it would use open source software. The two parties were clambering over one another to make the most convincing noises about IT bodges. Labour's own open source policy had been gathering dust for years.
Government_IT  ICT_Oligopoly  Open_Standards_&_Open_Source  politics  project_failures  aspire  benefitsprocessingsystem  bt  cabinetoffice  cabinetofficeictstrategy  chair  chancellor  coalitiongovernment  comptrollerandauditorgeneral  computersciencescorporation  conservativetechnologymanifesto  conservativetechnologystrategy  csc  defenceinformationinfrastructure  departmentforworkpensions  dii  dwp  edwardleigh  exclusive  francismaude  georgeosborne  hmrc  ictoligopoly  ictstrategy  intellectualproperty  investigation  itbodges  ministryofdefence  nao  nationalauditoffice  nationaloffendermanagementinformationsystem  nhsnationalprogrammeforit  nhsit  nomis  npfit  opensource  openstandards  pac  policy  poopscoop  publicaccountscommittee  report  thetimes  from google
october 2012 by davebriggs
Evolving Digital Engagement - From Participation to Partnership
"This report reviews the background and context for digital engagement, with a focus on the shifting social and media landscape and the potential for more radical forms of policy development."
digitalengagement  guide  report 
june 2012 by davebriggs
The Fate of the Semantic Web
"While many survey participants noted that current and emerging technologies are being leveraged toward positive web evolution in regard to linking data, there was no consensus on the technical mechanisms and human actions that might lead to the next wave of improvements – nor how extensive the changes might be."
future  internet  report  semanticweb  opendata  semantic  TimBernersLee  pewinternet  research 
may 2010 by davebriggs
Embracing Government 2.0: Leading transformative change in the public sector (PDF)
PDF warning! Link to paper from Grant Thornton on gov 2.0 - some interesting case studies.
gov  gov2.0  government  government2.0  report  whitepaper  casestudies 
march 2010 by davebriggs
MINDSPACE: Influencing behaviour through public policy - Institute for Government
"Influencing behaviour through public policy explores how behaviour change theory can help meet current policy challenges, such as how to reduce crime, tackle obesity, or ensure environmental sustainability."
marketing  policy  report  behaviour  culture  change 
march 2010 by davebriggs
Carnegie UK Trust - Democracy & Civil Society - Making good society
"Making good society, the final report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Future of Civil Society, argues that civil society has been pushed to the margins in key areas including politics, finance and the media and that this must change."
civilsociety  civic  society  politics  news  democracy  carnegietrust  report  pdf 
march 2010 by davebriggs
Engage: Getting on with Government 2.0: Draft report for comment | Government 2.0 Taskforce
"Here is the draft Government 2.0 Taskforce report Engage: Getting on with Government 2.0. The Taskforce is seeking your comments and input before finalising the report to go to Government."
gov2.0  report  australia  government2.0  government  taskforce 
december 2009 by davebriggs
Does Directgov Deliver?
Consumer Focus Lab's commentariat site asking for views on DirectGov
egov  government  report  whitepaper  gov2.0  service  uk  commentariat  wordpress  lesteph  directgov 
december 2009 by davebriggs
Research report — Media Trust
"A major piece of research, commissioned by Media Trust, reveals there is an opportunity for Community Voices to add real value to current media activities within disadvantaged and isolated communities."
hyperlocal  communities  digitalmentors  socialbysocial  research  report  pdf  download  mediatrust 
november 2009 by davebriggs
Using Technology to Move from e-Government to e-Governance
"In this report, the Accenture Institute for Health & Public Service Value explores the fundamental shift in how public service organizations are viewing and using technologies."
e-government  egov  technology  networking  egovernment  it  report  e-governance 
october 2009 by davebriggs
Instant mash: empowering communities through the web
"From virtual worlds, to CoPs and 'mash-ups' – Kent County Council is using all of these to promote knowledge management."
ideaperf  web2.0  idea  localgovernment  communities  km  localgovuk  report  secondlife  kent 
january 2009 by davebriggs
10 Best Intranets of 2009 (Jakob Nielsen's Alertbox)
"Intranets are getting more strategic, with increased collaboration support. Team size is growing by 12% per year, and platforms are becoming integrated, with a strong showing for SharePoint. Improving usability increased use by 106% on average. "
web2.0  web  technology  webdesign  usability  report  intranet  trends 
january 2009 by davebriggs
Digital Dialogues - Third Phase Report
Third and final report from the Digital Dialogues project
digitaldialogues  report  web  social_web  web2.0  socialmedia 
august 2008 by davebriggs

related tags

aspire  australia  behaviour  benefitsprocessingsystem  bt  buildingdemocracy  cabinetoffice  cabinetofficeictstrategy  carnegietrust  casestudies  chair  chancellor  change  civic  civilsociety  coalitiongovernment  commentariat  communities  comptrollerandauditorgeneral  computersciencescorporation  conservativetechnologymanifesto  conservativetechnologystrategy  csc  culture  defenceinformationinfrastructure  democracy  departmentforworkpensions  digitaldialogues  digitalengagement  digitalmentors  dii  directgov  dius  download  dwp  e-governance  e-government  edemocracy  edwardleigh  egov  egovernment  evaluation  event  exclusive  francismaude  future  georgeosborne  gov  gov2.0  government  government2.0  Government_IT  guide  hmrc  hyperlocal  ictoligopoly  ictstrategy  ICT_Oligopoly  idea  ideaperf  innovation  intellectualproperty  internet  intranet  investigation  it  itbodges  kent  km  lesteph  localgovernment  localgovuk  marketing  mediatrust  ministryofdefence  nao  nationalauditoffice  nationaloffendermanagementinformationsystem  networking  news  nhsit  nhsnationalprogrammeforit  nomis  npfit  opendata  opensource  openstandards  Open_Standards_&_Open_Source  pac  participation  pdf  pewinternet  policy  politics  poopscoop  project_failures  publicaccountscommittee  report  research  secondlife  semantic  semanticweb  service  social+media+game  socialbysocial  socialmedia  social_web  society  taskforce  technology  thetimes  TimBernersLee  trends  uk  ukyouthonline  unconference  usability  web  web2.0  webdesign  whitepaper  wordpress 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: