paradox   1843

« earlier    

My Favorite Paradox - ForrestTheWoods
A riveting tale of how good data can lead to bad decisions.
analytics  statistics  paradox  bigdata  bias  math  stats  simpsonsparadox 
20 days ago by stevesong
Gnamma #7 - The Teacher's Imposition
"The world is full of bad teaching. And somehow we all get on with it, of course.

Still, I have found it typical that people perk up when they think of their favorite, electrifying teachers. These are people we think about for the rest of our lives, largely because they inform our interests and ways of looking at the world (ontology, value systems, networked ideas, etc) at early ages. Let's talk about teachers, and I want to be clear: everyone directs teachable moments in life (especially guardians and managers). I'm referring to people in explicitly assigned roles to teach. (This thus puts these thoughts largely outside of the realm of unschooling [https://www.are.na/roberto-greco/unschooling ], I think, but I do not know enough to say—would love to understand more in this realm.)

"Why Education is so Difficult And Contentious" [https://www.sfu.ca/~egan/Difficult-article.html ]: TL;DR because when we say education we mean indoctrination, and everybody—teacher, parent, politician, etc—has different opinions on how people should be. It's touchy to talk about forced indoctrination because it both engenders fascism and is the founding idea behind of public education. There are obviously gradients of imposition on the student. Illich supports the need for the pedagogue to connect student to resources, but not much more—a fairly "hands-off" view of the teacher by today's standards. Still, the connective moments are going to reflect the ideology of the pedagogue.

Are teachers necessary for learning? No. Learning is between the student and the world. A quippish phrase I heard a couple times working at RenArts [https://www.renarts.org/ ] was "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it think." But education (structured learning with others) requires teachers, basically by definition. Teachers "lead to water" and apply social pressure to encourage partaking.

What makes for a good teacher? Well, I maintain the chief goals of structured learning are to build agency and cultivate awareness in the student (and maybe share specific skillsets). So, what kind of teacher builds agency in the student and cultivates awareness to the extent possible? Some modes of teaching quickly follow: I believe the teacher needs to support open-ended, coherent, and honest activities.

Without open-ended-ness, we lose exploratory and self-actualizing potential. Without coherence, students can get mired in lack of knowing where to start or end (but a little ambiguity isn't bad). Without honesty we lose touch with the world and how to work with our lived realities. By "honesty" here, I mean to be honest about application of material, about history of thought, and about context of the activity itself; as such, the best teaching acknowledges and works with its own context (/media) and the needs of the people in the room.

I am trying to recall where I heard the phrase that "teaching is making space." The teachers frames the room, the activities, the needs, the expectations, the discussions. In doing so, they embed indoctrination into the teaching. In the effort of honesty in the classroom, these framing decisions needs to be made explicit for the students. The effective teacher must constantly wrestle with their internalized epistemologies and ego in seeking to constantly be aware of and share their own framings of the world. (When I ran a workshop for the Free School of Architecture in Summer 2018 on alternative learning communities, I mostly brought with me a long list of questions to answer [https://www.are.na/block/2440950 ] in seeking to understand how one is framing a learning space.)

This need for constant "pariefracture" (a breaking of the frame, expanding the conceptual realm, or meta-level "zooming out"—my friend D.V.'s term) in teaching gave me quite a bit of anxiety, as a teacher, until reading Parker J. Palmer's book "The Courage to Teach," in which he outlines six paradoxes of teaching. [https://www.are.na/block/1685043 and OCRed below ] I like these paradoxes in themselves, but the larger concept that resonated with me was the ability to treat a paradox not as a dead end (as one does in mathematics, generally) but rather as a challenge that can be pulled out and embraced as the dynamo of an ongoing practice. Teaching never resolves: you just wake up tomorrow and give it another shot.

I think what I'm circling around, here, is how much of learning from a teacher involves inheriting their ways of looking, concurrent with the teacher's ways of looking being in constant, self-aware flux. We inherit snapshots of our teachers' worldviews, blend them together over our own substrate of grokking the world, and call it education."

[From Parker J Palmer’s “The Courage to Teach”:

“When I design a classroom session, I am aware of six paradoxical tensions that I want to build into the teaching and learning space. These six are neither prescriptive nor exhaustive. They are simply mine, offered to illustrate how the principle of paradox might contribute to pedagogical design:

1. The space should be bounded and open.
2. The space should be hospitable and "charged."
3. The space should invite the voice of the individual and the voice of the group.
4. The space should honor the "little" stories of the students and the "big" stories of the disciplines and tradition.
5. The space should support solitude and surround it with the resources of community.
6. The space should welcome both silence and speech.

I want to say a few words about what each of these paradoxes means. Then, to rescue the paradoxes and the reader from death by abstraction, I want to explore some practical ways for classroom teachers to bring these idea to life.“
lukaswinklerprins  teaching  howweteach  parkerpalmer  education  paradox  2019  indoctrination  ivanillich  exploration  boundaries  openness  hospitality  individualism  collectivism  community  silence  speech  support  solitude  disciplines  tradition  personalization  unschooling  deschooling  canon 
4 weeks ago by robertogreco
Beyond Bitcoin and Ethereum — a fairer and more just post-monetary sociopolitical economy | P2P Foundation
However, I would suggest that solidarity and sovereignty are two sides of the same coin – they mutually and dynamically ‘co-form’ and ‘in-form’ each other, and so co-evolve symbiotically.
holochain  paradox 
5 weeks ago by zryb
Has the ideas machine broken down?
Further piece critical of Gordon et al in The Economist.
breakthrough  paradox  rational 
7 weeks ago by michael.bhaskar
Jevons paradox - Wikipedia
In 1865, the English economist William Stanley Jevons observed that technological improvements that increased the efficiency of coal-use led to the increased consumption of coal in a wide range of industries.
paradox  wiki 
8 weeks ago by yufufi
Science of Science
Fortunato et al. Good view of advances in metaresearch, and also a view of how the complexity of science is making life very difficult.
breakthrough  paradox  science 
8 weeks ago by michael.bhaskar
Top 10 Archaelogy Discoveries of 2018
An outline of big finds that shows how things do keep happening.
breakthrough  paradox 
8 weeks ago by michael.bhaskar

« earlier    

related tags

*  1973  2016  2017  2019  algorithms  aliens  america  analytics  astronomy  attaq  authoritarianism  behavioral-gen  berkson  bias  bigdata  bike  biodet  birthday  bitcoin  blockchain  boundaries  breakthrough  canada-china_relations  canada  canon  capitalism  causality  china  china_rising  choice  choices  citations  civil-liberty  civilisation  ck2  collectivism  collision  communications  communism  community  comparison  complexity  conclusion  concurrency  conflict  context  contradiction  control  corporations  crisis  critical  cryptocurrency  cryptography  culture  deschooling  determinism  developing_countries  digihealth  direction  disciplines  discovery  dissent  doctor  doctorwho  eastern-europe  economics  editorials  education  egalitarianism-hierarchy  elasticsearch  energy  environmental-effects  ethereum  eu4  exploration  factionparadox  facts  fakes  fallacy  fermi  field-study  foreign_policy  form  free-speech  friendship  fusion  future  game-theory  games  government  gsg  guerrilla  haley  helmet  holochain  homo-hetero  hospitality  howto  howweteach  huawei  ideas  identity  income  index  indexing  individual  individualism  indoctrination  industrial  industry  information  innovation  inspection-paradox  inspection  institution  institutions  interesting  international  international_system  internationalrelations  internet  interpretation  intolerance  introduction  ivanillich  labor  law  left-wing  life  links  list  locking  logic  lukaswinklerprins  lyrics  massculture  material  math  mathematics  maths  medium  meng_wanzhou  monasticism  movies  multipolarity  natural-experiment  network  networks  nikki  nobel  nonindustrial  number  of  ontologicalsecurity  openness  org:nat  organisation  orwellian  overload  parkerpalmer  pdf  perception  personalization  phenomenon  philosophy  phys  pick  piracy  podemo  policy  polisci  politics  power  prediction  probability  problem  productivity  programming  q  quantum  r&d  rainydayfund  random  rational  relativistic  religion  reprisals  research  risk  rogue_actors  rome  s-factor  sample  sampling  science  security  self  semiotics  seti  sexy  shift  silence  silica  simpson's  simpsons  simpsonsparadox  slowdown  social-structure  society  sociology  solitude  song  speech  startups  state  statistics  stats  status  strategy  study  subject  support  teaching  team  tech  technology  thai  the  theory  thinking  threat  time  tolerence  tradition  u.s.-china_relations  umbertoeco  unschooling  variance-components  video  video_games  webb  wiki  wikipedia  wto 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: