education   422827

« earlier    

The Educational Tyranny of the Neurotypicals | WIRED
"Ben Draper, who runs the Macomber Center for Self Directed Learning, says that while the center is designed for all types of children, kids whose parents identify them as on the autism spectrum often thrive at the center when they’ve had difficulty in conventional schools. Ben is part of the so-called unschooling movement, which believes that not only should learning be self-directed, in fact we shouldn't even focus on guiding learning. Children will learn in the process of pursuing their passions, the reasoning goes, and so we just need to get out of their way, providing support as needed.

Many, of course, argue that such an approach is much too unstructured and verges on irresponsibility. In retrospect, though, I feel I certainly would have thrived on “unschooling.” In a recent paper, Ben and my colleague Andre Uhl, who first introduced me to unschooling, argue that it not only works for everyone, but that the current educational system, in addition to providing poor learning outcomes, impinges on the rights of children as individuals.

MIT is among a small number of institutions that, in the pre-internet era, provided a place for non-neurotypical types with extraordinary skills to gather and form community and culture. Even MIT, however, is still trying to improve to give these kids the diversity and flexibility they need, especially in our undergraduate program.

I'm not sure how I'd be diagnosed, but I was completely incapable of being traditionally educated. I love to learn, but I go about it almost exclusively through conversations and while working on projects. I somehow kludged together a world view and life with plenty of struggle, but also with many rewards. I recently wrote a PhD dissertation about my theory of the world and how I developed it. Not that anyone should generalize from my experience—one reader of my dissertation said that I’m so unusual, I should be considered a "human sub-species." While I take that as a compliment, I think there are others like me who weren’t as lucky and ended up going through the traditional system and mostly suffering rather than flourishing. In fact, most kids probably aren’t as lucky as me and while some types are more suited for success in the current configuration of society, a huge percentage of kids who fail in the current system have a tremendous amount to contribute that we aren’t tapping into.

In addition to equipping kids for basic literacy and civic engagement, industrial age schools were primarily focused on preparing kids to work in factories or perform repetitive white-collar jobs. It may have made sense to try to convert kids into (smart) robotlike individuals who could solve problems on standardized tests alone with no smartphone or the internet and just a No. 2 pencil. Sifting out non-neurotypical types or trying to remediate them with drugs or institutionalization may have seemed important for our industrial competitiveness. Also, the tools for instruction were also limited by the technology of the times. In a world where real robots are taking over many of those tasks, perhaps we need to embrace neurodiversity and encourage collaborative learning through passion, play, and projects, in other words, to start teaching kids to learn in ways that machines can’t. We can also use modern technology for connected learning that supports diverse interests and abilities and is integrated into our lives and communities of interest.

At the Media Lab, we have a research group called Lifelong Kindergarten, and the head of the group, Mitchel Resnick, recently wrote a book by the same name. The book is about the group’s research on creative learning and the four Ps—Passion, Peers, Projects, and Play. The group believes, as I do, that we learn best when we are pursuing our passion and working with others in a project-based environment with a playful approach. My memory of school was "no cheating,” “do your own work,” "focus on the textbook, not on your hobbies or your projects," and "there’s time to play at recess, be serious and study or you'll be shamed"—exactly the opposite of the four Ps.

Many mental health issues, I believe, are caused by trying to “fix” some type of neurodiversity or by simply being insensitive or inappropriate for the person. Many mental “illnesses” can be “cured” by providing the appropriate interface to learning, living, or interacting for that person focusing on the four Ps. My experience with the educational system, both as its subject and, now, as part of it, is not so unique. I believe, in fact, that at least the one-quarter of people who are diagnosed as somehow non-neurotypical struggle with the structure and the method of modern education. People who are wired differently should be able to think of themselves as the rule, not as an exception."
neurotypicals  neurodiversity  education  schools  schooling  learning  inequality  elitism  meritocracy  power  bias  diversity  autism  psychology  stevesilberman  schooliness  unschooling  deschooling  ronsuskind  mentalhealth  mitchresnick  mit  mitemedialab  medialab  lifelongkindergarten  teaching  howweteach  howwelearn  pedagogy  tyranny  2018  economics  labor  bendraper  flexibility  admissions  colleges  universities  joiito 
12 hours ago by robertogreco
The Real Enemy of Education Reform: It’s the Colleges, Stupid | The New Republic
"Colleges do very well under the status quo. And that’s bad for students and our economy."

"Where is all this money going? Many point to the rise of university administrator salaries and staffs. (You might know them as the college presidents complaining about all these changes Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama want to make to the higher education system.) Another possible culprit is bloated construction costs, which go toward building show palaces for…well, for the administrators to crow about, and attract more students to pay those high tuition rates.

Whatever explanation appeals to you, the failures of the current system point clearly toward supplying a public debt-free option as a way to drive down costs. This would provide an anchor against skyrocketing costs, and force the cleanup of administrative bloat and unnecessary construction spending. You can force public colleges to lower costs as a condition of accepting tuition reimbursement. And if a glut of student loans causes prices to rise, then a free public option would reverse the effect.

This goes back to the core issue: Incumbents prospering from a system don’t have much interest in seeing it change. And those wanting to reform the system must challenge those incumbents. It’s easier to single out the easy villains, the Sallie Maes and the Corinthian Colleges. But that just sidesteps the real opponent, and will lead to something far less than reform.

Most colleges are seen in a fairly benevolent light. Large higher-education institutions are often major employers in their communities. They drive innovation, and provide sanctuary to some of our best thinkers. And for many adults, they are wrapped in the warm and fuzzy gauze of nostalgia. It’s hard to get people to see them as propping up a crisis that is over-burdening students and even stunting the growth of our economy. But until we do, it’s going to be very difficult to see any change."
colleges  universities  education  schools  schooling  deschooling  unschooling  hierarchy  inequality  economics  capitalism  elitism  highered  highereducation 
12 hours ago by robertogreco
We can’t educate our kids out of inequality | The Outline
"Those who tout the advantages of a good education like to conjure an image of some future society full of educated professionals all working stable, fulfilling, and salaried jobs. But even the worst students can look around the world and see through this. They can see the economic instability facing most people, and they know that a good education won’t undo the vagaries of the gig economy, or replace the protections of a union. But, they’re told, if you do well enough in school, then hopefully you won’t have to worry about that stuff.

This false promise was more disheartening that any other realization I had while working with students. Unfair tests, confusing admissions policies, unequal schools — all that is bad but sadly unsurprising, so you can prepare yourself for it. On the other hand, I was not prepared to lie to students about how, if they just figured out trig functions, then everything would be OK.

Education fetishism gives the illusion of fairness to society’s inequalities. Grades and test scores and college rankings mirror the stratification of the economy, and apply a thin veneer of meritocracy to that hierarchy. What students internalize about school is that it is primarily about ranking people. So attempts to improve education are really attempts to make those rankings more accurate, instead of making them less determinative. As long as this is true, then education is not really the solution to society’s problems. Even bold steps to improve schools and bring down college costs will not fix the problem of inequality, since status and sorting are also the results of education in America.

None of this is to say that education is bad or that schools should not be improved for their own sake. Learning things, after all, is fun. Education is great when it’s about teaching people stuff they want to know. But because school has to serve this burden of fixing social problems it is not equipped to fix, it cannot simply teach students interesting things they want to learn. Students should learn trig functions because they are an elegant solution to a complicated problem. They should read Hamlet because it’s a good play. They should learn things because there is value in learning them.

Instead, educators have to rend these subjects apart, breaking them into supposedly marketable skills like “reading comprehension” and “analytical reasoning” so that they can be used to demonstrate a student’s market value and justify patently unjust economic outcomes. As long as this is the case, then not only will inequality fail to get better, but education will continue to get worse. Instead of insisting we can educate ourselves out of the social problems capitalism creates, we should learn something new."
education  inequality  johnschneider  2018  schools  schooling  society  meritocracy  capitalism  gigeconomy  admissions  colleges  universities  grades  grading  hierarchy  sorting  learning  deschooling  economics  unions  socialsafetynet  testing  bias 
12 hours ago by robertogreco
Societies | Free Full-Text | Inequality Is a Problem of Inference: How People Solve the Social Puzzle of Unequal Outcomes
"A new wave of scholarship recognizes the importance of people’s understanding of inequality that underlies their political convictions, civic values, and policy views. Much less is known, however, about the sources of people’s different beliefs. I argue that scholarship is hampered by a lack of consensus regarding the conceptualization and measurement of inequality beliefs, in the absence of an organizing theory. To fill this gap, in this paper, I develop a framework for studying the social basis of people’s explanations for inequality. I propose that people observe unequal outcomes and must infer the invisible forces that brought these about, be they meritocratic or structural in nature. In making inferences about the causes of inequality, people draw on lessons from past experience and information about the world, both of which are biased and limited by their background, social networks, and the environments they have been exposed to. Looking at inequality beliefs through this lens allows for an investigation into the kinds of experiences and environments that are particularly salient in shaping people’s inferential accounts of inequality. Specifically, I make a case for investigating how socializing institutions such as schools and neighborhoods are “inferential spaces” that shape how children and young adults come to learn about their unequal society and their own place in it. I conclude by proposing testable hypotheses and implications for research."
inequality  meritocracy  2018  schooling  schools  education  unschooling  deschooling  democracy  neighborhoods  society  institutions  jonathanmijs 
12 hours ago by robertogreco
Травля не любит гласности. Как бороться с буллингом в школе и в стране: интервью с экспертом
Травля — это систематическое унижение, оскорбление, исключение из общения и физическое воздействие на человека группой лиц. Нам нужно, чтобы школа вошла с нами в единое информационное поле. Мы сейчас приходим и говорим: вот посмотрите,

это — травля, и ее начал ваш учитель! Вот этим своим «ой, а смотрите, Петров сегодня в класс пришел наконец вовремя, дети, давайте похлопаем Петрову!»

Это советское наследие в общении друг с другом часто дает свои ростки. Дети и молодые взрослые видят, что учитель в классе так себя ведет, и это моделирует их поведение.
school  education  psychology  talks 
17 hours ago by some_hren

« earlier    

related tags

!reviewmarker  /english  1  1918  1937  2005  2018  academia  academy  access  activism  admissions  advocacy  agriculture  agw  america  analytics  architecture  art  assault  assessment  audience  austerity  australia  autism  bauhaus  bendraper  bias  blackmountaincollege  blacksocialistsofamerica  blindingly_useful  book  books  boys  branding  bsa  callouts  capitalism  care  career  censorship  challenge  challenges  change  chicago  children  china  christianity  christofascism  climate  climatechange  code  coding  collectivism  colleges  communication  computer  consent_culture  content  cost  courses  creativity  crime  crisismanagement  crowdfunding  css  culture  cuts  darrylclifton  data  datadecisions  davidadams  dc:creator=youngegary  dctagged  democracy  denial  department  deschooling  design  dev  development  device  digitaldivide  disabilities  discrimination  diversity  drum  ecoliteracy  ecology  economics  ed  edu  educational_effects  educational_opportunity  ego  elitism  energy  environment  ethics  evangelical  exclusion  eye  facebook  facilitation  failure  feminism  flexibility  food  forex  free  fundamentalism  funding  funnel  futures  gaming  gap  gay  gender  germany  gift  gigeconomy  girls  global  government  grades  grading  graphidesign  grid  hackers  hardware  harvard  health  hierarchy  higher  highered  highereducation  history  hn  homeschool  howto  howwelearn  howweteach  hslda  hunt  hännahettinger  india  individualism  inequality  innoculationtheory  innovation  institutions  intel  interactive  internet  investing  javascript  jobs  johnschneider  joiito  jonathanmijs  josefalbers  jupyter  keyboard  kids  kieryndarkwater  korea  labor  language  languages  laser-cut  lcd  lcproject  leadership  learning  legal  lifelongkindergarten  linux  machinelearning  magufuli  manufacturing  marketing  maryloujepsen  math  mathematics  mechanics  medialab  mentalhealth  meritocracy  meshnetwork  mexico  mit  mitchresnick  mitemedialab  model  moma  money  mooc  moocs  motivational  music  neglect  neighborhoods  neoliberalism  netbook  neurodiversity  neurotypicals  nicolasnegroponte  nonprofit  notebooks  olpc  opensource  openstudioproject  operatingsystem  opposition  organizing  parenting  pdf  pedagogy  personalbranding  personalized  peru  phd  physics  piano  pixelqi  policy  politics  poverty  power  pregnancy  price  prison  privacy  probability  product  programming  projectmanagement  psychology  publicrelations  python  reading  reference  release  religion  report  research  resistance  response  retinal  return  rights  ronsuskind  rossgittins  sarcasm  school  schooliness  schooling  schools  science  screen  screens  screentime  send  sex  sexual  sexuality  sight  social  socialism  socialmedia  socialsafetynet  society  software  solidarity  sorting  southkorea  statistics  stats  stayathomedaughters  stevesilberman  stories  struggle  students  sugarlabs  swift  syllabus  systems  talks  tanzania  teaching  tech  technology  test  testing  time  todo  training  tribunals  trump  tution  tutorial  tw  twitter  tyranny  uk  uneducation  unions  universities  unknown_chemical  unschooling  us_va  vaporware  video  visual  visualization  vorkurs  vrandtruth18  waltergropius  web  webdesign  website  welfare  widows  women  work  world  world_bank  wtf  youth 

Copy this bookmark: