cv   11744

« earlier    

Children, Learning, and the Evaluative Gaze of School — Carol Black
"That's when I understood: when you watch a child who is focused on learning, and you let them know you’re watching, and you let them know your opinion as though your opinion matters, you just took that thing away from them. You just made it yours. Your smell is all over it now.

The evaluative gaze does the greatest harm, of course, to the kids who live under a biased eye; the ones who enter school with a test score or a disciplinary record or a skin color that shades the gaze against them. Once an assessment of a child's ability has been made, positive or negative, that child will feel it; if you think you can conceal it from them, you're wrong. They know. They always know. Studies have shown that even lab rats learn more slowly if their researchers believe that they aren't smart rats. The kids who grow up under a negative gaze, the ones who day after day, year after year, feel themselves appraised and found wanting –– these kids pay the greatest price, their psyches permanently damaged by it, their futures irrevocably harmed. (The fact that our appraisals are shown again and again to be wrong never seems to discourage us from making them.) But even the kids who get the good grades, the high scores, the perfect "10's" –– even they are subtly blighted by it. They've won the prize, and lost their power.

Why is it clear to us that it's degrading and objectifying to measure and rank a girl’s physical body on a numeric scale, but we think it’s perfectly okay to measure and rank her mind that way?

Over the years I've watched the many ways that children try to cope with the evaluative gaze of school. (The gaze, of course, can come from parents, too; just ask my kids.) Some children eagerly display themselves for it; some try to make themselves invisible to it. They fight, they flee, they freeze; like prey animals they let their bodies go limp and passive before it. Some defy it by laughing in its face, by acting up, clowning around, refusing to attend or engage, refusing to try so you can never say they failed. Some master the art of holding back that last 10%, of giving just enough of themselves to "succeed," but holding back enough that the gaze can't define them (they don't yet know that this strategy will define and limit their lives.) Some make themselves sick trying to meet or exceed the "standards" that it sets for them. Some simply vanish into those standards until they don't know who they would have been had the standards not been set.

But the power of the gaze goes beyond the numbers and letters used to quantify it. It exists in looks and tones and body language, in words and in the spaces between words. It is a way of looking at another human being, of confronting another human life; it is a philosophical stance, an emotional stance, a political stance, an exercise of power. As philosopher Martin Buber might have put it, the stance of true relationship says to the other, "I–Thou;" the evaluative gaze says "I–It." It says, "I am the subject; you are the object. I know what you are, I know what you should be, I know what 'standards' you must meet." It is a god-like stance, which is actually a big deal even if you think you are a fair and friendly god.

The evaluative gaze of school is so constant a presence, so all-pervasive an eye, that many people have come to believe that children would actually not grow and develop without it. They believe that without their "feedback," without their constant "assessment," a child's development would literally slow or even stop. They believe that children would not learn from the things they experience and do and see and hear and make and read and imagine unless they have an adult to "assess" them (or unless the adult teaches them to "self-assess," which generally means teaching them to internalize the adult gaze.) For people whose experience is with children inside the school system, it may seem self-evident that this is true. For people whose experience is with children outside the school system, it may seem like believing that an acorn would not grow into an oak tree unless you measure it and give it your opinion. Because an oak tree does not actually require your opinion, and believe it or not, 90% of the time, neither does a child.

A pot boils whether you watch it or not. It just needs water and fire.

There are ever-increasing numbers of people raising their kids outside this Panopticon of constant evaluation and measurement and feedback, and what they find is simply this: they grow and develop very much like other kids. Like other kids, they don't all conform to the same "standards;" like other kids, they are individual and diverse. Like other kids, they have triumphs, and struggles, and doldrums, and passions, and frustrations, and joys. "Assessment," or the lack of it, seems to have remarkably little to do with it. Because what an oak tree actually needs is not your opinion but soil and water and light and air, and what a child needs is love and stories and tools and conversation and support and guidance and access to nature and culture and the world. If a kid asks for your feedback, by all means you can give it; it would be impolite not to. But what we should be measuring and comparing is not our children but the quality of the learning environments we provide for them. "
carolblack  canon  unschooling  deschooling  evaluation  assessment  schools  schooling  schooliness  cv  petergray  judgement  writing  art  sfsh  rubrics  children  childhood  learning  howwelearn  education  discipline  coercion  rabindranathtagore  panopticon  observation  teaching  teachers  power  resistance  surveillance  martinbuber  gender  race  racism  measurement  comparison  praise  rewards  grades  grading  2018 
5 days ago by robertogreco
Through-Wall Human Pose Estimation Using Radio Signals
Through-Wall Human Pose Estimation Using Radio Signals
cv  vision  surveillance  walls  privacy  wifi  rf 
6 days ago by ivar
kelaberetiv/TagUI: CLI tool for automating user interactions (RPA)
TagUI is now maintained by AI Singapore (aisingapore.org), a government-funded initiative to build local artificial intelligence capabilities. The intention is to add AI capabilities to TagUI while keeping it open-source and free to use. To get started, check out above hands-on tutorial, Prezi slides, or recorded video at FOSSASIA 2018.
automation  cv  country:singapore  chrome  chrome-extensions 
7 days ago by Spark
Minimal Resume PSD Template Freebie - Download Photoshop Resource - PSD Repo
This free minimal resume psd template was designed and shared by Nicolas Meuzard. Nice work!
cv  **  design 
7 days ago by pokerone
Norman
サイコパスAI。こうやって画像認識に対して意図的に重み付けというかキャラをつくっていけるの面白いな。
ai  cv 
8 days ago by slnbookmark
Are we overthinking general education? – Jonathan D. Becker, J.D., Ph.D.
"Many colleges and universities are trying to figure out new ways to tackle general education requirements. My own employer, VCU, has been undergoing an effort “to re-imagine our general education curriculum.” The proposed framework that my VCU colleagues came up with isn’t bad, but it still feels like picking courses out of individual boxes and checking boxes to complete a checklist. It feels like what happens when universities try to be innovative and break out of boxes, but turf wars ensue and departments dig in their heels. The result is an overwrought compromise that doesn’t serve anyone particularly well.

Here is something I wrote on Twitter back in 2015.

[embedded tweet: https://twitter.com/jonbecker/status/670360697105174529
@gsiemens I seriously want to teach a course where all we do is read and discuss @brainpicker and @Longreads.
]

Imagine this learning experience: 1 faculty member with 20-25 students just reading and discussing the Longreads Weekly Top 5. They’d meet once a week, in a meeting room or a coffee shop or outside on a lawn or in the forest; it doesn’t matter. And they’d just talk about what they learned. And maybe they’d blog about it so they could expand their discussion beyond the designated class time and space and could get others outside the class to weigh in. That’s it; that’s the whole instructional design. No predetermined curriculum; very little by way of planning. Learning outcomes? How about curiosity, wonder, critical thinking? Those are your “learning outcomes.” I’d bet students would learn more by reading and deeply discussing those 5 articles each week than they would in most other tightly-designed, pre-packaged curriculum-driven course.

I would also love to involve students in a learning experience built around food shows like Alton Brown’s Good Eats. Seriously. Watch just the first few minutes of this episode. In just the first 3+ minutes, we get history (information about the Ottoman Empire), science (cooking and surface area), and math (computing surface area). In a show about kabobs.

[embedded video: "Good Eats S09E2 Dis-Kabob-Ulated"
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5skv9x ]

What if general education was more like this? What if students read Longreads and watched episodes of Good Eats as part of an effort around interdisciplinary studies?

And then there’s Anthony Bourdain. To me, Parts Unknown was, at its heart, educational media.

I’m not from West Virginia like Craig Calcaterra (see below) is. But, I spent a lot of time in that state doing field research at the end of the 20th century. When I watched the episode of Parts Unknown that Calcaterra shares, I felt like Bourdain had really captured what I had come to know about the state and then some. Watch the episode and tell me that you didn’t learn a ton. The way Bourdain juxtaposes New York City and his fellow New Yorkers with the “existential enemy” in West Virginia is classic Bourdain."

[embedded tweet: https://twitter.com/craigcalcaterra/status/1005077364131422208
Anthony Bourdain went to West Virginia last year. In one hour he did way better capturing my home state than 1,000 poverty porn tourist journalists with pre-written stories parachuting in from coastal publications have ever done. https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6inwh4
]

Parts Unknown is an interdisciplinary curriculum. It is about culture, food, history, politics, economics, etc. It’s about people.

[embedded tweet: https://twitter.com/ablington/status/1005056496609169409
Anthony Bourdain had one of the only shows on tv that tried with all its might to teach Americans not to be scared of other people.
]

And isn’t that what general education is?

Replace the word “travel” with the word “learning” in the following quote from Anthony Bourdain.

[embedded tweet: https://twitter.com/Tribeca/status/1005073364531269633
“Travel isn’t always pretty. It isn’t always comfortable. Sometimes it hurts, it even breaks your heart. But that’s okay. The journey changes you; it should change you... You take something with you. Hopefully, you leave something good behind.” — Anthony Bourdain #RIP
]

Maybe we’re overthinking general education in higher education. Probably, in fact.
jonbecker  education  generaleducation  anthonybourdain  2018  interdisciplinary  learning  travel  sharing  ideas  unschooling  deschooling  cv  culture  exploration  conversation  longreads  lcproject  openstudioproject  howweteach  howwelearn 
10 days ago by robertogreco

« earlier    

related tags

**  2017  2018  6  academic  accessory  adolescence  advice  ai  alexandralange  alextruesdell  algorithms  alphabetinc  animation  anthonybourdain  api  ar  arduino  are.na  art  articles  assessment  automation  autonomy  awesome  bash  benjamindoxtdator  benjaminspock  bibliography  biology  blog  bookmarking  bookmarks  books  boxes  busdev  c  caine'sarcade  cainmonroy  calculus  calibration  california  camera  canon  carbon  cardboard  career  carolblack  charleseames  childhood  children  choicetime  chrome-extensions  chrome  cnn  code  coercion  cognition  collaboration  collaborativeresearch  collectiveintelligence  colleges  comparison  computer-vision  computer  computervision  conditioning  conference  constructivism  conversation  cooking  country:singapore  creativity  cs  cuisine  culture  curiosity  data-analysis  data-mining  data-science  data  dataset  deeplearning  demo  democracy  dependency  deschooling  design  detection  diagram  directinstruction  disabilities  disability  discipline  ditm  diversity  diy  django  drones  dsipro2  eames  edenproject  education  egalitarianism  ego  elevator  engineering  eurorack  evaluation  example  executive  exploration  exposure  face  facebook  facial-recognition  facial  facialrecognition  figure  flux  forests  fortpj  freedom  friends  game  gamify  gender  generaleducation  github  google  gough  grades  grading  graph  graphcut  guides  hermanmiller  highered  highereducation  highschool  hiring  history  hn  howwelearn  howweteach  howwewrite  idea  ideas  illustration  image-processing  image  imageprocessing  imagination  information  interdisciplinary  interestedness  interestingness  interface  interview  interviewing  jacobsam-larose  jameshennessey  job  jobs  jonbecker  journal  judgement  k12  kateantonova  keras  kitchen  language  latex  law  lcproject  learning  lectures  libraries  library  light  listening  literature  longreads  machine-learning  machinelearning  makers  making  martinbuber  meaning  meaningmaking  measurement  midi  ml  morethanhuman  multispecies  nature  network  networking  neuralnet  neuralnets  neuralnetworks  nintendo  nn  notebook  novato  objectdetection  observation  oer  online  opencv  opensource  openstudioproject  panopticon  panorama  paper  papers  parenting  pdf  pedagogy  petergray  photography  pitch  plants  platform  pokemon  police  pony  pose  power  praise  privacy  problemsolving  programming  projector  projects  publication  publicgood  publicschools  puns  purpose  python  pytorch  qualities  qubes  rabindranathtagore  race  racism  raspberry  raspberrypi  rayeames  reading  rebeccasolnit  recognition  recruiter  recycling  research  resistance  resume  rewards  rf  richquick  rnn  robertgair  rubrics  sanctuary  schoolforpoeticcomputing  schooliness  schooling  schools  scribing  seconds  sensor  sequencer  sfpc  sfsh  sharing  singapore  six  skynet  slam  socialbookmaking  socialism  society  softwaredevelopment  stanford  statistics  stories  story  storytelling  submission  summary  surveillance  synth  table  taeyoonchoi  tcsnmy  teachers  teaching  technology  tensorflow  text  thoreau  tip  tosteal  travel  tutorial  tweet  uncertainty  universities  unknowing  unschooling  us  vanishing  victorpapanek  video  vision  visiual  walking  walls  wandering  web  website  whiteboard  wifi  wildlife  woods  work  writing  yolo  your  找工作 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: