commons   7094

« earlier    

The "Tragedy of the Commons" was invented by a white supremacist based on a false history, and it's toxic bullshit / Boing Boing
Hardin's paper starts with a history of the English Commons -- publicly held lands that were collectively owned and managed -- and the claim that commons routinely fell prey to the selfish human impulse to overgraze your livestock on public land (and that even non-selfish people would overgraze their animals because they knew that their more-selfish neighbors would do so even if they didn't).

But this isn't what actually happened to the Commons: they were stable and well-managed until other factors (e.g. rich people trying to acquire even more land) destabilized them.

Hardin wasn't just inventing false histories out of a vacuum. He was, personally, a nasty piece of work: a white supremacist and eugenicist, and the Tragedy of the Commons paper is shot through with this vile ideology, arguing that poor people should not be given charity lest they breed beyond their means (Hardin also campaigned against food aid). Hardin was a director of the Federation for American Immigration Reform and the white nationalist Social Contract Press, and co-founded anti-immigrant groups like Californians for Population Stabilization and The Environmental Fund.
commons  capitalism  racism  garrett-hardin  tragedy-of-the-commons  politics  privatization  public-ownership 
10 days ago by jm
mattomildenberger on Twitter: "Something I've been meaning to say about The Tragedy of the Commons. Bear with me for a small thread on why our embrace of Hardin is a stain on environmentalism. tldr: we’ve let a flawed metaphor by a racist ecologist defi
Something I've been meaning to say about The Tragedy of the Commons. Bear with me for a small thread on why our embrace of Hardin is a stain on environmentalism. tldr: we’ve let a flawed metaphor by a racist ecologist define environmental thinking for a half century.
weekly  twitter  commons  economics 
13 days ago by twwoodward
mattomildenberger on Twitter: "Something I've been meaning to say about The Tragedy of the Commons. Bear with me for a small thread on why our embrace of Hardin is a stain on environmentalism. tldr: we’ve let a flawed metaphor by a racist ecologist defi
[via: "The concept of 'the tragedy of the commons' "is not a legacy based on empirical scholarship, but on a metaphor that doesn't quite hold water."
t h r e a d"
https://twitter.com/hautepop/status/1102903178901766144 ]

[also here: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1102604887223750657.html ]

"Something I've been meaning to say about The Tragedy of the Commons. Bear with me for a small thread on why our embrace of Hardin is a stain on environmentalism. tldr: we’ve let a flawed metaphor by a racist ecologist define environmental thinking for a half century. 1/

Hardin’s article, published in Science, turned 50 this past December. Since then, tens of millions of students have been taught its core message. Every individual seeks to exploit the commons. In doing so they unsustainably overuse our shared resources to the ruin of all. 2/

Google Scholar gives me a current citation count of 38730 (!). Most articles on environmental politics use the phrase at some point or another. It has permeated our lexicon like few other concepts. Here is the original Science essay, btw: http://science.sciencemag.org/content/162/3859/1243
3/

(Side note: Hardin’s piece actually drew on a much earlier 1833 pamphlet by William Forster Lloyd about the dangers of overgrazing the English countryside. Worth a read for those so inclined: https://www.jstor.org/stable/1972412?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents ) 4/

That this metaphor offers some essential insight is taken for granted. A generation of scholarship builds on its back, including in political science and economics. But does it? That's much less clear. 5/

As Susan Cox points out, British commons were exclusive to a defined set of individuals + this use itself was regulated. Commons as an institution worked but were undermined by other factors, including the efforts by the rich to accumulate more land http://dlc.dlib.indiana.edu/dlc/bitstream/handle/10535/3113/buck_NoTragedy.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y 6/

So the metaphor is not actually grounded in an empirically accurate representation of the commons. Other scholars have more strongly contested the logic of Hardin's argument. These range from friendly amendments (Ostrom) to wholesale critiques. 7/

This would all be an academic argument if not for the intellectual roots of Hardin's metaphor and thinking - roots that too few environmentalists acknowledge. 8/

Hardin wasn't a social scientist or on an expert on social organization. Instead, he was a Human Ecology prof at UC Santa Barbara (my home institution) where he taught until his 1978 retirement. (Morbid side note: he and his wife killed themselves in a 2003 suicide pact.) 9/

Have you read Hardin's Science essay lately? It's a mind-numbingly racist piece. And not in a subtle way that demands 2019 woke analysis. Spend the 20 minutes and do it. It’s an ethical mess from beginning to end. 10/
There are headings like “Freedom to Breed is Intolerable”, under which Hardin imagines the benefits that might accrue if “children of improvident parents starve to death”, an outcome stymied (a bad thing to him), by the welfare state. 11/

[image]

For these reasons, he campaigned against such programs as Food for Peace. A few paragraphs later: “If we love the truth we must openly deny the validity of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” I think you get the idea. 12/

And this is par for the course for Hardin, who was also a passionate eugenicist. Oh hey! Look who is classified by the Southern Poverty Law Center as a known white nationalist: https://www.splcenter.org/fighting-hate/extremist-files/individual/garrett-hardin 13/

Lets quote the SPLC: 14/

SPLC has painful quotes from his later work. “Diversity is the opposite of unity, and unity is a prime requirement for national survival” (1991). “My position is that this idea of a multiethnic society is a disaster…we should restrict immigration for that reason.” (1996) 15/

And here is another one, again as an image because, no thanks do I want my twitter history to pop up when people search these things. 16/ [image]

And here is Hardin making an appearance in the infamous racist “Mainstream Science on Intelligence” op-ed. I could go on (and the SPLC does), but you get the idea. http://www.intelligence.martinsewell.com/Gottfredson1997.pdf 17/

Fast forward. Probably you’ve read articles on the intellectual network behind Trump’s nativist, racist demagoguery. Many mention the very influential anti-immigration activist John Tanton, and his Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR): https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2018/09/27/shadowy-network-shaping-trumps-anti-immigration-policies/
18/

And who was on FAIR’s board, and a close friend of Tanton? Yep, Hardin. https://www.splcenter.org/fighting-hate/extremist-files/group/federation-american-immigration-reform 19/

In my mind, it’s not that Hardin WOULD HAVE been a Trumper. It's that he WAS a Trumper before Trump was a Trumper. He helped build the entire intellectual movement Trump has since exploited. 20/

Now, lots of awful people have left noble ideas that outlive them. But in Hardin’s case, the intellectual legacy is largely built on top of his racist, flawed Science that we still treat as gospel and uncritically assign in undergraduate courses year after year. 21/

It is not a legacy based on empirical scholarship, but on a metaphor that doesn't quite hold water. Not that you would know any of this from the anodyne retrospectives that have sprouted up in the last several months celebrating his article's 50th anniversary. 22/

Fifty years later, the environment community needs to stop ignoring this dark intellectual heritage. A movement that seeks to define a just, vibrant climate future needs to tear away the veneer, and choose what of Hardin to keep and what to discard. 23/

We must ask: on what empirical basis do we accept his metaphor? How do we teach his metaphor? Do we contextualize its racist roots? Is it productive to the social transformation necessary to save the world from the climate crisis? 24/

Not undertaking this honest examination will perpetuate its own (common) tragedy and make our intellectual heritage a form of unwitting support for some of the ugliest social forces at play in the world today. 25/25"
mattmildenberger  garrethardin  2019  en  commons  eugenics  diversity  racism  race  tragedyofthecommons  nativism  immigration  population  science 
15 days ago by robertogreco
Twitter
The within & media studies has been theorized as an alternative capitalist productive & soc…
communication  commons  from twitter_favs
21 days ago by freerange_inc

« earlier    

related tags

2015  2017  2018  2019  aaronswartz  access  accounting  acequia  aclu  administration  advertising  affairs  agent-based  alternative  analysis  analytica  analytics  and  another  anthropology  aop  api  arent  arron  art  banks  benedictoption  bercow  bitcoin  blockchain  blocks  boingboing  books  botany  brexit  business-model  business  cambridge  capitalism  cc0  chicago  cities  city.planning  civil+liberties  civil+rights  cleveland  clippings  coin  collaboration  collection  commentary  committee  communication  communities  community  compare  content  cooperation  copyleft  copyright  corruption  creative-commons  creative-entrepreneurship  creative  creative_commons  creativecommons  criticism  crowdfunding  crowdsourcing  crypto  cryptocurrency  culture  custodian  data  debate  debunk  decentralization  decentralized  decolonization  definition  democracy  deschooling  design  development  diversity  dlt  document  domain  donald  donation  donations  dvcs  economics  economy  ecosystem  education.resources  education  elections  elsevier  en  equality  ethereum  eugenics  evolution  evolutionary-economics  feminism  fiber  fibre  finance  flickr  food  foodcommons  ford  foundation  free  freedom  freeriders  fun  funding  fundraising  future  game-theory  game  games  gametheory  garrethardin  garrett-hardin  git  glam  global  google  governance  government  grants  graphs  greatlakes  happiness  hardin  higher_education  highered  hilder  history  homeschool  house  human+rights  human  hygge  idea  ideas  ifttt  image  images  immigration  indigenous  individualism  inequality  information  infosec  infrastructure  intellectualproperty  internal+revenue+service  internet.of.shit  internet  investigative+journalism  irs  japan  john  johndewey  journalism  knowledge  lang-en  law  learning  legal  legislation  letters  liberitiesrights  libertiesrights  library  licence  linux  london  magazine  mapa  mapping  mattmildenberger  may's  media  members  mercer  mt  municipal  museum  mw2015  nativism  network  networkedsociety  networks  news  nigeria  nonprofit  oer  of  on  online  open-education  open_access  open_source  open_source_software  openaccess  opencontent  opendemocracy  openknowledge  openscience  opensource  openstreetmap  optic  ostrom  p2p  parliament  patents  patreon  paul  payment  paywall  photo  photography  photopin  photos  plan  plants  platform  pluralism  pm  pocket  podcasts  policy  politics  population  power  print  privacy  private  privatization  profit  public+spaces  public-ownership  public.spaces  public  public_media  publicdomain  publicgood  publishing  punk-patronage  race  racism  radlib  reference  reform  relations  research  resilience  revenue  review  rijksmuseum  roddreher  royalty  schooling  schools  science  scuttlebutt  search  security  self-reliance  service  slideshare  smalltalk  smart.cities  social  social_networks  society  sociology  software  speaker  splash  spreadsheet  states  steve  story  surveillance  sustainability  system  taxes  te_papa  teaching  technology  the  theft  theresa  timcarmody  to-write-about  to_listen  tobago  tooled  tradegy  tragedy-of-the-commons  tragedy  tragedyofthecommons  trinidad  trump  twitter  uk  united  unschooling  utopia  value  visualization  vote  wales  walled.gardens  watchlist  wb  web  weekly  westminster  white_supremacy  wikimedia-commons  wikimedia  wikipedia  woodblock  world  writing  xenofeminism  zdjęcia 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: