carmack   411

« earlier    

Working fewer hours would make us more productive | Hacker News
I find these “shorter work weeks are just as effective” articles to be nonsense, at least for knowledge workers with some tactical discretion. I can imagine productivity at an assembly line job having a peak such that overworking grinds someone down to the point that they become a liability, but people that claim working nine hours in a day instead of eight gives no (or negative) additional benefit are either being disingenuous or just have terrible work habits. Even in menial jobs, it is sort of insulting – “Hey you, working three jobs to feed your family! Half of the time you are working is actually of negative value so you don’t deserve to be paid for it!”
If you only have seven good hours a day in you, does that mean the rest of the day that you spend with your family, reading, exercising at the gym, or whatever other virtuous activity you would be spending your time on, are all done poorly? No, it just means that focusing on a single thing for an extended period of time is challenging.

Whatever the grand strategy for success is, it gets broken down into lots of smaller tasks. When you hit a wall on one task, you could say “that’s it, I’m done for the day” and head home, or you could switch over to something else that has a different rhythm and get more accomplished. Even when you are clearly not at your peak, there is always plenty to do that doesn’t require your best, and it would actually be a waste to spend your best time on it. You can also “go to the gym” for your work by studying, exploring, and experimenting, spending more hours in service to the goal.

I think most people excited by these articles are confusing not being aligned with their job’s goals with questions of effectiveness. If you don’t want to work, and don’t really care about your work, less hours for the same pay sounds great! If you personally care about what you are doing, you don’t stop at 40 hours a week because you think it is optimal for the work, but rather because you are balancing it against something else that you find equally important. Which is fine.

Given two equally talented people, the one that pursues a goal obsessively, for well over 40 hours a week, is going to achieve more. They might be less happy and healthy, but I’m not even sure about that. Obsession can be rather fulfilling, although probably not across an entire lifetime.

This particular article does touch on a goal that isn’t usually explicitly stated: it would make the world “less unequal” if everyone was prevented from working longer hours. Yes, it would, but I am deeply appalled at the thought of trading away individual freedom of action and additional value in the world for that goal.
carmack  productivity 
9 weeks ago by vivitsu

« earlier    

related tags

2015  2016  2017-03-10  2017-03-11  360  ability-competence  achievement  advice  algorithm  algorithms  analysis  android  antifragile  api  apple  approximation  architecture  art  article  atoms  best-practices  bitcoin  blockchain  blog  book  build  c++  c  children  code  codec  coding  comment  commentary  comparison  comphist  compsci  computers  concurrency  contrarianism  cool  correlation  craft  critique  crypto  cryptocurrency  cs  cto  dan-luu  danluu  data  decentralized  degrees-of-freedom  dev  development  devops  devtools  discipline  discovery  distributed  doom  elegance  email  empirical  empty  engineering  environment  error  estimating  evidence-based  expert-experience  explanation  fast-inverse-sqrt  focus  for  formal-methods  fp  fps  free  frontier  functional  game  gamedev  gameprogramming  games  gaming  genius  goodstuff  gpu  graphics  gwern  hacker  hackernews  hashing  haskell  history  hmm  hn  hsitory  id  ideas  improvement  inline  inlined  innovation  inspiration  interesting  internet  interview  inverse  iphone  java  javascript  jobs  john  latency  learning  legend  len:short  lighting  links  lisp  list  local-global  mastery  math  metrics  microsoft  minecraft  minimum-viable  mobile  mostly-modern  netflix  network-structure  networking  neural-network  novelty  null-result  occulus  oculus  opengl  p2p  parenting  paste  pc  pdf  people  performance  physics  plan-file  plan  pls  plt  postmortem  pragmatic  presentation  productivity  programming  project  protocol  prototyping  quake  quotes  racket  ratty  reflection  regularizer  rendering  replication  repo  rhapsody  rhetoric  rigorous-crypto  roots  scaling-tech  scheme  science  security  server  shadow-volumes  shadows  shipping  slashdot  software  spj  sqrt  state  static  staticanalysis  steve_jobs  stories  strategy  stream  study  style  summary  system-design  system  systems  szabo  tech  technique  techtariat  tradeoffs  trivia  twitter  video-games  video  virtualreality  vr  vrscript  web  wisdom  wiz  wolfenstein  working-stiff  worrydream  zenimax  🖥 

Copy this bookmark: