border   4680

« earlier    

‘With or Without You’: Naturalising Migrants and the Never-Ending Tragedy of Liberalism | Salvage
"To be homeless is to be nameless. He. The existence of a migrant worker.

John Berger

*

The One Day Without Us campaign was launched in the UK in October 2016 ‘in reaction to the rising tide of post-Brexit street- level racism and xenophobia’ and, according to its website, ‘the divisive and stridently anti-migrant rhetoric emanating from too many politicians that has accompanied it.’ It held its target protest day on Monday 20 February 2017. ‘At a time when the political discussion about migration too often depicts a false narrative of “us versus them”, and when migrants are too often excluded from a debate that is supposedly about them, we wanted to provide an opportunity for migrants and British nationals to come together and celebrate the vital role that migrants play within their own communities.’ The campaign thus aimed to showcase a variety of pro-migrant sentiment and action across the UK. At my workplace, students and staff were encouraged to write on Post-its pinned to a map of the world their messages of support and solidarity, and what migrants meant to them. In other workplaces, one particularly striking message passing on social media emerged from a series of pictures of people contrasting what their work cohort looked like with and without migrants.

Emphasising how many migrants constitute our workforce and everyday life is a helpful way to create a contrast between the rhetoric of anti-immigration politics and the reality of migrant integration. Yet numbers are also threatening to some when imagined through The Sun-fuelled metaphors of hordes, swarms, and floods of monsters, coming here, taking our jobs. In its more extreme forms, the vocabulary of anti-immigration rhetoric shifts between the registers of environmental disaster to war and crusade. Against this, the One Day Without Us actions send out a powerful message of solidarity by numerically performing the sudden disappearance of the migrants amongst us to conjure up a bond that feels increasingly unbound."



"Specifically, it seems logical to this ideology that where and to whom one is born should determine what resources and conditions one should survive in – justified legally by the respective principles of ius solis and ius sanguinis for determining nationality rights. The anti-immigrant rhetoric in most European countries today reinforces and restricts these principles. However, in other contexts such as North America, as Jessica Evans reminds us, indigenous peoples are ‘internal outsiders with a prior claim to both jus solis and jus sanguinis’ and yet ‘access to the state and to the right for a state of their own’ remains denied to them. In both contexts, however, xenophobic and exclusionary rhetoric finds refuge in the cataclysmic sense of emergency where everybody is meant to accept that the world is dying, resources are limited and cannot be shared, and, crucially, (European) Christian culture is threatened. Thus, people should stay where they are and deal with the lot they were given, whether this means war, famine, persecution, discrimination, colonial theft and trauma, unemployment, lack of healthcare, and more. What this implies is the erosion of the principle of solidarity. Although this principle, when coupled to Western liberal ideals, has often led to the worst of liberal interventionism’s civilising missions, it remains a cornerstone of basic human decency and co- existence, and of socialist politics. It therefore must be protected from European liberalism’s securitisation, retrenchment and paranoia.

Thus, the ‘with and without us’ message signals the challenge of this tragic yet never-ending liberalism, which, like the narrator character in the U2 song ‘With or Without You’, threatens to die but remains loudly and infuriatingly alive and dominant. Liberalism is currently deemed at risk by the advance of the far right; as critics of liberalism, should we not be rejoicing? No, because what is really at risk is not liberalism, but the principle of solidarity that some liberalism contains. Instead of dying, liberalism is merely becoming more and more securitised and economically ‘rational’. The principle of solidarity is trapped in the farcical tragedy of liberalism’s never-ending schizophrenic dance-off to two different songs; trying to cleave to its ideal of harmonious economic migration and human- rights discourse on one hand, and its need for retaining and cajoling the interests of state and capital through cheap labour and border controls on the other.

In ‘With or Without You’, Bono is wailing, taunting us with despair and the threat of death because the subject of his love brings him both joy and pain. He personifies today’s dominant ideology, asking migrants to stay and save liberalism’s soul, while complaining of how they threaten it, justifying the need to exploit them, detain them or kick them back into the equivalent of outer- space. Economic liberalism maintains and reproduces a moral discourse of righteousness and an institutional façade of human rights. Nevertheless, it must be rejected in toto because it necessarily also furthers a policy agenda of fear and social hierarchy that fills up the pockets of employers and fuels the growing migration security agenda and industry. Sonja Buckel captures this relation well when explaining that ‘managing migration’ means that ‘neoliberal open-border politics has been interwoven with a left- liberal humanitarian and human rights strategy, while also needing to make concessions to the conservative project’. Thus, she writes, ‘what is currently happening with the immigration crisis is not a crisis of neoliberalism. Instead, “managing migration” remains effective’.

The left can of course be co-opted into this management of migration, and this calls for vigilance towards instances when we see these categories and subjectivities being invoked and performed. To teach migration from a more critical perspective is to acknowledge and disturb our role as ‘educators’ or conductors of these categories and subjectivities. This means, firstly, to teach the origins of migration as a process tied to the commodification and value theory of labour, where workers are necessarily ‘moving- workers’ but have been alienated to only identify as national citizens or ‘bordered-workers’; and secondly, to rethink on a basic level how we are all necessarily migrants under capitalism.[2]"



"Specifically, it seems logical to this ideology that where and to whom one is born should determine what resources and conditions one should survive in – justified legally by the respective principles of ius solis and ius sanguinis for determining nationality rights. The anti-immigrant rhetoric in most European countries today reinforces and restricts these principles. However, in other contexts such as North America, as Jessica Evans reminds us, indigenous peoples are ‘internal outsiders with a prior claim to both jus solis and jus sanguinis’ and yet ‘access to the state and to the right for a state of their own’ remains denied to them. In both contexts, however, xenophobic and exclusionary rhetoric finds refuge in the cataclysmic sense of emergency where everybody is meant to accept that the world is dying, resources are limited and cannot be shared, and, crucially, (European) Christian culture is threatened. Thus, people should stay where they are and deal with the lot they were given, whether this means war, famine, persecution, discrimination, colonial theft and trauma, unemployment, lack of healthcare, and more. What this implies is the erosion of the principle of solidarity. Although this principle, when coupled to Western liberal ideals, has often led to the worst of liberal interventionism’s civilising missions, it remains a cornerstone of basic human decency and co- existence, and of socialist politics. It therefore must be protected from European liberalism’s securitisation, retrenchment and paranoia.

Thus, the ‘with and without us’ message signals the challenge of this tragic yet never-ending liberalism, which, like the narrator character in the U2 song ‘With or Without You’, threatens to die but remains loudly and infuriatingly alive and dominant. Liberalism is currently deemed at risk by the advance of the far right; as critics of liberalism, should we not be rejoicing? No, because what is really at risk is not liberalism, but the principle of solidarity that some liberalism contains. Instead of dying, liberalism is merely becoming more and more securitised and economically ‘rational’. The principle of solidarity is trapped in the farcical tragedy of liberalism’s never-ending schizophrenic dance-off to two different songs; trying to cleave to its ideal of harmonious economic migration and human- rights discourse on one hand, and its need for retaining and cajoling the interests of state and capital through cheap labour and border controls on the other.

In ‘With or Without You’, Bono is wailing, taunting us with despair and the threat of death because the subject of his love brings him both joy and pain. He personifies today’s dominant ideology, asking migrants to stay and save liberalism’s soul, while complaining of how they threaten it, justifying the need to exploit them, detain them or kick them back into the equivalent of outer- space. Economic liberalism maintains and reproduces a moral discourse of righteousness and an institutional façade of human rights. Nevertheless, it must be rejected in toto because it necessarily also furthers a policy agenda of fear and social hierarchy that fills up the pockets of employers and fuels the growing migration security agenda and industry. Sonja Buckel captures this relation well when explaining that ‘managing migration’ means that ‘neoliberal open-border politics has been interwoven with a left- liberal humanitarian and human rights strategy, while also needing to make concessions to the … [more]
capitalism  migration  border  borders  citizenship  2017  maïapal  nationalism  race  racism  immigration  canon  liberalism  frédériclordon  johnberger  onedaywithoutus  neoliberalism  sandromezzadra  policy  politics  economics  identity  division  marxism  subjectivity  mobility  containment  society  migrants  immigrants  jessicaevans  indigenous  indigeneity  outsiders  accumulation  materialism  consumerism  jeffreywilliamson  sonjabuckel  security  industry  humanrights  humanitarianism  ideology  labor  work  territory  territorialism  colonization  west  xenophobia  naturalization  sovereignty  globalization  globalism  slavery  servitude  war  environment  climatechange  climate  globalwarming  colinmooers  supremacy  backwardness  davidharvey  jasonmoore  dereksayer  structure  agency  whitesupremacy  criticalpedagogy 
8 days ago by robertogreco
Lynch Mobs Killed Latinos Across the West. Descendants Want It Known. - The New York Times
“It was a turbulent time on the border when you had a lot of people getting killed on both sides,” said Mr. White, who still lives on the family’s ranch and refrains from calling the killings a massacre. “It’s 2019, right? Playing the race card doesn’t work any more.”

A historical marker to commemorate the massacre at Porvenir.
Credit
Jessica Lutz


Image
lynching  extrajudicialmurder  america  history  racism  border 
13 days ago by Felicity

« earlier    

related tags

$0  $3.6b  $35m  $4.75  $5.7  $8.6  'build  'monitored'  'record'  "i  "waste  -  100  10km  16  19eyz  19plx  2011  2016  2017  2018  2019  2020  3  750  a  about  access  accumulation  aclu  activism  activists  administration  adnadasifparveen  advocates  aerial  after  against  agency  agents  agrees  agriculture  ai  aid  air  alexandria_ocasio-cortez  america  american  analysis  anarchism  anarchoprimitivism  anarchy  and  animals  animate  animated  another  anthropocene  app  arbitrary  arizona  as  asia  asylum  at  audrelorde  avatar  avoid  backwardness  bangladesh  barriers  bennett  bernie_sanders  betoorourke  big_bend  bigger  billion  bipartisan  block  blockchain  blur  boars  borderlands  borderpatrol  borders  boston  box  brazil  brexit  budget  build  building  bust  but  by  call  calls  can't  cancels  canon  capitalism  caravan  carenkaplan  carnage  carrp  cash  cathypotter  cbp  chapo  checkpoint  chiefs:  cities  citizens  citizenship  city  ciudad  civilization  claims  clashes  climate  climatechange  colinmooers  collapse  collision  colombia  colonialism  colonization  color  colorado  colors  columbia  commercialfishing  compromise  concerts  congress'  congress  constitution  consumerism  consumption  containment  contraception  contradictory  control  corporations  corporatism  cost  coup  coverage  cpj  crash  crime  criminalization  crisis:  criticalpedagogy  cross  cruz  css  culturalconventions  culture  customs  dalailama  dams  davidharvey  dead  deal  death  declaration  declare  declares  declaring  decontextualization  demand  democracy  democrats  demographics  denmark  deploy  deportation  derekgregory  dereksayer  derrickjensen  deschooling  design  despite  destruction  detained  detaining  detection  detention  dev  dhs  director  disagreements  discrimination  displacement  div  division  doesn't  dominance  donald_trump  donaldtrump  drone  drones  drug  drugs  easier  ecology  economics  either  el  electricity  elpaso  elpasotimes  embodiment  emergencies  emergency  emergency’  empire  enclaves  end  ends  enforcement  environment  environmentalism  eu  europe  exception  expected  extrajudicialmurder  falfurrias-tx  falling  fanciful  fascism  fear  fence  fentanyl  firearms  first  fishing  five  flooding  food  football  for  france-italy  freedom  frontend  frédériclordon  funding  further  gangs  gender  geography  georgewbush  ghandi  globalism  globalization  globalwarming  goes  gop  gov  governance  government  greencard  groups  growth  happening  he'll  he  hierarchy  his  historia  history  hole  homeland_security  hope  house  huffingtonpost  hughhandeyside  human  humanitarian  humanitarianism  humanrights  humans  i'm  ice  identity  ideology  if  illegal  immigrants  immigration  impeachment  imperialism  in  inc.  india  indigeneity  indigenous  industry  inequality  infrastructure  initial  intelligence  intensifies  international  international_parks  interrogating  interview  iraq  ireland  is  isolate  issues  it'll  jaimeesparza  jameshacking  jasonmoore  javascript  jeffreywilliamson  jenniferasif  jessicaevans  jobs  johnberger  journalism  journalists  js  jsfiddle  juarez:  just  kenpaxton  kenya's  knowledge  korea  kushner  labor  land  landbase  landreform  large  latin  law  law_enforcement  lawyer  legal  liberalism  lie  lies  life  likely  linearity  local  localism  localknowledge  logging  longest  looming  lorries  love  lynching  made  maduro  map  martinlutherkingjr  marxism  massachusetts  materialism  maïapal  mcconnell  me.  me  meeting  meets  mexican  mexico  migrant  migrants  migration  mile  militarization  military  mitch  mobility  montana.  montana  morality  more  mulls  murder  muslim  my  national  national_emergency  national_parks  nationalism  naturalization  naturalresources  nature  necessary'  neoliberalism  new  nihilism  no  nonlinear  north  northamerica  not  of  offer  offering  on  onedaywithoutus  outsiders  over  overturn  ownership  pacificnorthwest  pacifism  pakistan  patrol  pay  pelosi  pentagon  place  plans  plummeted  policy  politico  politics  politifact  population  pork  portisabel-tx  poverty  power  press  primitivism  privacy  progressives  proposal  proposed  proposes  protection  protests  punjab  questioned  quicker  race  racism  reaches  record  refugee  religion  remain  reportedly  republicans  reschedule  resistance  response  revolution  ride  rights  rio_grande  rival  river  rivers  row  salmon  samplecode  sanantonio  sandromezzadra  say  says  scandal  schengen  science  screen  script  security  senate  senators  sensor  servitude  setting  several  share  shutdown  side  sign  signals  slavery  smartphone  smugglers  society  sonjabuckel  southern  sovereignty  space  spain  spanish  speaking  speech  spending  stage  state  states  structure  stuck  style  styles  subject  subjectivity  sue  supremacy  surveillance  sustainability  systemsthinking  talks  teaching  ted  teesta  tensions  territorialism  territory  texas  texasmonthly  than  that's  that  the  them  then  there  threat  thrilled"  time"  to  tool  town  trace  transcontextualism  troops  truck  trucks  trump's  trump  trump:  trump’s  turned  u.s.  unauthorized  unexamined  unicorns  union  united_states  unschooling  urban  urbanism  us-mexico  us-pres  us  usa  uscis  use  venezuela-colombia  venezuela  venezuelan  veronicaescobar  veto  violence  voted  wall  war  wars:  washington  water  wavy  web  webdesign  west  whitesupremacy  will  with  without  work  writing  xenophobia  zero  zone  ||  ‘national 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: