scorpionvoices + tv:sherlock + tv:elementary   1

It’s Elementary, Sherlock: How the CBS procedural surpassed the BBC drama · The A.V. Club
There’s a wholly unexpected, and entirely welcome, vitality to Elementary at its best, a sense of new ground being uncovered rather than old ground being re-trod—and while it’s not perfect, it does more than simply justify its existence. By now, the antisocial genius who solves crimes without being able to understand people is a trope so old it reads like a Mad Lib waiting for the latest iteration of proper noun/verb/adjective. But Doherty and his writers have found new life in the concept by creating an antisocial genius who is more than a cartoon. In doing so, they’ve given us a new, but still recognizable, Sherlock Holmes (Jonny Lee Miller), one who is in many ways superior to his Cumberbatchian counterpart.
post:meta  article  tv:sherlock  tv:elementary  u:SH 
january 2014 by scorpionvoices

Copy this bookmark: