petej + withdrawalagreement   680

Remain should push for an election
But the last few days have seen two knife-edge votes in the Commons. If either had gone for the government, Brexit would be about to happen. It would be game over. We came seriously close. We can't keep on surviving like this.

We are completely powerless in these events. We have to watch as MPs behave in ways that don't always make sense. The whole issue is being decided on the tightest of margins, by politicians who are exhausted and under enormous emotional pressure.

An election is not an ideal way to sort this. A referendum is. But we have to work with what we've got. And at least an election allows people a chance to get involved, to do something, to work on a campaign of securing Remain seats where they can be won - to have agency. It's better than simply having to sit here and watch BBC Parliament night after night in a state of high anxiety.

That has a democratic dimension too. If this thing is happening, at least let the public get involved in it. At least lets have them give some form of input, no matter how imperfect, to validate what is happening.

So, in summary: God knows. What a mess. But probably, overall, an election is the right way to go.
UK  EU  Brexit  politics  withdrawalAgreement  WAB  JohnsonBoris  Remain  transition  customsUnion  employment  regulation  rights  ERG  DUP  generalElection  ge2019  LabourParty  CorbynJeremy  campaigning  dctagged  dc:creator=DuntIan 
19 days ago by petej
How Brexit Will End | The New Yorker
Brexit is an uncanny political process because it is an inversion of the way that things were supposed to go. The world was becoming only more connected; money and people flowed. Europe was leading the experiment. And then a population said no. In 2016, Remainers tended to make economic arguments for staying in the E.U., while Leavers spoke about sovereignty and the health of the nation. In truth, it was a matter of instinct for both sides: were you prepared to go on sharing your agency with international forces of unimaginable scale, or did you believe that an old country could somehow reassert itself and claw out its own domain? The question was more philosophical than real. Being a member of the E.U. cost less than two per cent of Britain’s national budget. Most of us did not care. But, once the question was asked, it became fundamental, and the prelude to every future question. Choosing Brexit meant that we would diverge. We would diverge from Europe, and we would diverge from one another.
UK  EU  Brexit  referendum  politics  JohnsonBoris  withdrawalAgreement  dishonesty  evasion  CummingsDominic  VoteLeave  propaganda  language  discourse  WorldWarII  noDeal  OperationYellowhammer  PeoplesVote  deregulation  standards  economy  impact  publicSpending  ERG  BakerSteve  Rees-MoggJacob  England  nationalism  GaukeDavid  GrieveDominic  BurtAlistair  NorthernIreland  Ireland  GoodFridayAgreement  borders  backstop  MayTheresa  negotiations  DUP  VaradkarLeo  Liverpool  customs  regulatoryAlignment  WAB  HouseOfCommons  dctagged  dc:creator=KnightSam 
19 days ago by petej
Boris Johnson's Top Team Is At War Over Whether To Push For An Election
Firstly, while Corbyn may have blocked the election last time, he has repeatedly committed to backing an election as soon as an extension to Article 50 is triggered, so they think going back on his word would be politically all but impossible for the Labour leader.

Second, while Johnson’s aides were confident they could find a majority to ram their Withdrawal Agreement Bill through Parliament in three days this week, they are less confident about their chances of doing so during an extension.

There are fears that, given time for extra scrutiny and to formulate a coherent strategy, opposition MPs will coalesce around an amendment to wreck the bill. They are particularly concerned that the Liberal Democrats and Scottish Nationalist Party will set aside their usual position of not voting for any Brexit measure to back a customs union amendment.

Third, internal polling has shown that an election now would be favourable to the Tories as, one official claims, the evidence suggests the public wants Brexit over with. Johnson can campaign saying he has got a deal and just needs a majority to “get Brexit done”.
UK  EU  Brexit  politics  ToryParty  withdrawalAgreement  WAB  timetable  generalElection  JohnsonBoris  CummingsDominic  Article50  extension  ListerEddie  SmithJulian  BewJohn  FrostDavid 
24 days ago by petej
Don't buy the hype: Boris Johnson's Brexit deal did not win approval | Jonathan Freedland | Opinion | The Guardian
What does it mean? First, don’t fall for the hype that says that tonight parliament approved Johnson’s deal. It did not. MPs simply voted for it to receive a second reading, some of them motivated by the desire not to endorse it but to amend it. As Labour’s Gloria de Piero confessed, she voted yes, “not because I support the deal but because I don’t”. That 30-vote majority will include MPs who wanted to propose UK membership of a customs union, others keen on conditioning the deal on public support in a confirmatory referendum. Screen out the Tory spin: those MPs should not be counted as backers of the deal.
UK  EU  Brexit  politics  withdrawalAgreement  WAB  timetable  JohnsonBoris  HouseOfCommons  DUP  DePieroGloria  scrutiny  generalElection  dctagged  dc:creator=FreedlandJonathan 
24 days ago by petej
Huge problems storing up for the govt this week: Plan is to bring MV back tomorrow. Think almost certain not to happen as Speaker will rule out of order as (i) same issue twice (ii) contradicts Letwin amendment which says Brexit related legislation must b
There is a common misconception that the govt pulled the vote on Saturday. They did not. They just didn't bring the motion as amended to a division. It went through on the nod. The House decided something. I.e. Letwin, that there is no deal until WAB passes. That is big.
UK  EU  Brexit  withdrawalAgreement  meaningfulVote  JohnsonBoris  politics  HouseOfCommons  LetwinOliver  BercowJohn  amendments  referendum  customsUnion  dctagged  dc:creator=GoodallLewis 
27 days ago by petej
Here’s why Boris Johnson’s plans have every chance of falling apart | Tom Kibasi | Opinion | The Guardian
In truth, Brexit is best understood as a prism through which an argument about the future of the country has been refracted. That’s why the argument over the level playing-field provisions in the political declaration is so important. For the ERG, the strategic purpose of Brexit has always been to deregulate at home in order to strike trade deals with the US and emerging markets, since most modern trade deals are less about tariffs and more about regulation, and their political goal is to realign Britain from the EU to the US.

Meanwhile, wavering Labour MPs have sought assurances on high standards, workers’ rights and environmental protections – which are all essential to keeping Britain a social democracy with a mixed economy. But both versions of the future cannot be true. This isn’t a matter of opinion but logic. Britain cannot be Sweden and Singapore at the same time. It can’t be in the US regulatory sphere and the EU sphere simultaneously.
UK  EU  Brexit  JohnsonBoris  withdrawalAgreement  NorthernIreland  regulatoryAlignment  checking  trade  freeTradeAgreement  USA  deregulation  ERG  standards  rights  Europe  LabourParty  politicalDeclaration  politics  dctagged  dc:creator=KibasiTom 
29 days ago by petej
Boris Johnson 'on brink of Brexit deal' after border concessions | Politics | The Guardian
Under the deal being negotiated, Northern Ireland would not be part of the EU’s customs territory, but the bloc’s full customs code would have to be enforced in the Irish Sea. “Northern Ireland would de jure be in the UK’s customs territory but de facto in the European Union’s,” an EU source said.
UK  EU  Brexit  withdrawalAgreement  negotiations  JohnsonBoris  customsUnion  borders  NorthernIreland  singleMarket  BarnierMichel  EuropeanCouncil  summit  EU27  backstop  politics 
4 weeks ago by petej
« earlier      
per page:    204080120160

related tags

1922Committee  abandonment  accountability  advice  agency  agriculture  air  alienation  alternativeArrangements  amendments  anger  anti-Semitism  arrogance  Article50  assessment  association  audio  austerity  AustinIan  authoritarianism  authority  aviation  backstop  BakerSteve  banks  BanksArron  BarclayStephen  BarnierMichel  BaronJohn  BarronKevin  BattenGerard  BBC  BeckettMargaret  Belfast  Belgium  Benn-BurtBill  BennAct  BennHilary  Bennism  BennTony  BercowJohn  betrayal  BewJohn  bigotry  blame  BlueLabour  BolesNick  borders  BradleyKaren  BradyGraham  BravermanSuella  Brexit  BrexitParty  bribery  BridgenAndrew  BritanniaUnchained  BryantChris  budget  BurgonRichard  BurtAlistair  business  Cabinet  CableVince  CameronDavid  campaigning  CampbellAlastair  CampbellRonnie  Canada  CANZUK  CarneyMark  CBI  centrism  change  ChapmanJenny  checking  Chequers  citizensAssembly  citizenship  CityOfLondon  CivilService  civilService  CJEU  ClarkeKenneth  ClarkGreg  class  clearance  climateChange  CollinsDamian  CommonMarket2.0  commonRulebook  competition  compromise  concessions  conference  confirmation  consensus  consent  conservatism  constitution  constructiveAmbiguity  contempt  control  CooperRosie  CooperYvette  CorbettRichard  CorbynJeremy  CortesManuel  CostaAlberto  CoveneySimon  CoxGeoffrey  crash  credibility  CreedMichael  crisis  CummingsDominic  customs  customsArrangement  customsUnion  DavisDavid  dc:contributor=BastaniAaron  dc:contributor=ButlerJames  dc:contributor=CorbynJeremy  dc:contributor=DohertyAlex  dc:contributor=GalsworthyMike  dc:contributor=MasonPaul  dc:contributor=SarkarAsh  dc:contributor=WalkerMichael  dc:creator=AdlerKatya  dc:creator=AshTimothyGarton  dc:creator=BarnettAnthony  dc:creator=BehrRafael  dc:creator=BonePeter  dc:creator=BushStephen  dc:creator=ButlerJames  dc:creator=CampbellAlastair  dc:creator=ChakraborttyAditya  dc:creator=CorbynJeremy  dc:creator=CraceJohn  dc:creator=d'AnconaMatthew  dc:creator=DuntIan  dc:creator=FlintCaroline  dc:creator=FosterPeter  dc:creator=FreedlandJonathan  dc:creator=GoodallLewis  dc:creator=GourevitchAlex  dc:creator=GyimahSam  dc:creator=HarkerJoseph  dc:creator=HarrisJohn  dc:creator=HuttonWill  dc:creator=JenkinsSimon  dc:creator=JonesOwen  dc:creator=KettleMartin  dc:creator=KibasiTom  dc:creator=KnightSam  dc:creator=KuenssbergLaura  dc:creator=LeslieChris  dc:creator=LidingtonDavid  dc:creator=Long-BaileyRebecca  dc:creator=MasonPaul  dc:creator=MillerGina  dc:creator=MorganNicky  dc:creator=O'TooleFintan  dc:creator=OnwurahChi  dc:creator=PennyEleanor  dc:creator=PestonRobert  dc:creator=PowellJonathan  dc:creator=PowellLucy  dc:creator=RawnsleyAndrew  dc:creator=RuncimanDavid  dc:creator=SarkarAsh  dc:creator=SeymourRichard  dc:creator=SmithOwen  dc:creator=StarmerKeir  dc:creator=ThornberryEmily  dc:creator=ToynbeePolly  dc:creator=VerhofstadtGuy  dc:creator=YoungeGary  dc;creator=CraceJohn  dctagged  debt  deception  decisions  DeCordovaMaria  defeat  defence  deindustrialisation  delay  delays  DelorsJacques  delusion  democracy  democratisation  DeMontchalinAmelie  Denmark  DePieroGloria  deregulation  DerSpiegel  deselection  DExEU  differentiation  diplomacy  disclosure  discourse  discussion  dishonesty  disorder  division  DoddsNigel  doggedness  DowningStreet  DromeyJack  DuncanSmithIain  DUP  duration  DWP  EC  ECHR  ECJ  economy  editorial  education  EEA  EFTA  election  electoralReform  employers  employment  enforcement  England  entryism  environment  equivalence  ERG  ErskineMay  Esher  ESRC  Estonia  EU  EU27  Euro  Europe  EuropeanCommission  EuropeanCouncil  EuropeanParliament  Euroscepticism  Eurozone  EvansNigel  evasion  exclusion  exploitation  extension  extremism  factions  failure  fairness  FarageNigel  farming  farRight  fear  fiction  Fidesz  FieldMark  finance  financialisation  fishing  FitzpatrickJim  flexibility  FlintCaroline  food  forecasts  FosterArlene  FoxLiam  FPTP  France  franchise  FrancoisMark  Frankfurt  freedomOfMovement  FreemanGeorge  freeTradeAgreement  freeTradeArea  FrostDavid  FTA  FTPA  fuel  funding  Galileo  GaukeDavid  GDP  ge2017  ge2019  generalElection  Germany  Gibraltar  giletsJaunes  globalisation  GNU  GodsiffRoger  GoldsmithZac  GoodFridayAgreement  GourevitchAlex  GoveMichael  government  GraylingChris  Greece  GreeningJustine  GreenParty  GrieveDominic  Grimsby  growth  Guardian  GyimahSam  HalfonRobert  HammondPhilip  HammondStephen  HancockMatt  hardBrexit  HarmanHarriet  HarringtonRichard  health  healthcare  HepburnStephen  higherEducation  HindsDamian  history  HoeyKate  homeOwnership  homophobia  hostileEnvironment  HouseOfCommons  HouseOfLords  hubris  humiliation  humour  Hungary  HuntJeremy  immigration  impact  imperialism  implementation  incompetence  IndependentGroup  indicativeVote  industrialStrategy  inequality  interdependency  internationalism  interview  intransigence  investment  IPPR  Ireland  Italy  ITV  Jacobin  JamesMargot  JavidSajid  JenkinBernard  jobs  JohnsonBoris  JohnsonJo  JunckerJean-Claude  KennyEnda  KhanSadiq  KinnockStephen  KwartengKwasi  KylePeter  LabourParty  LambertsPhilippe  LancasterHouse  language  LaveryIan  leadership  LeadsomAndrea  leaks  Leave  Leave.EU  LedByDonkeys  LeDrianJean-Yves  legal  letter  LetwinOliver  leverage  LewisBrandon  LewisClive  Lexit  LiberalDemocratParty  liberalism  libertarianism  LidingtonDavid  LilleyPeter  LisbonTreaty  ListerEddie  Liverpool  livingStandards  LloydTony  LoiseauNathalie  London  Long-BaileyRebecca  LRB  LucasCaroline  MaasHeiko  MaastrichtTreaty  MacronEmmanuel  magicalVoluntarism  MajorJohn  MakeUK  MalthouseKit  manifesto  MannJohn  manufacturing  MarrAndrew  Marxism  MasonPaul  max-fac  MayPhilip  MayTheresa  McCluskeyLen  McDonnellJohn  McVeyEsther  meaningfulVote  media  medicine  membership  MEPs  MerkelAngela  migration  military  milkshake  misinformation  MordauntPenny  MorganNicky  MPs  MundellDavid  MurrisonAndrew  NandyLisa  nationalisation  nationalism  nativism  NATO  negotiations  neoliberalism  Netherlands  Newsnight  newspapers  NFU  NHS  noConfidence  noDeal  NorthernIreland  Norway  NorwayPlus  nostalgia  Novara  obligations  OnnMelanie  OperationYellowhammer  Opimium  opposition  optimism  Parliament  passporting  PatelPriti  payments  PenceMike  PeoplesVote  PerryClaire  PestonRobert  PettiforAnn  PhillipsJess  PlanB  polarisation  policing  policy  politicalDeclaration  politicalParties  politics  polity  polls  populism  Portugal  postponement  poverty  power  predictions  pregnancy  prices  procedure  process  ProdiRomano  propaganda  property  prorogation  protest  publication  publicServices  publicSpending  quotas  RaabDominic  racism  ratfication  ratification  redLines  Rees-MoggJacob  ReevesRachel  referendum  reform  refugees  regulation  regulatoryAlignment  relocation  Remain  renewal  representativeDemocracy  research  resignation  revocation  rights  risk  RobbinsOlly  RobinsonTommy  RoettgenNorbert  RogersIvan  RuddAmber  safety  Salzburg  SanchezPedro  satellite  SchulzMartin  Scotland  scrutiny  SDLP  secrecy  security  selectCommittee  SelmayrMartin  services  shadowCabinet  shortage  SiddiqTulip  Singapore  singleMarket  SinnFein  SkinnerDennis  SmeethRuth  SmithJulian  SmithLaura  SmithOwen  SnellGareth  SNP  socialCare  socialism  softBrexit  SoubryAnna  sovereignty  Spain  speech  SpelmanCaroline  split  springStatement  SPS  stagnation  Stalin  standards  StarmerKeir  state  stateAid  StewartRory  stockMarket  Stormont  Strasbourg  strategy  StringerGraham  Suez  summit  SupremeCourt  survey  SwinsonJo  SwireHugo  Syriza  tactics  talks  tariffs  TARP  technology  Thatcherism  ThatcherMargaret  TheLeft  TheRight  ThornberryEmily  threats  timetable  TimothyNick  ToryParty  towns  trade  tradeUnions  transition  transparency  transport  travel  Trotsky  TrumpDonald  trust  TuskDonald  UK  UKIP  UmunnaChuka  uncertainty  Unite  universities  unrest  USA  VaradkarLeo  VaroufakisYanis  VerhofstadtGuy  veto  video  visualisation  voluntarism  VonDerLeyenUrsula  VoteLeave  voting  WAB  wages  Wakefield  war  WatsonTom  WeyandSabine  whip  wikipedia  wikipediaPage  WilkinsChris  WillettsDavid  WilliamsonGavin  WilsonPhil  WilsonSammy  withdrawal  withdrawalAgreement  WollastonSarah  WorldWarII  WrightJeremy  WTF  WTO  xenophobia  youth 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: