petej + resentment   31

America’s Original Identity Politics | by Sarah Churchwell | NYR Daily | The New York Review of Books
The logic of exceptionalism is embedded in the American imagination: one set of rules historically applied to white American men, another set to all other people in the country, who were not recognized as full citizens—which is to say, as fully American.

---
To this day, the American common man remains strongly coded in racial, classed, and religious terms. The common man is not, for example, commonly understood to be a Muslim. He is understood to be a coal miner from West Virginia, despite the fact that American Muslim men are much more common, statistically speaking, than West Virginian miners. These are the voters we’ve heard from endlessly over the last two years, the white working-class men of so-called “Trump country,” especially the white men without a college education who voted for Trump by a margin of 71 percent to 23 percent. The reasons for their choice have been hotly debated, including the erosion of perceived power, economic stagnation, cultural backlash, racial bigotry, gender bias, and evangelical social agendas. Yet Trump’s election was also widely perceived as an anti-elite insurrection, one that was treated as an anomaly, instead of as the latest in a series of populist surges in American history that have sought to “restore” a power to the common man that he perceived himself to be losing to other less-deserving groups.
USA  politics  identityPolitics  TrumpDonald  Breitbart  race  gender  BlackLivesMatter  transgender  LillaMark  FukuyamaFrancis  history  slavery  whiteSupremacism  women  exceptionalism  populism  resentment  JeffersonThomas  JacksonAndrew  nativism  nationalism  KuKluxKlan  citizenship  census  exclusion  authenticity  dctagged  dc:creator=ChurchwellSarah 
4 weeks ago by petej
The American civil war didn't end. And Trump is a Confederate president | Rebecca Solnit | Opinion | The Guardian
You don’t have to be oppressed or come from a history of oppression to stand with the oppressed; you just have to have a definition of “we” that includes people of various points of origin and language and religious belief and sexual orientation and gender identity.

---

I do know that so much of what makes this country miserable is imagined poverty, the sense that there is not enough for all of us, that we need to become grabbers and hoarders and slammers of doors and ad hoc border patrols. Wars are fought over resources, and this is a fight over redistribution of resources and who decides about that distribution. We are a vast land, a country of unequaled affluence – albeit with obscene problems of distribution – a country that has always been diverse, and one that has periodically affirmed ideas of equality and universal rights that we could actually someday live up to fully. That seems to be the only real alternative to endless civil war, for all of us.
USA  politics  TrumpDonald  whiteSupremacism  Confederacy  race  privilege  guns  immigration  refugees  fear  resentment  AmericanCivilWar  pluralism  diversity  inclusion  dctagged  dc:creator=SolnitRebecca 
november 2018 by petej
Trump, stochastic terror and the hate that ends in violence — Quartz
Back in 2011, an anonymous writer coined the term “stochastic terrorism” to refer to “the use of mass communication to incite random actors to carry out violent or terrorist acts that are statistically predictable but individually unpredictable,” or, in other words “remote control terror by lone wolf.”

Stochastic means “having a random probability distribution or pattern that may be analysed statistically” but are hard to predict precisely. Vitriolic messages disseminated by pundits like Glenn Beck, Sean Hannity, and Bill O’Reilly will have the same effect as Osama bin Laden’s videotaped calls to violence, the writer warned way back in 2011.

Someone, somewhere, would react—it’s just hard to predict who and when.
USA  politics  terrorism  pipeBomb  SayocCesar  extremism  resentment  disaffection  media  incitement  farRight 
october 2018 by petej
How feelings took over the world | Culture | The Guardian
These two distinctions – between mind and body, and war and peace – now appear to have lost credibility altogether, with the result that we experience conflict intruding into everyday life with increasing regularity. Since the 1990s, rapid advances in neuroscience have elevated the brain over the mind as the main way by which we understand ourselves, demonstrating the importance of emotion and physiology to all decision making. Meanwhile, new forms of violence have emerged, in which states are attacked by non-state groups (such as Islamic State), interstate conflicts are fought using nonmilitary means (such as cyberwarfare), and the distinction between policing and military intervention becomes blurred. Our condition is one of nervous states, with individuals and governments existing in a state of constant and heightened alertness, relying increasingly on feeling rather than fact.

When reason itself is in peril, there is an understandable instinct to try to revive or rescue something from the past. It has become a cliche to celebrate the rugged individualism, cold rationality and truth-seeking courage of the scientific pioneers. But in our current age, when intelligence and calculation are performed faster and more accurately by machines than by people, an alternative ideal is needed. Perhaps the great virtue of the scientific method is not that it is smart (which is now an attribute of phones, cities and fridges) but that it is slow and careful. Maybe it is not more intelligence that we need right now, but less speed and more care, both in our thinking and our feeling. After all, emotions (including anger) can be eminently reasonable, if they are granted the time to be articulated and heard. Conversely, advanced intelligence can be entirely unreasonable, when it moves at such speed as to defy any possibility of dialogue.
emotion  rationality  OxfordCircus  panic  misinformation  socialMedia  fear  instinct  rumours  virality  Germany  refugees  Facebook  populism  psychology  violence  policing  militarisation  terrorism  experts  trust  elites  resentment  inequality  exclusion  disenfranchisement  dctagged  dc:creator=DaviesWill 
september 2018 by petej
Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism - Open Future
I think a lot of the—often quite legitimate—rancor directed at the “liberal elite” is based on resentment of those working-class people see as having effectively grabbed all the jobs where you’ll actually get paid well to do something that’s both fun and creative, but also, obviously benefits society. If you can’t afford to send your kid to a top college and then support them for 2-3 years doing unpaid internships in some place like New York or San Francisco, forget it, you’re locked out.

For everybody else, unless you get very lucky, your choices are largely limited to two options. You can get a basically bullshit job, which will pay the rent but leave you wracked with the guilty feeling that you are being forced, against your will, to be a fraud and a parasite. Or, you can get a helpful, useful job taking care of people, making or moving or maintaining things that people want or need - but then, likely you will be paid so little you won’t be able to take care of your own family.

There is an almost perfect inverse relation between how much your work directly benefits others, and remuneration. The result is a toxic political culture of resentment.

Those in the largely pointless jobs secretly resent teachers or even auto workers, who actually get to do something useful, and feel it’s outrageous when they demand nice salaries and health care and paid vacations too. Working class people who get to do mostly useful things, resent the liberal elite who grabbed all the useful or beneficial work which actually does pay well and treats you with dignity and respect.
work  labour  jobs  lateCapitalism  bullshitJobs  bureaucracy  management  polarisation  exclusion  resentment  economics  dctagged  dc:creator=GraeberDavid 
august 2018 by petej
A mission for journalism in a time of crisis | News | The Guardian
"But our guiding focus, especially in countries such as Britain, the US and Australia, will be to challenge the economic assumptions of the past three decades, which have extended market values such as competition and self-interest far beyond their natural sphere and seized the public realm. We will explore other principles and avenues through which to organise society for the common good."
Guardian  journalism  history  PeterlooMassacre  TaylorJohnEdward  cotton  slavery  ScottCP  Ireland  colonialism  technology  informationTechnology  Internet  businessModels  advertising  Facebook  algorithms  trust  diversity  Brexit  TrumpDonald  polarisation  inequality  resentment  politics  radicalism  dctagged  dc:creator=VinerKatharine 
november 2017 by petej
What So Many People Don’t Get About the U.S. Working Class
"The terminology here can be confusing. When progressives talk about the working class, typically they mean the poor. But the poor, in the bottom 30% of American families, are very different from Americans who are literally in the middle: the middle 50% of families whose median income was $64,000 in 2008. That is the true “middle class,” and they call themselves either “middle class” or “working class.”"
TrumpDonald  class  workingClass  middleClass  work  labour  aspiration  masculinity  identity  conservatism  poverty  resentment  welfare  socialSecurity  police  culture  polarisation  DemocraticParty  politics 
november 2016 by petej
Taking Trump voters’ concerns seriously means listening to what they’re actually saying - Vox
"What’s needed is an honest reckoning with what it means that a large segment of the US population, large enough to capture one of the two major political parties, is motivated primarily by white nationalism and an anxiety over the fast-changing demographics of the country. Maybe the GOP will find a way to control and contain this part of its base. Maybe the racist faction of the party will dissipate over time, especially as Obama’s presidency recedes into memory. Maybe it took Trump’s celebrity to mobilize them at all, and future attempts will fail.

But Donald Trump’s supporters’ concerns are heavily about race. Taking them seriously means, first and foremost, acknowledging that, and dealing with it honestly."
TrumpDonald  USA  politics  race  racism  resentment  intolerance  immigration  RepublicanParty 
october 2016 by petej

related tags

advertising  algorithms  alt-right  AmericanCivilWar  AmericanDream  anger  anti-feminism  Article50  aspiration  Australia  Austria  authenticity  authoritarianism  bigotry  BlackLivesMatter  Breitbart  Brexit  Britishness  bullshitJobs  bureaucracy  business  businessModels  CameronDavid  Canada  census  chemicals  citizenship  CityOfLondon  class  colonialism  complexity  conditions  Confederacy  conservatism  consolidation  conspiracyTheory  cotton  crisis  culture  danger  DavisLane  dc:creator=ChurchwellSarah  dc:creator=CoppolaFrances  dc:creator=DaviesWill  dc:creator=FreemanHadley  dc:creator=GraeberDavid  dc:creator=HanleyLynsey  dc:creator=HarrisJohn  dc:creator=HochschildArlie  dc:creator=LanchesterJohn  dc:creator=MasonPaul  dc:creator=MooreSuzanne  dc:creator=PennyLaurie  dc:creator=SolnitRebecca  dc:creator=VinerKatharine  dc:creator=YoungeGary  dctagged  dehumanisation  deindustrialisation  democracy  DemocraticParty  deregulation  disaffection  disenfranchisement  diversity  divideAndRule  division  economics  economy  education  elderly  election  elites  emotion  employers  employment  England  Englishness  Enlightenment  environment  environmentalism  EPA  ethicity  EU  Europe  exceptionalism  exclusion  experts  extremism  Facebook  farRight  fascism  fear  Fidesz  finance  France  freedomOfMovement  freeTradeAgreement  FrontNational  FukuyamaFrancis  gamergate  gender  Germany  globalisation  GoodhartDavid  government  Guardian  guns  harassment  health  history  honesty  HopeNotHate  hostility  Hungary  identity  identityPolitics  immigration  incel  incitement  inclusion  individualism  indulgence  industry  inequality  informationTechnology  inheritance  instinct  Internet  intolerance  investment  Ireland  Islam  Islamophobia  Italy  JacksonAndrew  JeffersonThomas  Jews  jobs  JohnsonBoris  journalism  KuKluxKlan  labour  LabourParty  lateCapitalism  LawAndJusticeParty  Leave  LillaMark  Lithuania  location  London  Louisiana  LRB  management  manufacturing  markets  masculinity  MayTheresa  media  meritocracy  middleClass  migrants  militarisation  MinassianAlek  misinformation  misogyny  mobility  monopolies  multiculturalism  murder  nationalIdentity  nationalism  nativism  negotiations  neoliberalism  Netherlands  NewLabour  Newport  Nissan  noDeal  Norway  nostalgia  Obama  opposition  OvertonWindow  OxfordCircus  panic  passporting  patriotism  pay  PeoplesVote  pessimism  PeterlooMassacre  pipeBomb  pluralism  Podemos  Poland  polarisation  police  policing  politics  pollution  populism  post-industrialism  poverty  precariat  precarity  prejudice  privilege  property  psychology  race  racism  radicalism  RalphRetort  rationalism  rationality  recession  referendum  refugees  regionalism  regions  regulation  Remain  RepublicanParty  resentment  ressentiment  RobinsonTommy  RodgerElliot  rumours  safety  sanctions  SayocCesar  ScottCP  segregation  singleMarket  skills  slavery  socialMedia  socialMobility  socialSecurity  society  Spain  students  Sunderland  surveillance  TaylorJohnEdward  TeaParty  technology  terrorism  Thatcher  Thatcherism  ThatcherMargaret  TheLeft  TheRight  threats  tolerance  ToryParty  trade  tradeUnions  transgender  transgression  trolling  TrumpDonald  trust  UK  UKIP  USA  victimhood  violence  virality  wages  waste  wealth  welfare  whiteSupremacism  whiteWorkingClass  women  work  workingClass  xenophobia  YiannopoulosMilo  youth 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: