petej + norms   8

Counting the Countless — Real Life
To summarize: Data science as currently constituted

provides new tools for state and corporate control and surveillance
discursively (and recursively) demands more participation in those tools when it fails
communicates through its control universalized views of what humans can be and locks us into those views.

Those don’t sound compatible with queerness to me. Quite the opposite: They sound like a framework that fundamentally results in the elimination of queerness — the destruction of autonomy, contextuality, and fluidity, all of which make us what we are and are often necessary to keep us safe.

If you’re a trans person or otherwise queer person interested in data science, I’m not saying, “Don’t become a data scientist under any circumstances.” I’m not your mother, and I get that people need to eat to survive. I’m just explaining why I refuse to teach or train people to be data scientists and why I think reformist approaches to data science are insufficient and that co-option into data science, even to fix the system, is fundamentally inimical unless your primary question is asking who is left out of those fixes. You need to make the decision that is right for your ethics of care.

For me, my ethics of care says that we should be working for a radical data science: a data science that is not controlling, eliminationist, assimilatory. A data science premised on enabling autonomous control of data, on enabling plural ways of being. A data science that preserves context and does not punish those who do not participate in the system.
gender  transgender  data  bias  ethics  norms  control  administrativeViolence  quantification  analysis  decision-making  surveillance  tracking 
2 days ago by petej
Why we stopped trusting elites | News | The Guardian
If a world where everyone has their own truth-tellers sounds dangerously like relativism, that’s because it is. But the roots of this new and often unsettling “regime of truth” don’t only lie with the rise of populism or the age of big data. Elites have largely failed to understand that this crisis is about trust rather than facts – which may be why they did not detect the rapid erosion of their own credibility.

Unless liberal institutions and their defenders are willing to reckon with their own inability to sustain trust, the events of the past decade will remain opaque to them. And unless those institutions can rediscover aspects of the original liberal impulse – to keep different domains of power separate, and put the disinterested pursuit of knowledge before the pursuit of profit – then the present trends will only intensify, and no quantity of facts will be sufficient to resist. Power and authority will accrue to a combination of decreasingly liberal states and digital platforms – interrupted only by the occasional outcry as whistles are blown and outrages exposed.
elites  representativeDemocracy  trust  politics  media  business  honesty  norms  authority  liberalism  technology  Internet  populism  lies  alienation  disillusionment  UKIP  MPs  expenses  wikileaks  phonehacking  MurdochRupert  Libor  finance  BBC  Tesco  Volkswagen  exposure  whistleblowing  FOI  BlairTony  transparency  Brexit  Leave  MetropolitanPolice  RobinsonTommy  conspiracyTheory  relativism  dctagged  dc:creator=DaviesWill 
november 2018 by petej

related tags

academia  administrativeViolence  advertising  alienation  Altena  analysis  anger  attack  audience  authority  BBC  behaviour  bias  BlairTony  blocking  Brexit  business  change  children  communication  communities  conferences  conservatism  conspiracyTheory  control  culture  data  dc:creator=BadyAaron  dc:creator=DaviesWill  dctagged  decision-making  discrimination  disillusionment  elites  ethics  etiquette  expectations  expenses  exposure  Facebook  finance  FOI  gender  Germany  hatred  honesty  hostility  incitement  insecurity  Internet  Leave  liberalism  Libor  lies  livetweeting  media  MetropolitanPolice  morality  MPs  MurdochRupert  norms  outrage  parenthood  phonehacking  politics  populism  privacy  private  provocation  public  quantification  racism  refugees  relativism  representativeDemocracy  RobinsonTommy  scale  socialMedia  socialWeb  society  stigmatisation  surveillance  technology  Tesco  threats  tracking  transgender  transparency  TrumpDonald  trust  Twitter  UK  UKIP  USA  violence  Volkswagen  whistleblowing  wikileaks  xenophobia 

Copy this bookmark: