petej + mining   56

Nostalgia Mining | Amber A’Lee Frost
The real commonality among these films, though, is their affection for miners but not so much for workers. To put it another way, the films seem to like miners best when they’re playing a flugelhorn, marching in gay pride parades, or driving their creative children far away from the coalfields so they can dance ballet. Miners were always more than just miners, but it’s a lot harder to talk about the actual jobs they were fighting for. I don’t blame the filmmakers too much for falling short here; it’s hard to explain why preserving such difficult, dangerous, and unhealthy work was so politically strategic, but those jobs gave working-class Brits a hand on the lever of both the welfare state and the industrial policy of the United Kingdom. It’s not that there’s some overlooked romance in pickaxes and pit ponies; workers controlling mining meant that the workers who built the country might be able to run it too, and not in some symbolic, protesty, “whose streets? our streets!” kind of way. I mean really run the country. And they came so damn close.

My fixer says he worries that a recently invigorated love for the miners might have something to do with the fact that they’re no longer a threat to power, and I can’t say I don’t share his concerns. It’s true that there was plenty of vocal support for the miners during the strike, but the difference between mercy and solidarity has become ever-blurrier amid the disastrous global decline of the labor movement. Mercy is for Christians, and solidarity is for socialists. It’s not that the two categories are mutually exclusive (and a little mercy certainly makes the world more bearable), but one is hardly a substitute for the other. Mercy dictates support for the miners because they were wickedly and ruthlessly felled; solidarity dictates support for the miners because the union makes us strong.
UK  mining  miners  coal  MinersStrike  NUM  tradeUnions  history  RedHills  Durham  nostalgia  preservation  ScargillArthur  Stalin  class  film  solidarity 
october 2018 by petej

related tags

Aberfan  abundance  accountability  adblockers  advertising  Africa  ANC  Appleby  architecture  art  asteroids  BanksArron  blocking  Bolivia  Brexit  browser  business  businessModels  campaigning  capitalism  cars  change  childLabour  children  China  cities  class  climateChange  ClintonHillary  CNN  coal  collusion  Colombia  colonialism  Colorado  coltan  commemoration  commerce  computers  conditions  conflict  Congo  ConradJoseph  conservatism  consumerism  control  copper  CorbynJeremy  corruption  cryptocurrencies  culture  danger  dc:creator=BastaniAaron  dc:creator=HallRichard  dc:creator=KayJoseph  dc:creator=MonbiotGeorge  dctagged  deforestation  deindustrialisation  DemocraticParty  deprivation  disaster  Doncaster  DRC  Durham  Easington  ecology  economics  economy  education  election  electronics  Empire  employment  environment  environmentalism  Erdogan  Estonia  ethics  EU  EuropeanParliament  exclusion  exploitation  exploration  FALC  film  finance  football  funding  gender  geology  GertlerDan  Glencore  globalisation  government  Greenpeace  hacking  Hardt  HardtMichael  health  history  humanRights  immigration  indium  Indonesia  industry  inequality  informationTechnology  injection  interestRates  interference  InventingTheFuture  Islam  ItF  Javascript  jobs  labour  LabourParty  LatinAmerica  leaks  Leave  Lonmin  Malaysia  MalemaJulius  malware  manufacturing  Marikana  media  medical  memory  metal  metals  military  minerals  miners  MinersStrike  mines  mining  mobilePhones  modernism  Monero  Multitude  murder  MuskElon  Myanmar  nationalisation  nature  NCB  negligence  Negri  NegriAntonio  Netflix  Nissan  North-East  North-SouthDivide  Northumberland  nostalgia  Nucla  NUM  Orgreave  ParadisePapers  Parliament  Peru  Philippines  platinum  poetry  police  policing  politician  politics  pollution  post-capitalism  Potosi  poverty  power  preservation  protest  provocation  radioactivity  rareEarthMinerals  recycling  RedHills  referendum  refining  regulation  relegation  RobensAlf  Russia  Rwanda  Salon  sanctions  scarcity  ScargillArthur  school  security  selectCommittee  shares  shipbuilding  shooting  silver  SkinnerDennis  SMB  socialism  solidarity  Soma  SouthAfrica  SouthYorkshirePolice  space  SpaceX  SrnicekNick  Stalin  stockMarket  strike  strikes  Sunderland  sustainability  SYP  technology  Telluride  Thatcherism  tin  trade  tradeUnions  TrumpDonald  Turkey  Uganda  UK  UKIP  underground  unemployment  uranium  Uravan  USA  video  violence  Wales  war  Web  WestVirginia  WigmoreAndy  wikipedia  wikipediaPage  WilliamsAlex  work  workingClass  WTO  Yorkshire  YouTube  ZumaJacob 

Copy this bookmark: