petej + mps   70

Hero or villain? Bercow’s notoriety is a consequence of parliament’s crisis – not its cause | James Butler | Opinion | The Guardian
The Speaker’s rulings are a consequence, not a cause, of the political impasse – the unavoidable effect of a conflict between legislature and executive eagerly pursued by successive governments. Small majorities or minority governments – as much the result of a democratic process as the referendum – find their rebels empowered; if any such government treats parliament as a truculent inconvenience, it will find MPs ready to humble it. Bercow’s instinct to empower parliament is real and consistent – though he delights in making enemies – but his “constitutional vandalism” is unlikely to trouble any government with a majority. Whatever the tabloids claim, this government’s inability to win a vote is its fault, and its fault alone.

The competition to replace Bercow is already under way. Some candidates, such as Labour’s Chris Bryant, promise a return to procedural orthodoxy: umpire-like impartiality, slavish adherence to the rulebook. Yet it is hard to see how any candidate could avoid controversy in a restive, finely balanced parliament with an executive determined to test the limits of its power and a legislature impatient with abuse.

Brexit has seen the withering of many parliamentary delusions: the strictures of convention, the stability of the parties, the reliability of the “good chap” theory of office. Bercow’s pugnacious defence of the legislature is a boon, but he must realise that reform conducted solely through the Speaker’s chair also tests democratic legitimacy; such a realisation must be behind his embrace, in last night’s lecture, of a more codified constitutional settlement. As the legal case over prorogation waits to be heard by the supreme court next week, and the looming Brexit deadline leaves the government scrambling for political safety, Bercow’s final act remains yet to be played. It is certain to be a stormy one.
UK  politics  BercowJohn  HouseOfCommons  retirement  democracy  executive  legislature  Speaker  neutrality  accountability  MPs  reform  controversy  impartiality  dctagged  dc:creator=ButlerJames 
5 weeks ago by petej
EU leaders tell May to find Brexit consensus among MPs | Politics | The Guardian
Denmark’s prime minister, Lars Løkke Rasmussen, said the EU was being “as flexible as we can be. I think it is now up to the British to come together and create a kind of national consensus in order to tell us exactly what to do to get this through the British parliament.”

The prime minister of Luxembourg, Xavier Bettel, said the discussions with May had been an “honest exchange”.

“Theresa May is clear, but the fact is that Westminster is not that clear. So we know what Theresa wants, and she wants the best possible deal in Westminster, but the problem is the MPs in London,” he said.

“For internal political reasons some people want to gamble with the relations between the European Union and the UK for the future, and it is bad.”
UK  EU  Brexit  negotiations  withdrawalAgreement  backstop  MayTheresa  JunckerJean-Claude  Ireland  politics  Parliament  MPs 
december 2018 by petej
Why we stopped trusting elites | News | The Guardian
If a world where everyone has their own truth-tellers sounds dangerously like relativism, that’s because it is. But the roots of this new and often unsettling “regime of truth” don’t only lie with the rise of populism or the age of big data. Elites have largely failed to understand that this crisis is about trust rather than facts – which may be why they did not detect the rapid erosion of their own credibility.

Unless liberal institutions and their defenders are willing to reckon with their own inability to sustain trust, the events of the past decade will remain opaque to them. And unless those institutions can rediscover aspects of the original liberal impulse – to keep different domains of power separate, and put the disinterested pursuit of knowledge before the pursuit of profit – then the present trends will only intensify, and no quantity of facts will be sufficient to resist. Power and authority will accrue to a combination of decreasingly liberal states and digital platforms – interrupted only by the occasional outcry as whistles are blown and outrages exposed.
elites  representativeDemocracy  trust  politics  media  business  honesty  norms  authority  liberalism  technology  Internet  populism  lies  alienation  disillusionment  UKIP  MPs  expenses  wikileaks  phonehacking  MurdochRupert  Libor  finance  BBC  Tesco  Volkswagen  exposure  whistleblowing  FOI  BlairTony  transparency  Brexit  Leave  MetropolitanPolice  RobinsonTommy  conspiracyTheory  relativism  dctagged  dc:creator=DaviesWill 
november 2018 by petej

related tags

AbbottDiane  access  accountability  activism  advocacy  AlexanderDanny  alienation  amendments  anti-cuts  anti-Semitism  Article50  assessment  austerity  authenticity  authoritarianism  authority  backstop  banks  BBC  BercowJohn  bigotry  BIS  BlairTony  boundaries  BPV  BradyGraham  BravermanSuella  Brexit  BrooksRebekah  business  buyToLet  CambridgeAnalytica  CameronDavid  campaigning  capitalism  Channel4  children  China  committee  commodification  communication  compromise  compulsion  consent  conspiracyTheory  constituencies  consultancy  controversy  CooperYvette  CorbynJeremy  corruption  CoxJo  crime  crisis  culture  CummingsDominic  cuts  DailyExpress  dc:creator=ButlerJames  dc:creator=CadwalladrCarole  dc:creator=CoxBrendan  dc:creator=DaviesWill  dc:creator=FreedlandJonathan  dc:creator=HarrisJohn  dc:creator=HirstTony  dc:creator=KettleMartin  dc:creator=LanchesterJohn  dc:creator=YoungeGary  dctagged  debt  defeat  delusion  democracy  deselection  disclosure  discourse  dishonesty  disillusionment  distrust  diversity  DubsAlfred  earnings  editorial  education  election  elections  elites  engagement  ERG  Estonia  EU  Europe  executive  expenses  exposure  extension  Facebook  factions  farRight  fear  Fidesz  finance  FOI  France  freedomOfSpeech  FryStephen  ge2015  ge2017  generalElection  giletsJaunes  government  GreenParty  Guardian  hackgate  HansardSociety  harassment  hardBrexit  hatred  higherEducation  HintonLes  holidays  honesty  hostility  HouseOfCommons  housing  Hungary  HuqRupa  ICO  impartiality  incentives  income  incompetence  influence  inquiry  insults  integrity  Internet  intimidation  intransigence  investigation  investment  Ireland  Islamophobia  Italy  JohnsonBoris  journalism  journalists  judgement  JunckerJean-Claude  LabourParty  landlords  Leave  legal  legislature  letters  letterWriting  LewisClive  libel  liberalism  Libor  lies  lobbying  LucasCaroline  Mar26  March26  marketing  MayTheresa  meaningfulVote  media  membership  memes  Metgate  MetropolitanPolice  middleClass  MillerGina  misuse  money  MPS  MPs  murder  Murdoch  MurdochJames  MurdochRupert  Muslims  nativism  negotiations  neoliberalism  networks  neutrality  news  NewsInternational  newspapers  NixAlexander  noDeal  norms  offshore  OsborneGeorge  Parliament  participation  pay  PeoplesVote  personalData  pessimism  PhillipsJess  phonehacking  photographs  police  policing  policy  politicalDeclaration  politicalParties  politicians  politics  polity  populism  power  prison  privacy  property  prorogation  protest  pseudonymity  RaynerAngela  Rees-MoggJacob  referendum  reform  refugees  regulation  relativism  Remain  renting  rents  representation  representativeDemocracy  retirement  RifkindMalcolm  rights  RobinsonTommy  safeSpaces  safety  salaries  selectCommittee  ShappsGrant  SiddiqTulip  socialDemocracy  socialGraph  socialMedia  Speaker  SpelmanCaroline  StrawJack  SupremeCourt  surveillance  tabloids  tax  taxAvoidance  teaching  technology  TEF  Tesco  TheSun  threats  ToryParty  transparency  trolling  trust  Twitter  UK  UKIP  undercover  universities  video  visualisation  Volkswagen  voting  wages  whip  whistleblowing  wikileaks  withdrawal  withdrawalAgreement  women  ZuckerbergMark 

Copy this bookmark: