nhaliday + diogenes   17

The Politically Incorrect Guide to Ending Poverty - The Atlantic
The case for colonialism: http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01436597.2017.1369037

The Case for Contrarianism: http://quillette.com/2017/10/10/the-case-for-contrarianism/
Another semester, another academic publishing scandal, complete with calls for penitence and punishment. This time the catalyst is “The Case for Colonialism,” a “Viewpoint” editorial in Third World Quarterly. In this essay, Bruce Gilley argued that “it is high time to question [the anti-colonial] orthodoxy. Western colonialism was, as a general rule, both objectively beneficial and subjectively legitimate in most of the places where it was found, using realistic measures of those concepts.” Gilley’s article has since been withdrawn due to “serious and credible threats of personal violence” made against the journal’s editor. This obviously troubling development should make us wonder: just what evil would this article have brought about if not withdrawn? The Streisand effect is in full display here. The article – detailed, abstruse, and not always beautifully written – has no doubt been far more widely read than it would have been without the controversy.


What’s worth emulating about a prediction market is that it turns the expression of unpopular beliefs into a low-risk, high-reward enterprise. In the real, social world, it is often very costly to dissent from a dominant view: friendships can be lost and careers ruined. But it is not costly at all to assent to a dominant view; on the contrary, conforming in this way is helpful and often necessary both socially and professionally.

Now, consider the situation of someone who believes, for instance, that the dominant view is just as likely to be false as it is true. Normal incentives push such a person to go along with the dominant view, and they may feel perfectly comfortable about it. But the incentives of a prediction market would push a person in the opposite manner. They would push a person, who believes the dominant view is actually a 50/50 proposition, to invest in the belief which has a higher reward – that is, the less popular viewpoint. The distribution of this market ends up more rational over time simply because the dominant view is not artificially inflated by people playing it safe.

Author of article on “the case for colonialism” withdraws it after death threats and social-media mobbing; academics are mostly silent: https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2017/10/12/author-of-article-on-the-case-for-colonialism-withdraws-it-after-death-threats-and-social-media-mobbing-colleagues-are-mostly-silent/
“Credible threats of personal violence” against editor prompt withdrawal of colonialism paper: http://retractionwatch.com/2017/10/09/credible-threats-personal-violence-editor-prompt-withdrawal-colonialism-paper/
How the hate mob tried to silence me: http://standpointmag.co.uk/node/7027/full
- Bruce Gilley

This is where the "Case for Colonialism" paper goes wrong. Western states today couldn't recolonize an anthill. It's Singapore's job
I wouldn't put today's Western states in charge of anything important
skunkworks  labor  economics  macro  policy  government  foreign-policy  longform  urban  profile  world  developing-world  contrarianism  growth-econ  arbitrage  diogenes  news  nl-and-so-can-you  proposal  econotariat  paul-romer  🎩  org:mag  wonkish  technocracy  realpolitik  polisci  democracy  polis  egalitarianism-hierarchy  wealth-of-nations  antidemos  expansionism  exit-voice  conquest-empire  multi  study  essay  rhetoric  drama  academia  social-science  urban-rural  org:popup  letters  unaffiliated  left-wing  current-events  philosophy  westminster  truth  is-ought  meta:rhetoric  censorship  civil-liberty  history  early-modern  counterfactual  alt-inst  prediction-markets  paying-rent  info-dynamics  cost-benefit  incentives  markets  signaling  info-econ  institutions  preference-falsification  org:sci  scitariat  peace-violence  org:anglo  twitter  social  commentary  backup  gnon  rant  pessimism  :/  asia  managerial-state  anarcho-tyranny 
july 2016 by nhaliday
My Heroic and Lazy Stand Against IFTTT (Pinboard Blog)
Imagine if your sewer pipe started demanding that you make major changes in your diet.

Now imagine that it got a lawyer and started asking you to sign things.

You would feel surprised.
diogenes  lol  pinboard  tech  sv  techtariat  integration-extension 
july 2016 by nhaliday
Apply HN: Pinboard – Make Y Combinator Great Again | Hacker News
Following in this earnest vein, I live a life of independence and fun, and would like to encourage young technical people to live that life too, rather than wasting their youth in pursuit of a one-in-ten-thousand shot at plutocracy.
satire  yc  sv  venture  startups  diogenes  hn 
april 2016 by nhaliday

bundles : vague

related tags

:/  academia  accretion  acmtariat  advertising  advice  agriculture  ai  ai-control  albion  alt-inst  anarcho-tyranny  announcement  antidemos  antiquity  arbitrage  ascetic  asia  backup  business  career  censorship  civil-liberty  commentary  community  conquest-empire  contrarianism  cost-benefit  counterfactual  cracker-econ  critique  culture  current-events  cycles  dark-arts  debate  decentralized  deep-learning  democracy  developing-world  diogenes  drama  early-modern  econ-productivity  economics  econotariat  eden  eden-heaven  egalitarianism-hierarchy  essay  exit-voice  expansionism  farmers-and-foragers  finance  food  foreign-policy  futurism  gnon  government  growth-econ  hanson  hard-tech  history  hmm  hn  ideology  incentives  info-dynamics  info-econ  institutions  integration-extension  is-ought  labor  latin-america  left-wing  len:short  letters  lol  longform  machine-learning  macro  malthus  managerial-state  markets  meaningness  meta:rhetoric  microbiz  miri-cfar  moloch  mostly-modern  multi  mystic  new-religion  news  nibble  nl-and-so-can-you  org:anglo  org:biz  org:bleg  org:econlib  org:lite  org:mag  org:med  org:popup  org:rec  org:sci  paul-romer  paying-rent  peace-violence  pessimism  philosophy  pinboard  policy  polis  polisci  politics  prediction  prediction-markets  preference-falsification  presentation  primitivism  privacy  profile  proposal  rant  ratty  realpolitik  reddit  reflection  regularizer  regulation  rhetoric  risk  sapiens  satire  scitariat  signaling  skunkworks  slides  social  social-science  society  socs-and-mops  software  ssc  startups  status  study  sv  tech  technocracy  techtariat  thiel  transportation  travel  trends  truth  twitter  unaffiliated  urban  urban-rural  usa  venture  wealth-of-nations  web  westminster  wonkish  world  yc  🎩  🐸 

Copy this bookmark: