the-watchers   3

Evidence-based | West Hunter
The central notion of evidence-based medicine is that our understanding of human biology is imperfect. Some of the idea we come up with for treating and preventing disease are effective, but most are not, worse than useless. So we need careful, rigorous statistical studies before implementing those ideas on a wide scale. A good example of doing this the wrong way was when when doctors started recommending having babies sleep prone, which roughly doubled the incidence of sudden infant death syndrome for the next several decades.

It seems to me that our understanding of psychology, sociology, economics, political science, and education is at least as imperfect as our understanding of biomedicine.
“Measure twice, cut once” – can’t get much more elitist than that!

Carefully testing innovations on a small scale before widely implementing them is pretty much the opposite of what self-appointed elites have done. Are you deef or something?
To the extent that they diverge from accepted best practice, physicians, on average, add negative value. I’ve seen this in action, and statistical studies back it up. In other words, Gregory House is a fictional character.
west-hunter  scitariat  discussion  truth  westminster  social-science  academia  psychology  social-psych  sociology  economics  polisci  education  medicine  meta:medicine  evidence-based  empirical  elite  technocracy  cochrane  best-practices  marginal  multi  poast  vampire-squid  humility  reason  ability-competence  the-watchers 
september 2017 by nhaliday

related tags

ability-competence  academia  alignment  article  best-practices  chart  cochrane  contracts  cooperate-defect  corruption  decision-making  discussion  economics  education  elite  empirical  essay  ethics  evidence-based  free-riding  gilens-page  gnon  government  gt-101  humility  info-econ  institutions  interests  len:long  leviathan  madisonian  managerial-state  marginal  medicine  meta:medicine  micro  models  multi  noblesse-oblige  organizing  poast  polisci  political-econ  politics  power  psychology  reason  reference  rent-seeking  scitariat  social-choice  social-psych  social-science  sociology  technocracy  truth  vampire-squid  west-hunter  westminster  wiki 

Copy this bookmark: