reification   94

« earlier    

Rasmus Grønfeldt Winther - James and Dewey on Abstraction, The Pluralist, 07/2014 | via Researchgate
elucidates the abstraction-reification account diagnosed by James and Dewey and locates it in contemporary scientific work. Section 2 -- the complex process of abstraction in James and Dewey, and with a nod to CS Peirce. Identifying 3 stages in the abstraction process— singling out, symbolizing, and systematizing—clarifies the parallels between James’s and Dewey’s analyses. Section 3 -- pragmatists’ warnings against committing abstractionist fallacies. Identifies pernicious reification as neglecting 3 kinds of context: functional, historical, and analytical-level. Both philosophers implored everyday reasoners, scientists, and philosophers to attend to context. Reification, qua pathology of abstraction, results in disease symptoms such as universalized, narrowed, and/ or ontologized abstractions. Acknowledging the importance of biographical and social conditions, the genealogy and mutual influence of James’s and Dewey’s perspectives are traced, especially in endnotes. Section 4 -- how James and Dewey avoid reifying the very distinction with which they are weaving their analysis: the abstract vs. the concrete. Conclusion -- following the pragmatic forward-looking attitude, a gesture is made toward developing medicines (pluralism and assumption archaeology) out of the abstraction-reification account. After all, pernicious reification is to abstraction as disease is to health. Such treatments permit de-reifying ill models in contemporary science. -- downloaded pdf to Note
article  pragmatism  James_William  Dewey  Peirce  epistemology  logic-Dewey  abstraction  essence  essentialism  reification  sociology_of_knowledge  sociology_of_science  sociology_of_science_&_technology  scientific_method  scientific_culture  induction  modelling  reason  downloaded 
january 2016 by dunnettreader
Nancy Fraser: Rethinking Recognition. New Left Review 3, May-June 2000.
Has the liberating charge of struggles for recognition dissolved into pure identity politics? Do these have to sidestep inequalities of wealth and power? Not, Nancy Fraser contends, if recognition is understood as a question of social status rather than existential address. -- interesting fit from a social justice angle of key themes taken up by Jacib Levy in his new book -- downloaded pdf to Note
social_theory  culture_wars  cultural_authority  classes  status  political_participation  minorities  identity  identity_politics  multiculturalism  communitarian  identity-multiple  wealth  inequality-opportunity  inequality  inequality-wealth  redistribution  reification  recognition  Hegel  dialogue  marginalized_groups  downloaded 
june 2015 by dunnettreader
Kill Your Martyrs – The New Inquiry
"However well intentioned, the urge to treat Matthew Shepard as a blameless angel demonstrates so many of the pathologies in contemporary social liberalism. First is the left’s attraction to heroes and martyrs — a drive to personalize and individualize every issue, in a way that seems to directly cut against the theoretical commitment to identifying structural causes for social problems. After all, it is the right wing that prefers to reduce complex social issues to problems of personal character and claim economic outcomes are entirely the result of individual work ethic and talent. Advancing individuals as the symbols of a political causes invites attempts to discredit the causes by discrediting the inevitably flawed martyrs pressed into service to emblemize them. Yes, the personal is political. But the person is not the politics.

Neither are the activist groups entirely synonymous with their causes. Despite recent declarations of victory thanks to the advance of same-sex marriage, queer people in America continue to suffer from vast and entrenched discrimination in a variety of arenas. The gay rights movement remains essential and in need of protection against reactionary power. But no activist group is the movement. Like all institutions, they inevitably become more devoted to their self-perpetuation and to the needs of those working within them than to the cause with which they are identified. The Matthew Shepard Foundation, started by his parents, is an example. It has repeatedly worked to delegitimize not just Jimenez’s work but the very legitimacy of questioning the facts surrounding Shepard’s death.

But what, exactly, do Jimenez’s critics fear? What if every bad rumor about Matthew Shepard were true? For years, I have argued against the “race realist” arguments about race and IQ, the notion that our broad racial categories are significantly different in intelligence. But I have also argued against the notion that we just shouldn’t investigate the question — that some types of investigation should be taboo. This argument, voiced by writers like John Horgan and others, seems an enormous tactical and rhetorical mistake. What are they scared might be found? Regardless of any studies, I have no fear that we will somehow “discover” the inherent inferiority of any particular racial group. I have no fear that social science will result in our rejecting the equal dignity, value, and rights of people of color.

bloodpsortTNI Vol. 24: Bloodsport is out now. Subscribe for $2 and get it todayIf empirical tests suggest that our social construct of race align with differences in our social construct of intelligence, it invites consideration of how those constructs have been assumed or theorized, how those tests have been designed, and how structural aspects of our economy and our society have created conditions that make such perceived differences possible. No test results could undermine our pre-empirical commitment to the social and political equality of all races. Likewise, no journalistic revelations will change the fact that Matthew Shepard was strapped to a post, has his brain bludgeoned, and was left to die in the snow by killers who worked consciously and with premeditation. The right to live is not deserved. The right to not be killed does not stem from the perceived social legitimacy of one’s sexual or gender identity. McKinney and Henderson took Matthew Shepard out with the intention of killing him, and they did. That fact alone is reason for grief, disgust, and horror.

What, ultimately, is true about what happened in Laramie? I don’t know, and neither does Stephen Jimenez, and neither do his vitriolic critics. But I feel confident in the following: Someone who was innocent of anything immoral, as opposed to illegal, was intentionally and brutally murdered. His murderers were possessed, at the time, of some degree of homophobia, whether those feelings included the self-hatred of McKinney or not. The victim was forced to live in an unrepentantly homophobic country, one which refuses to meaningfully address the physical vulnerability of its unjustly targeted gay population and which was thus tacitly implicated in his murder. He died for no reason, and his killers deserve to spend the rest of their lives in jail. All that is true.

But the notion that this killing was a simple story of strangers meeting a defenseless gay man, being panicked by his homosexuality, and executing him in a fit of hatred, is no longer a responsible or informed position.

If Jimenez’s Matthew Shepard — involved in the drug trade, intimately acquainted with his killers, despairing — is the real Matthew Shepard, we face the same moral questions that we do when we consider Shepard the secular saint. Even if his death was not a black-and-white morality play which spoke perfectly to the assumptions of those who mourn him, and he not a media-ready victim but a complex and flawed human being, would he then lie outside of the boundaries of our compassion and our responsibility? And if he did, where is left for a movement seeking human justice to go?"
politics  personalization  individualization  matthewshepard  freddiedeboer  2014  news  truth  complexity  purity  humans  left  socialliberalism  heroes  martyrs  martyrdom  reification  hagiography  stephenjimenez  rigobertamenchú  simplification  simplicity  messaging  whitewashing  josephbrennan  credulity  bias  jennifertoth  themolepeople  journalism  storytelling  fiction  nonfiction  thebookofmatt  canon  radicalism 
january 2015 by robertogreco

« earlier    

related tags

*****  1.1_uniform_http_protocol  2002  2007  2014  aa  abstract  abstraction  accomplishment  adaptation  aesthetics  agency  algebraic  alienation  annotation  antagonisms  anthropology  antifestival  api  architecture  art  article  artists  assemblage  atom_publishing_protocol  automation  belief  bias  bibliographicdescription  blog  canon  capitalism  change  christianity  citation  citations  cito  classes  cli  coding  coherence  collections  comics  commodityfetishism  communitarian  community  complexity  compsci  computer-club  computer  computerscience  computing  concept  concrete  conference  construct  constructor  contemporary  coordination  cp2tech01  creativity  credulity  criticism  critique  cultural_authority  culture  culture_wars  cutting  danah_boyd  data  datarepresentation  dc:creator=brickleydan  dc:creator=grantjan  dc:creator=shottondavid  dctagged  deception  definition  definitions  delicious-export  design  desire  detangling  development  dewey  dialogue  difference  digital-divide  done  downloaded  dsl  duration  economics  economy  education  efellows  elearning  elearningcolombia  emergence  emergent  epistemology  erasure  essay  essence  essentialism  evan.calder.williams  examples  execution  extension  facebook  failure  fakery  faking_it  fallacy  festival  festivals  fiction  finland  first-class  forth  frameworks  freddiedeboer  functional  gadts  generic  generics  geography  georglukacs  gestalt  goals  god  good  graph  graphs  grasping  group  gui  hagiography  hegel  heroes  highways  historiography  history  holistic  homoiconic  howto  http  humans  ict_skills  ict_teaching  ideas  identity-multiple  identity  identity_politics  ikl  illusion  imported  independent  individualization  induction  inequality-opportunity  inequality-wealth  inequality  information  innovation  institution  intelligence  interaction  international  internet  interview  introspection  invariance  isms  item  james_william  java  jena  jennifertoth  josephbrennan  journalism  jvm  kevin_marks  km  knowledge  knowledge_representation  kuopio  labor  lamda-calculus  language  leadership  left  lic:cc:by-sa  life  linked_data  linkeddata  links  literal  liturgy  live  logic-dewey  logic  lukacs  m  macro  macrosociology  making.use  management  map  marginalized_groups  martyrdom  martyrs  marxism  matthewshepard  memory  messaging  metadata  metadiscovery  metal  metaphor  minorities  misunderstanding  model  modelling  mooc  multiculturalism  multistability  multistable  music  n-aryrelations  namedgraphs  narrative  nealgafter  news  nonfiction  npk4dev  oac  objects  ontology  oo  ood  optical  organization  owl  paging  participation  patheticfallacy  pattern  patterns  peirce  people  perception  performance  persistent  personalization  pgmg  philosophy  php  pl  places  political_participation  politics  post  pragmatism  problems  production  prog21  programming-language-semantics  programming-language  programming  projects  proposal  prov  provenance  psychology  public  publicdata  purity  query_languages  quotation  radical  radicalism  rdf  rdfa  realisr  reality  reason  recognition  redistribution  referential-opacity  reflection  reified  reify  relation  relations  religion  resistance  resource  rhetoric  rigobertamenchú  roles  rotting  roy_t._fielding  roy_t._fielding_dissertation  ruined  ryanholiday  salvage  salvagepunk  scala  scholarlycommunication  science  scientific_culture  scientific_method  scott-berkun  secondlife  self-representation  self  semantic-web  semantic  semantic_web  semantics  semanticweb  semiotics  shards  simple_knowledge_organization_system  simplicity  simplification  site-specific  site.specific  sites  social  social_theory  socialliberalism  socialnetworking  society  sociology  sociology_of_knowledge  sociology_of_science  sociology_of_science_&_technology  software  software_engineering  softwaredevelopment  solidarity  sontag  sorting  space  sparql  spatial.imaginary  spatial.practice  spatiality  speech  src:wikipedia  stars:5  status  stephenjimenez  story-telling  storytelling  success  sum  superman-problem  superman  swbpdwg  systems  tagging  tangles  teams  technology/internet  term  territory  thebookofmatt  themolepeople  theory  things  thought  time  tinderboxed  to-grok  to-share  topic_maps  toread  trust  truth  typeclasses  types  ui  umsetzung  uris_resources  usability  use  useless  user-interface  ux  vague  versioning  w3c  walking  waste  wasteland  wealth  web_access_control  web_architecture  web_resources_named_graphs  web_services  web_tutorial_mindswap  whitewashing  whole  wikipedia  wisdom  words  workshops  world_wide_web  write-enabled_web  writing  xml 

Copy this bookmark: