jeffrey_goldberg   20

SHAME Profile: Jeffrey Goldberg
In case you needed any more evidence regarding Jeffrey Goldberg being a piece of shit, this article compiles a lot of information together. When Goldberg was an Israeli prison guard, he would beat Palestinian prisoners (though he attempts to justify this by stating that he was acting in self defense). He also speaks gleefully about the idea of indefinite detention with no due process. And to top of all off, he thought that we would look back on the Iraq war as a moment of great morality. What a douche.
jeffrey_goldberg  israel  humanrights  warcrimes  stupid  douchebag 
june 2012 by fraaz
The Israeli Desert - Jason Zengerle, New York
Peter Beinart thought his new book on Israel would be a rallying cry for liberal Zionism. Instead, it’s been attacked by many of his peers and embraced by some whose views he finds terrifying.
Jeffrey_Goldberg  Peter_Beinart  Zionism 
june 2012 by jrick
Jeffrey Goldberg, excommunicator
Jeffrey Goldberg has ignited a blog conflagration with an attack on Allison Benedikt's coming-of-age tale of her progressive disillusionment with the gung-ho Zionism she sucked up in summer camp. I found Benedikt's  narrative riveting, and Goldberg's critique smotheringly self-righteous.Goldberg asks of Benedikt: "Does she ever try to answer for herself why Israel exists? Or is she happy to subcontract out her thinking about the most important questions facing Jews first to her camp counselors, and then to her husband?"  It's true that Benedikt's stances on the issues are barely sketched in, but that in itself suggests neither a lack of thought nor of due diligence. Her focus is on how her changing perceptions registered emotionally, not on the data points that caused them. Hers is not a policy piece; it's a chronicle about how she navigated the family mania for Israel -- and later, her husband's antipathy toward the country -- over the course of a decade and a half or so. Benedikt's response to Goldberg makes this point better than I can.I want to focus on Goldberg's most poisonous charge -- which he saves for last. I think it reveals more about him than about Benedikt:And then there is a whole set of other questions:  Does she ask herself whether she has a responsibility to make Israel a better, more humane, place? Does she question herself about the consequences of abandoning Israel? Does she think about the sin of the wicked son in the Passover story, and how that sin might echo in her own life?  Abandoning Israel? Goldberg seems to have derived that idea from Benedikt's kicker at the close. Let's take a look:My sister lives a full and happy life in Tel Aviv. She has two awesome kids who will both serve in the Israeli Army one day. I love them all very much. All of us kids have had an impact on my mother—as has Jeffrey Goldberg. Mom turns out to be open-minded. She thinks she never got the full story either, and is now tortured over Israel, a torture that seems to occupy 80% of her brain. She is basically alone among her friends, most of them reflexively "pro"-Israel, one-issue voters who try to make her feel stupid when she is not. My father is still a hawk. I don't care as much as either of them, but I do still care—and not just because it's a Major World Issue, and not just because my sister lives there.John and I have two kids of our own and are raising them as Jews. Most of my Jewish friends are disgusted with Israel. It seems my trajectory is not at all unique. My best memories from childhood are from camp, and I will never, ever send my kids there."There" is the Zionist summer camp, a repellent, brainwashing organization. "There" is not Israel, and "disgusted with" does not equal abandonment -- Goldberg himself is often disgusted with Israel. Benedikt is not obligated to make Israel the focal point of her life, nor to become an investigative journalist (she is the Village Voice's film editor). Not doing so does not mean that she is "abandoning" anything.Goldberg, it should be noted, is quite capable of nuance and admirably endowed with empathy for Palestinians as well as Israelis.. But the smug, parochial strain in his writing and thinking is embedded in that toxic little zinger about the wicked son in the Passover story. Does she think about the sin of the wicked son in the Passover story, and how that sin might echo in her own life?  Make no mistake, he is implicitly expelling her from the community.  Wise Son that he is, he takes the Haggadah's 1st or 2nd-century C.E. special ed prescriptions to heart:The Torah speaks of four sons: one wise, one wicked, one simple, and one who does not know how to ask. ..The wicked son, what does he say? "What is this service to you?" By saying, "to you," he implies: "but not to himself." Since he has excluded himself from the people at large, he denies the foundation of our faith.Therefore, you should blunt his teeth and tell him: "It is because of this, what God did for me when I went out of Egypt."By saying "for me," you imply: "but not him." Had he been there, he would not have been redeemed.Bludgeoned by Goldberg with this putrid bit of religious invective, Benedikt responds that in her own family Seder, she deletes reference to the wicked child. That sets off a fresh round of spiritual hand-wringing, inducing Goldberg not only to condemn this "un-Jewish" editing himself, but to call in the heavy religious artillery -- a certain Rabbi Andy Bachman, who responds to the deletion as follows:I was blown away by this.  The structure of the Seder is built on the number 4 (4 questions, 4 cups, 4 children) There is a long intellectual tradition of writing creative Haggadahs but to delete a core element, to delete a *child* seems to be severing a connection to the people that cuts to the heart of the Jewish peoplehood debate today.  A Seder without a Wicked Child is not a Seder.  A Jewish people without all its voices is not a people.  It's an American denominationalist religion where land, history and language gather dust.  That may work for some people; but it obviously doesn't work for others.  Thus does Bachman sentimentalize the harsh exclusions inherent in the Seder (along with a bit of pointless number symbolism). The "wicked child" is part of the community! An essential part!  The scapegoated, demonized, labeled, ostracized part. Holy paradox -- forever "including" the excluded one as excluded one. What a useful reminder the little bastard is. And so Bachman uses Benedikt -- an instructively lost daughter who is severing a connection to the people that cuts to the heart of the Jewish peoplehood debate today. The corollary is that for the wise (Goldberg and Bachman), the Seder is about what God did for me and for my people. That is, smite "our" oppressors, lead "us" out of slavery, and, ultimately, command and impel "us" to exterminate and displace the inhabitants of a certain once-again-contested sliver of land. The Seder is focused on the first part of the story: the liberation.  There is a brief, pious nod toward not celebrating the death of the Egyptians, and -- in modern American Haggadot in any case --  a modicum of guided discussion about universal values and rights. But the whole narrative is of course sacred to Jews. The Seder reflects a basic tension in Judaism between tribalism and universalism.For centuries, in Jewish thought, universalism was dominant.  What Benedikt's piece implicitly suggests is that today, increasingly, tribalism has come to the fore. How do we react if the Tanach, which celebrates displacement of the Promised Land's prior inhabitants, is being used by an increasingly dominant cohort of fundamentalist Israelis to justify ever more displacement of the current inhabitants -- and American Jews go along with it? To turn Goldberg's charge around, Benedikt's piece can be understood to ask: What if the wicked one is the one doing the indoctrinating, rather than the resistant child at the receiving end of the indoctrination? Personally, that's how I experienced the God of the Jewish Bible in my religious instruction: as a haranguing, threatening, punishing bully. And still do.I am that wicked son -- sitting through the Seder resenting the endless repetition of a tale told by an idiot. Okay, that's rage boiling over. There's nothing "idiotic" about the original narrative. Let's call it a tale handed down by ancient theocrats with an agenda, held up by atavist reflex by those invested in the belief that the tale encapsulates timeless wisdom, notwithstanding its assertions of divinely commanded genocide. And in this generation, some have reified a virulent strain of original intent: The land is mine, God gave this land to me.  What an evil lie.  God does not deal in real estate.That's not the whole story, of course. I am not writing this to morally condemn the writers of Exodus, or their Jewish interpreters through the centuries.  I agree with Robert Wright that God grows kinder through the ages -- that is, His (and/or Her) perceived nature reflects evolving and yes improving human ethics. For many a century, the rabbis were strong drivers of that process.  But post-Enlightenment,  I don't see any reason to invest continued sanctity in texts that are morally archaic, that we have improved upon.  As a personal guide, I'll take the Universal Declaration of Human Rights over the Ten Commandments any day.  "Sacred" texts are better equipped to teach us where we came from and how our moral understanding has evolved than how to live or think today.Benedikt, on the other hand, is raising her children as observant Jews by her lights.  Last I checked, Judaism has no pope, though these days, alas, it's not short of theocratic thugs, like the one who tweeted to her: "you make up your own hagada? who in the world do you think you are? and why do you think it's a hagada?"Goldberg finds Benedikt's response -- "I am Jewish, you mother fucker. And I'm not unique" -- "repellent."  As he might expect from one to be repelled, a wicked child.Kudos to Benedikt for rejecting such rejection.Related posts:Myths are all very well, but dreams of purity are perniciousOn not respecting the past
Jeffrey_Goldberg  Haggadah  Allison_Benedkict  Andy_Bachman  from google
june 2011 by HalSF
No. 26: Jeffrey Goldberg - Alex Pareene, War Room
His inaccurate Iraq stories helped pave the way for war.
Jeffrey_Goldberg 
december 2010 by jrick
Goldberg's War - Ken Silverstein, Harper's
In urging war on Iraq, Goldberg took highly dubious assertions—for example, that Saddam was an irrational madman in control of vast quantities of WMDs and that Iraq and Al Qaeda were deeply in bed together—and essentially asserted them as fact. From these unproven allegations, he demonstrated that an invasion of Iraq was the only rational policy.
Jeffrey_Goldberg 
july 2010 by jrick
The Jeffrey Goldberg Media - Glenn Greenwald, Salon
He's so representative of the American media because the more discredited his journalism becomes, the more blatant propaganda he spews, the more he thrives in our media culture. That's why it's not hyperbole to observe that we are plagued by a Jeffrey Goldberg Media; he's not an aberration but one of its most typical and illustrative members.
Jeffrey_Goldberg 
june 2010 by jrick
Why I'm Not Blogging More About Gaza - Jeffrey Goldberg
My paralysis isn't an analytical paralysis. It's the paralysis that comes from thinking that maybe there's no way out. Not out of Gaza, out of the whole thing.
politics  world  israel  jeffrey_goldberg  theatlantic.com 
january 2009 by tfrab

related tags

1967  allison_benedkict  andy_bachman  barack_obama  bashar_al-assad  benjamin_netanyahu  china  diversity  douchebag  foreign_policy  h._política/activismo  haggadah  hamas  humanrights  illiberalism  iran  iraq  isis  islam  israel  john_kerry  journalism  kevin_williamson  libya  middle_east  mideast_peace  news  obama  palestina  peter_beinart  politics  ronald_reagan  russia  saudi_arabia  six-day_war  stupid  syria  ta-nehisi_coates  terrorism  the_atlantic  theatlantic.com  vladimir_putin  warcrimes  west_bank  world  zionism 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: