inquiry   985

« earlier    

Uncertainty in School Contexts | Ronald Beghetto | TEDxUConn - YouTube
How can teachers and schools promote creativity and innovation through education? Ronald Beghetto suggests structured uncertainty.
Education  inquiry  ronald_beghetto 
16 days ago by tonyyet
The Misguided Drive to Measure ‘Learning Outcomes’ - The New York Times
"It seems that the pressure to assess student learning outcomes has grown most quickly at poorly funded regional universities that have absorbed a large proportion of financially disadvantaged students, where profound deficits in preparation and resources hamper achievement. Research indicates that the more selective a university, the less likely it is to embrace assessment. Learning outcomes assessment has become one way to answer the question, “If you get unprepared students in your class and they don’t do well, how does that get explained?” Mr. Eubanks at Furman University told me.

When Erik Gilbert, a professor of history at Arkansas State University, reached the end of his World Civilization course last fall, he dutifully imposed the required assessment: an extra question on the final exam that asked students to read a document about Samurai culture and answer questions using knowledge of Japanese history. Yet his course focused on “cross-cultural connections, trade, travel, empire, migration and bigger-scale questions, rather than area studies,” Mr. Gilbert told me. His students had not studied Japanese domestic history. “We do it this way because it satisfies what the assessment office wants, not because it addresses concerns that we as a department have.”

Mr. Gilbert became an outspoken assessment skeptic after years of watching the process fail to capture what happens in his classes — and seeing it miss the real reasons students struggle. “Maybe all your students have full-time jobs, but that’s something you can’t fix, even though that’s really the core problem,” he said. “Instead, you’re expected to find some small problem, like students don’t understand historical chronology, so you might add a reading to address that. You’re supposed to make something up every semester, then write up a narrative” explaining your solution to administrators.

Here is the second irony: Learning assessment has not spurred discussion of the deep structural problems that send so many students to college unprepared to succeed. Instead, it lets politicians and accreditors ignore these problems as long as bureaucratic mechanisms appear to be holding someone — usually a professor — accountable for student performance.

All professors could benefit from serious conversations about what is and is not working in their classes. But instead they end up preoccupied with feeding the bureaucratic beast. “It’s a bit like the old Soviet Union. You speak two languages,” said Frank Furedi, an emeritus professor of sociology at the University of Kent in Britain, which has a booming assessment culture. “You do a performance for the sake of the auditors, but in reality, you carry on.”

Yet bureaucratic jargon subtly shapes the expectations of students and teachers alike. On the first day of class, my colleagues and I — especially in the humanities, where professors are perpetually anxious about falling enrollment — find ourselves rattling off the skills our courses offer (“Critical thinking! Clear writing!”), hyping our products like Apple Store clerks.

I teach intellectual history. Of course that includes skills: learning to read a historical source, interpret evidence and build an argument. But cultivating historical consciousness is more than that: It means helping students immerse themselves in a body of knowledge, question assumptions about memory and orient themselves toward current events in a new way.

If we describe college courses as mainly delivery mechanisms for skills to please a future employer, if we imply that history, literature and linguistics are more or less interchangeable “content” that convey the same mental tools, we oversimplify the intellectual complexity that makes a university education worthwhile in the first place. We end up using the language of the capitalist marketplace and speak to our students as customers rather than fellow thinkers. They deserve better.

“When kids come from backgrounds where they’re the first in their families to go to college, we have to take them seriously, and not flatter them and give them third-rate ideas,” Mr. Furedi told me. “They need to be challenged and inspired by the idea of our disciplines.” Assessment culture is dumbing down universities, he said: “One of the horrible things is that many universities think that giving access to nontraditional students means turning a university into a high school. That’s not giving them access to higher education.”

Here is the third irony: The value of universities to a capitalist society depends on their ability to resist capitalism, to carve out space for intellectual endeavors that don’t have obvious metrics or market value.

Consider that holy grail of learning outcomes, critical thinking — what the philosopher John Dewey called the ability “to maintain the state of doubt and to carry on systematic and protracted inquiry.” Teaching it is not a cheap or efficient process. It does not come from trying to educate the most students at the lowest possible cost or from emphasizing short, quantifiable, standardized assignments at the expense of meandering, creative and difficult investigation.

Producing thoughtful, talented graduates is not a matter of focusing on market-ready skills. It’s about giving students an opportunity that most of them will never have again in their lives: the chance for serious exploration of complicated intellectual problems, the gift of time in an institution where curiosity and discovery are the source of meaning.

That’s how we produce the critical thinkers American employers want to hire. And there’s just no app for that."
learning  learningoutcomes  outcomes  academia  assessment  evaluation  quantification  measurement  accountability  highered  highereducation  2018  mollywhorthen  criticalthinking  johndewey  metrics  inquiry  efficiency  standardization  standardizedtesting  capitalism  content  complexity  howwelearn  howwethink  knowledge  education  lcproject  openstudioproject  unschooling  deschooling  schools  pedagogy  teaching  skepticism  bureaucracy  corporatism  corporatization  inequality 
7 weeks ago by robertogreco

« earlier    

related tags

"we  10  1228  2009  2013  2015  2016  2017-10-12  2017-10-14  2017-10-16  2017-10-18  2017-10-20  2018  9/11  abuse  academia  accountability  activity  afghanistan  ai  airfrance  aisle  alan_kay  alanjacobs  all  alternative  alternatives  an  angela  answering  anywhere  apple  appreciative  art  askingquestions  aspiration  assessment  atención  attorney  available  ber  best  bias  blair  blairtony  blixhans  book  brightworks  building  bureaucracy  bush  bushgeorgew  business  cameron  capitalism  care  career  catholicism  charge  chemistry  chemistryactivity  chilcot  chilcotjohn  child  childhood  children  chinese  christianity  christieseyfert  chrome  cityasclassroom  civilsociety  cladding  classideas  claudeshannon  cliente  communication  community  complex  complexity  comprehension  considering  construction  contact  content  contextual  cookrobin  coordinated  corbyn  corporatism  corporatization  corruption  creativity  criticalthinking  cronyism  curiosity  curriculum  customer  cuts  database  david  dc:creator=kuenssberglaura  dc:creator=monbiotgeorge  dctagged  demands  democracy  deregulation  deschooling  devops  difference  digital  digitalcitizenship  digitlliteracy  diigo  disaster  diveintoinquiry  doj  eagle  east  edhirsch  editorial  education  efficiency  electricity  empathy  erikdavis  error  establishment  evaluation  evernote  experience  factors  fat  fbi  fbu  feel  finds  fire  flanneryo'connor  food  foodwaste  for  foreignpolicy  foucault  future  gafesummit  gathering  georgesteiner  gesellschaft  govemichael  government  grenfelltower  guardian  gwbush  harassment  have  henry_county  herstory  highered  highereducation  higherorder  history  homeoffice  homeschool  housing  howwelearn  howweteach  howwethink  human  humanities  humble  humility  husseinsaddam  i  ifttt  immigration  inequality  info-graphic  infoliteracy  informant's  infrastructure  institutes  insults  intelligence  interactive  interested  interestedness  interface  internet  intervention  interview  intimidation  into  iraq  iraqwar  is  james  jeremy  jm  johndewey  joshusdog  journal  judaism  judge  just  justice  kath  kennethburke  klm  knowledge  koan  kristatippett  labour  labourparty  lcproject  learning  learningoutcomes  letwinoliver  lisabishop  listening  literacy  local/bounded  london  loose  magazine  maintenance  marketing  maths  matter  may  maytheresa  measurement  metadiscovery  metrics  michelfoucault  middle  middleeast  middleschool  mikecaulfield  mikhailbakhtin  military-intelligence  military  military–industrial  minersstrike  mobile  mollywhorthen  moore-bickmartin  motorcycle  mps  mu  murdoch  mystery  national-geographic  nature  neo-nomads  neoconservatism  neoconservatives  neoteny  nomadic  non  nonlinear  nz  on  one:  online  open  openstudioproject  optimism  options  orgreave  outcomes  parenting  parliament  party  pbl  pedagogy  personalization  personalized_learning  phone...  phone  physics  pickpocket  pirsig  planet  pocket  podcast  point  policing  policy  policyexchange  politicians  politics  population  post-conceptual  postgraduate  posthumanism  postmodernism  postsecularism  practice  practices  presentation  presentations  privileged  problem  problembasedlearning  productivity  progress  projects  publication  pypchat  quantification  query  question  questionasking  questioning  questions  quiddle  rationality  raykurzweil  raziskave  reading  readings  rec  redtape  reduction  regulation  religion  report  reputation  rhetoric  rights  robert  robertcoles  robertpondiscio  ronald_beghetto  ruddamber  rules  sac  safety  sambarlow  sanfrancisco  schedule  schools  science  science_education  search  sel  sexual  sfsh  share  sk  skepticism  slideshow  smear  socialmedia  society  solving  spent  spirituality  standardization  standardizedtesting  stephengrenblatt  strawjack  sucks  sued  support  surgical  systems  taylorcuffaro  teachers  teaching  techcrunch  tedx  terence  text  the  thegatelessbarrier  thegatelessgate  theresa  thought  threats  to  toff  together  tony  travel  twitter  types  typography  uk  unasking  understanding  unlock  unschooling  uranium  usa  utopia  učenje  values  video  videogames  violence  visual  war  was  we  web  wertegesellschaft  westminster  what  whitehall  without  wmd  wonder  work  workshop  wumenhuikai  xc  years  zen     

Copy this bookmark: