education   427619

« earlier    

15 Ways to Validate Your Online Course Idea
I also strongly recommend that you charge for your pilot if you truly want to test your market.
marketing  ccp  education 
2 hours ago by foliovision
The Great American Meritocracy Machine – alex posecznick
"Cheating is a thing. It happens a lot. A few years ago, I was having a conversation with Gregoire, who ran the testing center at an institution I will call “Ravenwood College.” Although Ravenwood accepted SAT and ACT scores, they also had their own in-house entrance exam which was administered on site. Gregoire was meticulous in proctoring exams, checking paperwork and especially photo identification carefully. He recalled one time, when an applicant claimed to have left her ID in the Office of Admissions and said she would be right back. Later, the applicant returned with the ID and escorted by an admissions counselor, but it was an entirely different person.

She tried to persuade Gregoire that he was mistaken – that they had just spoken and she had come back as instructed. But he responded, with a roll of the eyes and a dry comment: “Okay, who did you get to take your exam for you?”

Sound familiar?

The Operation Varsity Blues admissions scandal has splatted hard in the middle of the media, and already faded from our attention. Several days of non-stop coverage and opinion, followed by fatigue. Our attention is nothing if not fickle. It is outrageous that wealthy elites and influential celebrities and their consultants have falsified documents and bribed coaches so their kids can go to extremely selective universities. And it makes sense that this would catch our collective attention. The story fundamentally undermines our trust in American meritocracy.

Maybe it should. Maybe that’s a good thing. Because the most noteworthy thing about the scandal is not the cheating. There are other important observations to be made. And there have been many who have made important observations about how affluent families already game the system in entirely legal ways. But there is more still to consider here.

I’ve spent a lot of my professional life around colleges and universities and seen wonderful and transformative things happen there. But we have to also recognize that a big part of what colleges do is sort students into piles based on merit. “Going to college” is one sort of meritorious pile that employers pay a lot of attention to; and in some circles the most relevant pile is which college we went to. And even affluent parents are under a tremendous amount of pressure to make sure their kids are sorted into the most distinctive pile. There is thus a lot of consequence here.

The contradiction, however, is that the more people obtain degrees, the less distinctive those degrees become. This pushes people to find new ways to be distinctive: a degree from this elite college, or perhaps a master’s degree. But this is an anxiety-fueled, credentials arms race – and although it can benefit colleges and universities financially, I’m not sure it is sustainable. How many loans can the average American family bear?

Elite institutions flourish when demand is high and admission low. Demand is measured by how many people you reject every year. But admission offices need to constantly balance the demands of coaches, wealthy donors, trustees, campus executives, ranking metrics, and alumni. One’s job could be at risk if the wrong donor is unhappy, or if the institution falls in a popular ranking system. We therefore need to acknowledge that colleges and universities are not the ivory towers we like to pretend they are. Not any longer. Colleges and universities are extremely competitive, profit-focused enterprises that must reconcile competing aims: educational mission on one side and market on the other. The big secret is that admission offices are under as much pressure as parents are.

This pressure shifts in less-selective spaces, but does not diminish.

Less-selective institutions flourish based on higher enrollments, because their budgets are so closely tied to the number of students sitting in their classrooms. Such institutions may have some strong standing locally, but like “Ravenwood” College, are not household names across the country. For these colleges, the consequence to a bad year could be layoffs, contractions, budget cuts, or closures. In fact, Ravenwood itself experienced some of these challenges. And this is increasingly a concern: by some accounts, private colleges are closing at the rate of 11 per year!

Public universities are not cushioned from such pressures either; many states have so severely cut funding to public higher education in recent years that they must learn to play the market like private institutions. Colleges and universities want to appear distinctive for the same reasons that we all do.

In short, we have built a massive, comprehensive infrastructure to “objectively” identify, evaluate, measure, and sort us into piles. And this sorting machinery involves high school administrations, college recruiters, College Board test designers, marketing teams, private test prep centers, university administrations, college athletics, federal regulatory agencies, voluntary accrediting agencies, magazine publishers, student loan lenders, employers, faculty, students, and their families.

Attending college does not define our value as human beings, but it would be naïve to pretend that there was no consequence to how we get sorted. When employers take note of a particular name or brand, what they are really interested in is how we’ve been continuously sorted into the right bins across our lifetimes. This scandal (and the many editorials since it broke) has revealed that this infrastructure is not objective. The notion of meritocracy has long been at the heart of the rhetoric of education in American society, but is that machinery broken?

Students of history should know that we’ve never had an objective, merit-measuring machine; this is not the story of national decline that some have been preaching. As many have been pointing out, affluent families systemically use their resources to give their kids advantage all the time – and always have. There are boarding schools, expensive test-prep programs, legacy admissions, private counselors and coaches, private violin lessons and extravagant service trips to other countries that make for a great personal statement. And despite some recent and limited interventions through affirmative action, communities of color have been systematically and appallingly excluded for centuries.

Operation Varsity Blues reveals that although the meritocracy machine is powerful and active, we should not always accept it at face value. Not only in elite space, but at all levels, we must recognize individuals for their achievements while weighing them critically and skeptically. In short, the best measure against a broken meritocracy machine is vigilant, morally-grounded people willing to challenge what they see. As long as we have the credentials arms race, there will be cheats and scammers – and the most noteworthy part of this scandal is not that some cheated, but that the wealthy perpetrators will face consequences.

Unless of course the siren call of some new big scandal distracts us."
meritocracy  colleges  universities  highered  highereducation  2019  operationvaristyblues  alexposecznick  markets  degree  sorting  ranking  rankings  society  degreeinflation  employment  elitism  objectivity  testing  standardizedtesting  cheating  credentials  scams  corruption  admissions  anxiety  education 
4 hours ago by robertogreco
Programming for People - YouTube
Learning to program no matter your skill or experience. From your first creative program through to complex computer vision setup ProgrammingforPeople helps ...
creative-coding  resource  education  learn  projection-mapping  electronics  learning  video  tutorial 
9 hours ago by ilijusin
Silicon Valley Came to Kansas Schools. That Started a Rebellion. - The New York Times
Public schools in Kansas rolled out a web-based learning platform backed by Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg. Now students have staged walkouts and sit-ins. Their parents have organized.
education  tech  Facebook  1 
11 hours ago by noiseguy

« earlier    

related tags

1  2017  2019  a  activities  adler  admissions  ai  alexdewaal  alexposecznick  alumni  anxiety  archives  art  article  atlanticcollege  austerity  aws  behavior  behaviour  body  book  books  brazil  brøndmo  budget  calculus  california  canon  capitalism  card  career_paths  ccp  censorship  change  charitableindustrialcomplex  charters  charterschools  charts  cheating  children  china  chivalry  choices  christopherlasch  chrome  civil_service  class  classism  clinicalai  cloud  code  coding  college  colleges  colleges_&_universities  community  conformity  conservatism  consignment  control  cool  cooperative  corruption  course  creative-coding  credentials  crowdfunding  css  culture  debate  deep_learning  deeplearning  degree  degreeinflation  demographics  design  development  diet  dietary  digital  discovery  diversity  documentation  economic_development  educators  electronics  elitism  em-português  emmanuel_macron  employment  ena  environmental  ethics  ethnomathematics  experience  experimental  extension  facebook  fake_facts  famine  fat  favorites  food  france  francophonie  free  freedom  french  front-end  frontend  fsib  funding  funny  games  generative  git  global  google  graduate  guide  hans  harassment  health  healthcare  heterogeneity  highered  highereducation  history  housing  humanity  humor  hunger  hunt  ibm  ibo  inbreeding  india  indigenous  individualpsychologie  inequality  infographic  infontology  information-management  infrastructure  inspiration  interactive  interesting  internationalbaccalaureate  intervention  javascript  joke  journal  journalism  journalists  js  justification  karthik.muralidharan  knowledge  language  larrysummers  learn  learning  legislatures  liberalism  library  literacy  lukas  lunch  machinelearning  make  malloc  malware  managers  mandarins  marketing  markets  mars  math  mathematics  medical  memory  mentorship  meritocracy  mikegravel  mikhailbakunin  monde  music  ncs  neoliberalism  new.york  news  newswire  nlp  noblesseoblige  node  notredame  npm  nutrition  nys  obesity  objectivity  one  online  onlinetool  open.source  operationvaristyblues  outreach  paulwolfowitz  pedagogy  petemuttigieg  peter  philanthropicindustrialcomplex  philosophy  physics  poetry  policy  policymakers  politics  population  post-wwii  poverty  power  presentation  prison  probability  product  productivity  program  programming  project  projection-mapping  psychology  public  public_service  python  quebec  racial_inequality  ranking  rankings  react  real-time  recherche  redaction  reference  resource  resources  robertrubin  rune  safety  scams  school  schools  science  security  self-importance  sexual  shame  share  siliconvalley  sjw  social  socialdarwinism  society  sorting  space  sports  standardizedtesting  statistics  success  suffering  surgery  talent  teachers  teaching  tech-culture  tech  technology  technoport  testing  tools  tragedy  training  transformational  travel  trousse  tutorial  uk  umn  unimaginative  universities  uqam  us_vt  user  utopia-dystopia  uwc  video  violence  viruses  visualization  watch  webdesign  webdev  webdevelopment  x 

Copy this bookmark: