defeat   299

« earlier    

Theresa May’s Brexit lost to the ultimate adversary: reality | Rafael Behr | Opinion | The Guardian
This has been the greatest source of frustration and shock for the rest of Europe: the spectacle of a once serious country, formerly admired for the coolness of its temperament, racing towards perilous choices while turning its face defiantly against obvious realities. That, plus the tragic irony of history creating a vacancy for visionary leadership and then filling it with May.

There is an almost perfect mismatch between the prime minister’s character and the skills she has needed. She was blunt when she should have been diplomatic; inscrutable when she needed to be candid. When imagination was required, she opted for inane repetition. When she should have reached out, she doubled down. She appeased enemies of compromise in parliament and squandered goodwill in the country.

It can be hard to disentangle the disaster Brexit might always have been from the specific mess May has made of it. There are turnings on the road to failure that she did not need to take, junctions that were missed. She did not have to embark on the article 50 route before knowing where it led. She could have drawn different red lines or changed them when they confined her to impossible choices. But while there were problems with the driver, there were also limits to how far she could get with Brexiteer maps, scrawled in crayon on the eve of the referendum with wild, higgledy lines pointing at destinations that don’t exist.

The result is that the country has been driven round in circles. The parliamentary debate on May’s deal today was a gloomier, paler version of the one that was held in January. For much of the day the Commons benches were emptier than last time. The prime minister’s exhausted voice was hoarser. The deal was rejected by a smaller margin not because it has got any better, but because fear and exhaustion are catching up with Tory MPs, overtaking their belief that something better will come along.

As for the implacables who voted against May, they were not jubilant. They inflicted a defeat, but they know also that there was no victory here for any kind of Brexit. A ruinous no deal is still technically possible, but a chain of events has been triggered that could lead to postponement or even annulment of the whole project. The prime minister’s humiliation could rebound on to every Eurosceptic fanatic who urged her ever further and faster down the road to nowhere. Brexiteers have a dangerous adversary that they cannot name. It isn’t any opposition party, or Brussels, or remainers. It is reality.
UK  EU  Brexit  withdrawalAgreement  meaningfulVote  defeat  HouseOfCommons  Parliament  backstop  Euroscepticism  MayTheresa  politics  nationalism  delusion  leadership  failure  dctagged  dc:creator=BehrRafael  intransigence 
march 2019 by petej

« earlier    

related tags

'basic  1-0  1  1985  1998  2015  2019  28  39sdaviscuphopeshitbydram  a  aek  after  again  aguero  agut  ai  airgap  america  and  andre  andy  anna  another  api  argentina  argentinas  article50  artificial  as  assessments  at  athens  atlia  australian  avengers:  avoid  backstop  bakersteve  barniermichel  bassett  bautista  bbc  beaton  becker  belinda  bencic  bethanie  betrayal  bitter  blog  bolesnick  bomb  boris  bows  bradygraham  brexit  british  brogan  but  by  bypass  call  camerondavid  canada  cancer  captain  captcha  celtic  celtic:  centrism  challenge  champions  channel  chaos  city  clan  coaching  collinsdamian  commonmarket2.0  compromise  consecutive  copa  corbynjeremy  cost?  culture  cup  curren  customsunion  cynthia  data  davis  daviscup  dc:creator=behrrafael  dc:creator=freedlandjonathan  dc:creator=harkerjoseph  dc:creator=kettlemartin  dc:creator=kuenssberglaura  dc:creator=masonpaul  dc:creator=toynbeepolly  dctagged  deadline  deal  decisions  defeating  defect  defending'  degale  degaulle  delicious  deliver  delusion  democracy  democrats  despite  detail  devastated  device  diesel  dirrell  division  dockers  donald  double  dunkirk  dup  during  economy  editorial  education  eec  election  elections2016  embarrassing  emissions  encircle  encouraging  end  endgame  englands  ensure  epa  erg  errors  essendon  eu  europe  euroscepticism  exfiltration  explain  exploit  extension  extraction  failure  feared  fifa  final  fingerprint  firebirds  fool  football  for  france  freedomofmovement  from  frustrated  ge2017  generalelection  george  germany  gerrard  geylang  github  glasgow  go  google  gop  government  governor  grand  grest  groves  grugq  guardian  gutwrenching  hack  hacking  halts  hammondphilip  hands  hardbrexit  has  heartbreaking  helps  historic  history  hockey:  houseofcommons  how  http://telegraph.feedsportal.com/c/32726/f/568360/s/4928d5c0/sc/13/l/0l0stelegra  http://www.espnfc.com/singapore-s-league/story/2572116/sleague-young-lions-off-bottom  human  humiliation  ice  ifttt  illinois  image  immigration  imperialism  in  incompetence  india  intelligence  into  intolerance  intransigence  iraq  isis  islam  islamic  islamicrepublic  ivo  japan  jay  jihad  john  johnsonboris  karlovic  kazakhstan  labourparty  last  leadership  league  learning  liberalism  limit  lions  looms  loss  lumsden  machine  mahut  maia  making  malthousekim  man  manchester  marathon  match  may's  may  maytheresa  may’s  meaningfulvote  memorandum:  message  microsoft  midtjylland  migration  mobil  monumental  moscow  mps  msps  much  multiculturalism  murray  muslims  nadal  nationalidentity  nationalism  nature  negotiations  neoliberalism  networks  neural  new  news  nicolas  nixon  no  noconfidence  nodeal  norway  norwayplus  not  nova  novak  nox  of  on  one  open  opposition  out  over  overcomes  overtake  p1  parliament  paul  pentesting  people  peoplesvote  peter  plan  planb  points  politicaldeclaration  politics  posix  presidential  profession  psychology  quarterfinals  queer  radical  rafael  rangers'  rankings  rare  re  recaptcha  recognition  redlines  rees-moggjacob  referee  referendum  reform  relevance  remain  repeat  report:  reveals  rf  roberto  rodriguez  rues  ryan  s.league  sadhguru  saints  sam  samsung  scanner  scotia  security  seeds  send  shares  shed  side  sight  singlemarket  sixth  slumps  softbrexit  somdev  source  southampton  spares  spartak  special  speech2text  sport  springstatement  state  stay  steven  storm  stosur  strategy  sub  suffer  suffers  super  swifts  swinney  syria  tears  tempest  tennis  territory  terrorism  thanos  the  theresa  theright  throwing  to  top  toryparty  trade  trailer:  traitor  trio  trump  tumbling  uk  unbeaten  unix  update  victory  violation  vote  war  was  wikipedia  will  williamsongavin  wimbledon  windows  with  withdrawalagreement  work  worldwarii  xkcd  young  yuki  zealand  zolwa2r 

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: