commentary   9779

« earlier    

The Intellectual We Deserve – Current Affairs | Culture & Politics
Jordan Peterson — in case any friends express affinity for his horse shit
politics  culture  commentary 
2 days ago by inrgbwetrust
Mistakes happen for a reason | Bloody shovel
Which leads me to this article by Scott Alexander. He elaborates on an idea by one of his ingroup about their being two ways of looking at things, “mistake theory” and “conflict theory”. Mistake theory claims that political opposition comes from a different understanding of issues: if people had the same amount of knowledge and proper theories to explain it, they would necessarily agree. Conflict theory states that people disagree because their interests conflict, the conflict is zero-sum so there’s no reason to agree, the only question is how to resolve the conflict.

I was speechless. I am quite used to Mr. Alexander and his crowd missing the point on purpose, but this was just too much. Mistake theory and Conflict theory are not parallel things. “Mistake theory” is just the natural, tribalist way of thinking. It assumes an ingroup, it assumes the ingroup has a codified way of thinking about things, and it interprets all disagreement as a lack of understanding of the obviously objective and universal truths of the ingroup religion. There is a reason why liberals call “ignorant” all those who disagree with them. Christians used to be rather more charitable on this front and asked for “faith”, which they also assumed was difficult to achieve.

Conflict theory is one of the great achievements of the human intellect; it is an objective, useful and predictively powerful way of analyzing human disagreement. There is a reason why Marxist historiography revolutionized the world and is still with us: Marx made a strong point that human history was based on conflict. Which is true. It is tautologically true. If you understand evolution it stands to reason that all social life is about conflict. The fight for genetical survival is ultimately zero-sum, and even in those short periods of abundance when it is not, the fight for mating supremacy is very much zero-sum, and we are all very much aware of that today. Marx focused on class struggle for political reasons, which is wrong, but his focus on conflict was a gust of fresh air for those who enjoy objective analysis.

Incidentally the early Chinese thinkers understood conflict theory very well, which is why Chinese civilization is still around, the oldest on earth. A proper understanding of conflict does not come without its drawbacks, though. Mistakes happen for a reason. Pat Buchanan actually does understand why USG open the doors to trade with China. Yes, Whig history was part of it, but that’s just the rhetoric used to justify the idea. The actual motivation to trade with China was making money short term. Lots of money. Many in the Western elite have made huge amounts of money with the China trade. Money that conveniently was funneled to whichever political channels it had to do in order to keep the China trade going. Even without Whig history, even without the clueless idea that China would never become a political great power, the short-term profits to be made were big enough to capture the political process in the West and push for it. Countries don’t have interests: people do.

That is true, and should be obvious, but there are dangers to the realization. There’s a reason why people dislike cynics. People don’t want to know the truth. It’s hard to coordinate around the truth, especially when the truth is that humans are selfish assholes constantly in conflict. Mistakes happen because people find it convenient to hide the truth; and “mistake theory” happens because policing the ingroup patterns of thought, limiting the capability of people of knowing too much, is politically useful. The early Chinese kingdoms developed a very sophisticated way of analyzing objective reality. The early kingdoms were also full of constant warfare, rebellions and elite betrayals; all of which went on until the introduction in the 13th century of a state ideology (neoconfucianism) based on complete humbug and a massively unrealistic theory on human nature. Roman literature is refreshingly objective and to the point. Romans were also murderous bastards who assassinated each other all the time. It took the massive pile of nonsense which we call the Christian canon to get Europeans to cooperate in a semi-stable basis.

But guess what? Conflict theory also exists for a reason. And the reason is to extricate oneself from the ingroup, to see things how they actually are, and to undermine the state religion from the outside. Marxists came up with conflict theory because they knew they had little to expect from fighting from within the system. Those low-status workers who still regarded their mainstream society as being the ingroup they very sharply called “alienated”, and by using conflict theory they showed what the ingroup ideology was actually made of. Pat Buchanan and his cuck friends should take the message and stop assuming that the elite is playing for the same team as they are. The global elite, of America and its vassals, is not mistaken. They are playing for themselves: to raise their status above yours, to drop their potential rivals into eternal misery and to rule forever over them. China, Syria, and everything else, is about that.
gnon  right-wing  commentary  china  asia  current-events  politics  ideology  coalitions  government  statesmen  leviathan  law  axioms  authoritarianism  usa  democracy  antidemos  trade  nationalism-globalism  elite  error  whiggish-hegelian  left-wing  paleocon  history  mostly-modern  world-war  impetus  incentives  interests  self-interest  signaling  homo-hetero  hypocrisy  meta:rhetoric  debate  language  universalism-particularism  tribalism  us-them  zero-positive-sum  absolute-relative  class  class-warfare  communism  polanyi-marx  westminster  realness  cynicism-idealism  truth  coordination  cooperate-defect  medieval  confucian  iron-age  mediterranean  the-classics  literature  canon  europe  the-great-west-whale  occident  sinosphere  orient  nl-and-so-can-you  world  conquest-empire  malthus  status  egalitarianism-hierarchy  evolution  conceptual-vocab  christianity  society  anthropology  metabuch  hidden-motives  X-not-about-Y  dark-arts  illusion  martial  war  cohesion  military  correlation  causation  roots  japan  comparison  long-short-run 
5 days ago by nhaliday
Interview with Bruce Sterling — “There will not be a Singularity.”
“It is as if you are trying to build a cargo aircraft, and you insist that it should also lay eggs because it can fly.”
ai  tech  commentary 
5 days ago by inrgbwetrust

« earlier    

related tags

&  (ibm  2016-election  2018  absolute-relative  academe  aerobic_exercise  aesthetics  africa  ai-control  ai  alien-character  allodium  amazon  america  amusing  analogy  analytical-holistic  and  anglo  anglosphere  announcement  anthropology  anti-corporate-globalizaiton  antidemos  aphorism  arms  art  article  asia  attention  audio  audio_stuff  authoritarianism  auto-bio-echo  automation  axioms  backup  barons  biases  big-peeps  big-surf  bio  biodet  biophysical-econ  biotech  blogging  britain  broad-econ  business-models  business  canada  canon  capitalism  car  career  cars  causation  change  charity  china  christianity  citizen+journalism  civil-liberty  civilization  class-warfare  class  cliometrics  clippings  clojure  cloud  coalitions  cohesion  cold-war  comments  communism  comparison  compensation  competition  computer_science  computing  concepts  conceptual-vocab  confucian  conquest-empire  contradiction  contrarianism  cooperate-defect  coordination  corporation  correlation  corruption  cost-benefit  cost-disease  cotton  cracker-econ  creative  creditbureau  crispr  critique  css  culture+shock  culture  current-events  cyberattacks  cybersecurity  cynicism-idealism  dark-arts  data  death  debate  debt  deep-learning  deep-materialism  deepgoog  defense  definite-planning  democracy  design  deterrence  developing-world  development  dimensionality  dirty-hands  discussion  dogs  douthatish  drugs  duplication  early-modern  economics  economy  econotariat  eden  education  egalitarianism-hierarchy  egt  election  elite  emotion  energy-resources  engineering  enhancement  enlightenment-renaissance-restoration-reformation  enterprise  entrepreneurialism  envy  equilibrium  error  essay  ethics  eu  europe  events  evidence-based  evolution  exercise_physiology  explanans  explanation  exploratory  facebook  fake-news  farmers-and-foragers  featured  fiction  field-study  fighting  flux-stasis  freespeech  frontier  future  futurism  gallic  games  gaming  garett-jones  gdp  gender  generalization  genetics  genomics  germanic  gibbon  globalization  gnon  gnxp  google  government  growth-econ  gutenberg  hanson  happiness  hard-tech  headphones  health  heterodox  hidden-motives  higher-ed  hiit  history  hmm  hn  homo-hetero  housing  hsu  human-capital  human-ml  humor  hypocrisy  ideology  illusion  impetus  incentives  independent+media  individualism-collectivism  industrial-revolution  industry  indymedia  inequality  innovation  input-output  insightful  inspiration  institutions  interdisciplinary  interesting  interests  internet  intervention  interview  intricacy  invasion  investing  iran  iraq-syria  iron-age  islam  israel  jackets  japan  jobs  journalism  judaism  knowledge  labor  language  law  leadership  learning  left-wing  lesswrong  leviathan  liberalarts  library  links  literary-criticism  literature  local-global  lol  long-short-run  long-term  machine-learning  macro  magnitude  malthus  management  marginal-rev  marginal  market-power  marketing  markets  martial  meaningness  media  medicine  medieval  meditation  mediterranean  mena  mental_health  meta-analysis  meta-literature  meta:rhetoric  meta:war  metabuch  metrics  microfoundations  microphones  microsoft  migrant-crisis  migration  military  miri-cfar  mobile  models  mokyr-allen-mccloskey  moloch  moments  monetary-fiscal  money  morality  mostly-modern  mp3  multi  musk  mutation  n-factor  narrative  nascent-state  nationalism-globalism  network-structure  new+media  new-religion  news  newspapers  nibble  nl-and-so-can-you  noahrothman  noble-lie  nuclear  nyt  objektbuch  occident  off-convex  offbeat  old-anglo  open-access  open-closed  opinion  opioidepidemic  optimism  optimization  oracle  orfe  org:biz  org:bv  org:econlib  org:edu  org:mag  organization  organizing  orient  other-xtian  outcome-risk  ownership  paleocon  paradox  parasites-microbiome  pastiche  patristics  people  pessimism  philosophy  piketty  planning  podcast  poetry  polanyi-marx  polarization  policy  polisci  political-econ  political  politics-of-higher-ed  politics  population-genetics  posts  pre-ww2  presentation  princeton  privacy  pro-rata  productivity  progress  propaganda  protestant-catholic  pseudoscience  psychology  quality  questions  quotes  race  racism  randy-ayndy  ranking  rather-interesting  rationality  ratty  react  readinglist  realness  recruiting  red-queen  redistribution  reference  reflection  regulation  religion  replication  research-program  research  review  revolution  rhetoric  right-wing  risk  roots  rot  s-factor  saas  sanfrancisco  sanjeev-arora  sap  sass  satire  scale  science  scifi-fantasy  scitariat  securities  security  self-interest  selfdriving  sex  sexuality  signaling  sinosphere  skunkworks  social+media  social-capital  social-choice  social-psych  social  social_science  socialism  society  socs-and-mops  software  speakers  spearhead  speculation  speedometer  ssc  stagnation  startup  startups  state-of-art  statesmen  status  stories  strategy  straussian  street-fighting  strength_training  study  styleguide  stylized-facts  sulla  summary  supply-demand  sv  synthetic  teaching  tech  technical  technologists  technology  terrorism  the-classics  the-great-west-whale  the-monster  the-south  the-west  theos  theruin  thiel  things  thinking  time-preference  time-series  to-do  to-read  tools  top  track-record  trade  tradeoffs  tradition  trans  trends  tribalism  trump  truth  tv  twitter  ui  uncertainty  universalism-particularism  university  urban-rural  us-them  us_army  usa  ux  values  venture  video  volo-avolo  war  web-dev  web  webdesign  webdev  westminster  whiggish-hegelian  white-paper  winner-take-all  wire-guided  wisdom  womenintech  wonkish  wordpress  work  workshop  world-war  world  x-not-about-y  yvain  zeitgeist  zero-positive-sum  🌞 

Copy this bookmark: