centralamerica   442

« earlier    

RT : So rare and important to hear about the reality of what the US did to / in the 80s onwards;…
CentralAmerica  Honduras  from twitter
december 2018 by kcarruthers
Monthly Review | Marx on Immigration
Marx did not elaborate on his reasons for writing that Irish immigration reduced English workers’ wages. He implied that the cause was an oversupply of manual laborers, but his other statements indicate that he considered English xenophobia and the resulting antagonism among workers an even greater problem. The important point, however, is that he was not blaming lower wages on the immigrants themselves; for him the culprits were the colonial system that drove Irish workers to England, and the exploitation of these workers once they arrived.

The same considerations apply in the United States today. The main difference is the addition of legal status as a factor in setting wage levels—the laws that now make work “illegal” for millions of immigrant workers. Immigrant rights advocates may feel it is expedient to cite academic economists like Peri who downplay or deny the downward pressure exerted on wages by the exploitation of undocumented workers. It is not. As Columbia University economist Moshe Adler has noted, this approach does nothing to convince the many U.S. citizens who work in occupations with large numbers of undocumented immigrants and therefore “know firsthand that [exploitation of immigrant workers] puts direct downward pressure on their own wages.”16 Far from helping the movement, citing Peri only adds to these workers’ distrust and resentment toward middle-class immigrant rights advocates.17 More importantly, this approach distracts attention from efforts to address the real issues: the root causes of immigration in U.S. foreign policy, the super-exploitation of immigrant workers, and the common interests of immigrant and native-born workers.


In his 1870 letter, Marx described what he then considered the overriding priority for labor organizing in England: “to make the English workers realize that for them the national emancipation of Ireland is not a question of abstract justice or humanitarian sentiment but the first condition of their own social emancipation.” His closing words of advice to Meyer and Vogt were similar: “You have wide field in America for work along the same lines. A coalition of the German workers with the Irish workers (and of course also with the English and American workers who are prepared to accede to it) is the greatest achievement you could bring about now.” This internationalist and class-based perspective has lost none of its good sense in the century and a half since it was written.
Marx  immigration  Ireland  England  USA  Mexico  CentralAmerica  migration  pay  wages  competition  supply  demand  language  skills  racism  discrimination  legal  deportation  workingClass  xenophobia  employers  sanctions  tradeUnions  internationalism  rights 
november 2018 by petej

« earlier    

related tags

#see  #travel  2017  abuse  aclu  actblue  america  animalhistory  ap.com  archaeology  archives  arctic  arcticocean  argentina  asia  association  asylum  avocado  bananas  bananas:diseases  bars  bbc  belize  blogs  bm  border  borderpatrol  borders  boston  bostonglobe  botany  bush  business  c.schlesinger  cabbage  caribbean  carrot  cbp  chartercities  cheese  chicagobulls  children  china  cia  ciudadjuarez  climate-change  climate  cnn  codex  colla  competition  congress  conspiracytheory  cornell  corruption  cos  cospost  cr  crime  dance-parties  data  decline  deforestation  demand  deportation  digitalarchive  digitalhumanities  diigo  disappeared  discrimination  dominicanrepublic  donaldtrump  dreamwidth  drugs  dystopia  ecommerce  education  ejc  election  elpaso  elsalvador  employers  england  enterprise  environment  environmentalhistory  españa  eu  facebook  film  films  foreignaffairs  foreignpolicy  fox  ft  gangs  gender  greece  guatemala  haiti  harina  heartofpalm  history  histscimed  honduras  ice  immigrants  immigration  indigenas  international  internationalism  internets  interventionism  ireland  japan  jobs  journalism  justice  kb  korea  language  latinamerica  latinos  law  lawenforcement  lawsuit  legal  longreads  manufacturing  marchforstolenchildren  marx  masa  maya  mesoamerica  mexico  mexicocity  migrants  migration  military  mncs  money/laundering  morocco  muckreads  murder  narcotrafficing  narcotraficantes  nationalgeographic  nbc  nepal  news  newyorker  newyorkmagazine  newyorktimes  ngos  nicaragua  nightclubs  northkorea  oil/gas  op-ed  orangeetc  pacificstandard  panama  parents  pay  paymentgateway  payments  photos  police  politics  portugal  pragmatism  protests  psychology  racism  rall  refugees  research  reuters  review  rights  sanctions  school  sexism  sexuality  skills  slate  slaw  social-media  sorosgeorge  southamerica  spain  supply  teaching  technology  tedrall  theatlantic  theconversation  thedailybeast  theeconomist  theguardian  torture  tpp  trade  tradeunions  trafficking  trump  trumpdonald  ufco  unitedstates  us-latinam  us  usa  violence  wages  wapo  war/on/drugs  war  wildlife  women  workingclass  xenophobia 

Copy this bookmark: