britain   7643

« earlier    

Three Types of Societies, Three Types of Governments – The Neo-Ciceronian Times
Having said all of this, I would then note that among the many other things which are influenced by both genes and surroundings are the broad types of governmental forms (specifically, the three “classical” types of monarchic, aristocratic, and democratic) which tend to be “inhering” traits of the peoples who exhibit them. Several months ago, I touched on this in a post which could be thought of as a “case study,” in this case the specific question of why medieval and renaissance republicanism seems to have been limited to high-IQ Germanic populations. Why do cultures – and I’m going to bring the focus specifically to European, European-derived, and near-kin Indo-European populations – exhibit preferences for one type over the others? Are there cultural reasons which may predispose a nation in a certain governmental direction?

Let me first note the three general types of societies which a culture may exhibit, in broad terms, within the larger unit of a civilisation (such as, e.g., Western civilisation or Indian civilisation, etc.).

First, you have what I call core groups. These are groups which, as the name suggests, inhabit central areas within their larger civilisational setting, often hailing from the urheimat of their clade, or from areas which were settled early on in cases of migration. They tend to be more centralised in their cultural and social organisation, and may tend toward the baroque, or even decadence.

Second, you have marcher groups. These cultures exist on the edges of their clade’s contiguous settled areas, facing outward toward alien groups. As a result, they are often more heavily militarised, exhibiting forms of organisation which tends towards enhancing military preparedness and effectiveness.

Third, you have pioneer groups. These cultures usually develop when a clade is undergoing an expansion phase into new lands, and involves a great degree of decentralisation and political experimentation. These groups tend towards greater levels of “rugged individualism” as they find themselves thrown upon their own resources for survival and expansion.

I believe that we can see some tendencies (keeping in mind that they’re just tendencies) that each type of society has toward the governmental forms they prefer. Core groups will tend towards monarchy, marcher groups toward aristocracy, and pioneer groups toward democracy. We should also note that groups can change their configuration over time as their environment changes. Likewise, within a political unit, we can also discern that subgroups of the dominant culture may begin to diverge because of varied roles.


The important thing to note is that even though we live in a world which is much smaller due to globalisation, the existence of marcher (and even pioneer) nations has not ended. Despite the high degree of world development, not every state and not every nation within the various states are necessarily core societies whose culture/genetic complex would tolerate absolutist authority systems. There are still fracture areas between civilisations and clades which will militate toward aristocratic systems entailing personal loyalty and distributed military power. It is always possible in the future that (depending on how bad any Great Reset event might end up being) situations involving rapid expansion and the formation of (relatively) more democratic pioneer-type societies may still occur. One of the goals for neoreaction is to seek to bring order to the chaos. This order will demand greater authority for rulers. Even in democratic-tending populations, the foolish errors of universal suffrage, egalitarianism, and mass society must avoid repetition. Yet, those who would desire absolute monarchy may have to suffer the existence of aristocratic republics and feudal organisations. Nevertheless, the goal should always be to keep the momentum moving away from the democratisation and egalitarianism we currently see and towards more orderly, stable, and hierarchical governing systems.
gnon  politics  polisci  institutions  ideology  race  culture  society  social-structure  things  phalanges  democracy  antidemos  europe  germanic  the-great-west-whale  gavisti  civil-liberty  geography  thinking  individualism-collectivism  frontier  aristos  egalitarianism-hierarchy  gallic  britain  class  russia  india  asia  migration  MENA  usa  anglo  anglosphere  optimate  expansionism  conquest-empire  decentralized  military  government  correlation  redistribution  n-factor  cultural-dynamics  leviathan  martial  the-west  the-south  authoritarianism  feudal  history  medieval  prediction  revolution  elite 
5 days ago by nhaliday
Caution on “Lexit”
a left critique of a left critique of the EU
britain  brexit 
6 days ago by daniel.c.mccarthy
Occupiers Liability
Another good summary of landowner liability
UK  britain  england  wales  scotland  landowners  land  rights  law  legislation  access  liability 
9 days ago by Nachimir
Far more Britons live in Europe than government statistics suggest
The UK’s Office for National Statistics (ONS) has recently produced estimates of the number of British citizens living in the European Union (EU). The numbers,…
world  Britain  from instapaper
26 days ago by ree

« earlier    

related tags

17th_century  18th_century  2014  2016-election  2018  20th_century  20thcentury  absolute-relative  access  africa  age-of-discovery  ai-control  ai  albion  alexds  alien-character  altruism  american-culture  anglo  anglosphere  anthropology  antidemos  antisemitism  aphorism  appeasement  archaeology  architecture  archive  aristos  asia  austerity  authoritarianism  automation  backup  banking  battle  behavioral-gen  belgium  biases  big-peeps  biodet  biotech  bitcoin  black  bloomberg  books  borders  brad.delong  brexit  british  buddhism  buildings  business  cambridgealaytica  cambridgeanalytica  canada  canon  cartogram  checks  cheddar  china  christianity  civil-liberty  class-warfare  class  classic  climate-change  coalitions  cohesion  colonialism  coming-apart  commentary  community  comparison  compensation  computing  conquest-empire  conservation  control  corbyn  correlation  crime  crooked  cryptocurrency  cultural-dynamics  culture-war  culture  cycles  cynicism-idealism  data  datavis  death  debates  decentralized  deep-materialism  democracy  direct-indirect  discussion  disease  distribution  dna  drugs  duh  duty  early-modern  economic_history  economics  economy  econotariat  education  egalitarianism-hierarchy  eire  election2017  electionresults  elections  elite  embodied  emotion  ends-means  england  english  enhancement  enlightenment-renaissance-restoration-reformation  environment  environmental-effects  envy  eu  europe  events  evolution  expansionism  facebook  farmers-and-foragers  fashun  fatalities  feudal  finance  finland  flight  food  foreign-lang  foreign-policy  forensics  forest  forms-instances  forth  france  frontier  funny  gallic  garett-jones  gas  gavisti  gender  genetics  genomics  geography  geometry  geopolitics  germanic  gnon  gnosis-logos  god-man-beast-victim  government  grammar  great-powers  grotesque  guardian  gwas  haidt  hanson  hardware  harvest  hate  health  healthcare  history  hmm  homeless  homelessness  homepage  hurricane  identity-politics  ideology  idiot!  idiot  immigration  imperalism  imperialism  impetus  india  individualism-collectivism  industrial_revolution  industrialrevolution  industry  inequality  info-dynamics  infrastructure  injured  injury  innovation  institutions  interview  intricacy  iq  ireland  is-ought  israel  janus  jargon  journos-pundits  knowledge  korea  labour  land  landowners  language  law  left-wing  legislation  letters  leviathan  liability  linguistics  linkfodder  links  list  literature  local-global  locamotive  london  long-term  longform  love-hate  malaise  man  maps  marginal-rev  markzuckerberg  martial  math  maxim-gun  meaningness  media  medieval  mediterranean  memes(ew)  memetics  memoirs  memory  mena  metrics  microcomputing  migrant-crisis  migration  military  miri-cfar  models  moments  monarchy-envy  money  mostly-modern  multi  museum  museumofsovereignty  mutiny  mystic  n-factor  nationalism-globalism  network-structure  new-religion  news  nietzschean  nigellefarge  nl-and-so-can-you  nostalgia  oceans  of  old-anglo  opcw  optimate  org:nat  origins  orwell  paleocon  paradox  parallax  patho-altruism  people  personal  pessimism  phalanges  philosophy  photo  photography  pic  pinker  planning  platform  poetry  policy  polisci  political-econ  politics  population  populism  post-colonialism  poverty  power  pre-history  pre  prediction  preflight  priors-posteriors  privacy  privilege  pro-rata  programming  propaganda  proposition  psychographic  psychology  pub  public_engagement  q-n-a  q1  questions  quotes  race  racism  raf  rail  rambling  ranking  ratty  realness  realpolitik  redistribution  reference  referendum  regencyandaround  regulation  religion  replication  restoration  retrocomputing  revisionism  revolution  right-wing  rights  risk  roots  rot  royal-wedding  russia  russian  s-factor  sartre  scale  scary  science  scitariat  scotland  scramble  self-interest  sewer  sex  sexuality  simulation  sinosphere  skripal  skull  social-psych  social-structure  social  sociality  socialmedia  society  sociology  sovereignty  space  spearhead  speculation  speedometer  spices  spitfire  spreading  ssc  stackex  stamps  statesmen  status  straussian  study  stupidity  stylized-facts  summary  sweden  tech  teenagers  television  telos-atelos  the-devil  the-great-west-whale  the-self  the-south  the-west  theory-of-mind  theos  theresamay  things  thinking  track-record  train  transportation  trap  travel  trends  tribalism  troll  trump  trust  truth  twitter  uk  ums  unaccompaniedminors  united-states  unitedstates  universal-healthcare  universalism-particularism  us-them  usa  user  value  values  vampire-squid  video  vocab  wales  walk  walking  wapo  water  westminster  whole-partial-many  wiki  wikipedia  windrush  wisdom  work  working  world  writing  wsj  yvain  zeitgeist  zimbabwe  🐸 

Copy this bookmark: