analogy   861

« earlier    

The Space Trilogy - Wikipedia
Out of the Silent Planet:

Weston makes a long speech justifying his proposed invasion of Malacandra on "progressive" and evolutionary grounds, which Ransom attempts to translate into Malacandrian, thus laying bare the brutality and crudity of Weston's ambitions.

Oyarsa listens carefully to Weston's speech and acknowledges that the scientist is acting out of a sense of duty to his species, and not mere greed. This renders him more mercifully disposed towards the scientist, who accepts that he may die while giving Man the means to continue. However, on closer examination Oyarsa points out that Weston's loyalty is not to Man's mind – or he would equally value the intelligent alien minds already inhabiting Malacandra, instead of seeking to displace them in favour of humanity; nor to Man's body – since, as Weston is well aware of and at ease with, Man's physical form will alter over time, and indeed would have to in order to adapt to Weston's programme of space exploration and colonisation. It seems then that Weston is loyal only to "the seed" – Man's genome – which he seeks to propagate. When Oyarsa questions why this is an intelligible motivation for action, Weston's eloquence fails him and he can only articulate that if Oyarsa does not understand Man's basic loyalty to Man then he, Weston, cannot possibly instruct him.



The rafts or floating islands are indeed Paradise, not only in the sense that they provide a pleasant and care-free life (until the arrival of Weston) but also in the sense that Ransom is for weeks and months naked in the presence of a beautiful naked woman without once lusting after her or being tempted to seduce her. This is because of the perfection in that world.

The plot thickens when Professor Weston arrives in a spaceship and lands in a part of the ocean quite close to the Fixed Land. He at first announces to Ransom that he is a reformed man, but appears to still be in search of power. Instead of the strictly materialist attitude he displayed when first meeting Ransom, he asserts he had become aware of the existence of spiritual beings and pledges allegiance to what he calls the "Life-Force." Ransom, however, disagrees with Weston's position that the spiritual is inherently good, and indeed Weston soon shows signs of demonic possession.

In this state, the possessed Weston finds the Queen and tries to tempt her into defying Maleldil's orders by spending a night on the Fixed Land. Ransom, perceiving this, believes that he must act as a counter-tempter. Well versed in the Bible and Christian theology, Ransom realises that if the pristine Queen, who has never heard of Evil, succumbs to the tempter's arguments, the Fall of Man will be re-enacted on Perelandra. He struggles through day after day of lengthy arguments illustrating various approaches to temptation, but the demonic Weston shows super-human brilliance in debate (though when "off-duty" he displays moronic, asinine behaviour and small-minded viciousness) and moreover appears never to need sleep.

With the demonic Weston on the verge of winning, the desperate Ransom hears in the night what he gradually realises is a Divine voice, commanding him to physically attack the Tempter. Ransom is reluctant, and debates with the divine (inner) voice for the entire duration of the night. A curious twist is introduced here; whereas the name "Ransom" is said to be derived from the title "Ranolf's Son", it can also refer to a reward given in exchange for a treasured life. Recalling this, and recalling that his God would (and has) sacrificed Himself in a similar situation, Ransom decides to confront the Tempter outright.

Ransom attacks his opponent bare-handed, using only physical force. Weston's body is unable to withstand this despite the Tempter's superior abilities of rhetoric, and so the Tempter flees. Ultimately Ransom chases him over the ocean, Weston fleeing and Ransom chasing on the backs of giant and friendly fish. During a fleeting truce, the "real" Weston appears to momentarily re-inhabit his body, and recount his experience of Hell, wherein the damned soul is not consigned to pain or fire, as supposed by popular eschatology, but is absorbed into the Devil, losing all independent existence.
fiction  scifi-fantasy  tip-of-tongue  literature  big-peeps  religion  christianity  theos  space  xenobio  analogy  myth  eden  deep-materialism  new-religion  sanctity-degradation  civil-liberty  exit-voice  speaking  truth  realness  embodied  fighting  old-anglo  group-selection  war  paying-rent  counter-revolution  morality  parable  competition  the-basilisk  gnosis-logos  individualism-collectivism  language  physics  science  evolution  conquest-empire  self-interest  hmm  intricacy  analytical-holistic  tradeoffs  paradox  heterodox  narrative  philosophy  expansionism  genetics  duty  us-them  interests  nietzschean 
6 weeks ago by nhaliday
Sacred text as cultural genome: an inheritance mechanism and method for studying cultural evolution: Religion, Brain & Behavior: Vol 7, No 3
Yasha M. Hartberg & David Sloan Wilson

Any process of evolution requires a mechanism of inheritance for the transmission of information across generations and the expression of phenotypes during each generation. Genetic inheritance mechanisms have been studied for over a century but mechanisms of inheritance for human cultural evolution are far less well understood. Sacred religious texts have the properties required for an inheritance system. They are replicated across generations with high fidelity and are transcribed into action every generation by the invocation and interpretation of selected passages. In this article we borrow concepts and methods from genetics and epigenetics to study the “expressed phenotypes” of six Christian churches that differ along a conservative–progressive axis. Their phenotypic differences, despite drawing upon the same sacred text, can be explained in part by differential expression of the sacred text. Since the invocation and interpretation of sacred texts are often well preserved, our methods allow the expressed phenotypes of religious groups to be studied at any time and place in history.
study  interdisciplinary  bio  sociology  cultural-dynamics  anthropology  religion  christianity  theos  protestant-catholic  politics  ideology  correlation  organizing  institutions  analogy  genetics  genomics  epigenetics  comparison  culture  pdf  piracy  density  flexibility  noble-lie  deep-materialism  new-religion  universalism-particularism  homo-hetero  hypocrisy  group-selection  models  coordination  info-dynamics  evolution  impact  left-wing  right-wing  time  tradition  spreading  sanctity-degradation  coalitions  trees  usa  social-capital  hari-seldon  wisdom  the-basilisk  frequency 
9 weeks ago by nhaliday
MAC/FAC: A Model of Similarity-Based Retrieval - Forbus - 1995 - Cognitive Science - Wiley Online Library
We present a model of similarity-based retrieval that attempts to capture three seemingly contradictory psychological phenomena: (a) structural commonalities are weighed more heavily than surface commonalities in similarity judgments for items in working memory; (b) in retrieval, superficial similarity is more important than structural similarity; and yet (c) purely structural (analogical) remindings e sometimes experienced. Our model, MAC/FAC, explains these phenomena in terms of a two-stage process. The first stage uses a computationally cheap, non-structural matcher to filter candidate long-term memory items. It uses content vectors, a redundant encoding of structured representations whose dot product estimates how well the corresponding structural representations will match. The second stage uses SME (structure-mapping engine) to compute structural matches on the handful of items found by the first stage. We show the utility of the MAC/FAC model through a series of computational experiments: (a) We demonstrate that MAC/FAC can model patterns of access found in psychological data; (b) we argue via sensitivity analyses that these simulation results rely on the theory; and (c) we compare the performance of MAC/FAC with ARCS, an alternate model of similarity-based retrieval, and demonstrate that MAC/FAC explains the data better than ARCS. Finally, we discuss limitations and possible extensions of the model, relationships with other recent retrieval models, and place MAC/FAC in the context of other recent work on the nature of similarity.
november 2017 by tonyyet
If Quantum Computers are not Possible Why are Classical Computers Possible? | Combinatorics and more
As most of my readers know, I regard quantum computing as unrealistic. You can read more about it in my Notices AMS paper and its extended version (see also this post) and in the discussion of Puzzle 4 from my recent puzzles paper (see also this post). The amazing progress and huge investment in quantum computing (that I presented and update  routinely in this post) will put my analysis to test in the next few years.
tcstariat  mathtariat  org:bleg  nibble  tcs  cs  computation  quantum  volo-avolo  no-go  contrarianism  frontier  links  quantum-info  analogy  comparison  synthesis  hi-order-bits  speedometer  questions  signal-noise 
november 2017 by nhaliday

« earlier    

related tags

1985  2002  2017-08-28  2017-08-30  2017-09-01  2017  :/  academia  acm  acmtariat  adversarial  aesthetic  africa  age-generation  agri-mindset  agriculture  ai  albion  algorithm  allodium  alt-inst  altruism  analysis  analytical-holistic  anatomy  anglo  anglosphere  animals  animated  anomie  anthropic  anthropology  antidemos  aphorism  app  application  approach  approximation  archaics  architect  ariadnesthread  ariely  aristos  arms  art  article  asia  associative  attention  attribution  audience  authoritarianism  autism  automation  axioms  backup  banking  barons  behavioral-gen  big-peeps  big-picture  bio  biodet  biology  biotech  bits  blowhards  book  books  bounded-cognition  brain-scan  brianeno  britain  broad-econ  canon  capital  career  cc:0  cell  change  chart  children  china  christianity  civil-liberty  civilization  cjones-like  class-warfare  clever-rats  cliometrics  clipart  clothes  coalitions  cocktail  code  coffee  cog-psych  cognition  cogsci  cohesion  cold-war  coming-apart  commentary  communication  comparison  compensation  competition  complex-systems  composer  composition  computation  computer  computerscience  concept  conceptual-vocab  confucian  conquest-empire  consciousness  constraint  contrarianism  cooperate-defect  coordination  correlation  corruption  counter-revolution  counterfactual  creativity  critique  crooked  crypto  cryptography  cs  cultural-dynamics  culture-war  culture  current-events  curse  cycles  dafna_shahaf  dan  darwinian  data  database  dating  debate  debugging  dedre_gentner  deep-learning  deep-materialism  definite-planning  definition  definitions  degrees-of-freedom  democracy  dennett  density  dialectic  dictionary  diet  digital  digitalpainting  dimensionality  dirty-hands  discrete  discussion  disease  display  distribution  diversity  domain  donaldtrump  dopost  douglas_hofstadter  douthatish  drama  drawing  duality  duty  early-modern  econ-metrics  economics  econotariat  eden  education  efficiency  egalitarianism-hierarchy  egt  elite  embodied  endo-exo  endogenous-exogenous  enhancement  entropy-like  envy  epidemiology  epigenetics  epistemic  error  essay  ethanol  eu  europe  evolution  evopsych  example  examples  exit-voice  expansionism  experiment  explain  explanation  exposition  facts  farmers-and-foragers  feedback  feudal  fiction  fighting  finance  fitness  flexibility  font  food  foreign-policy  formal-values  free-riding  free  frequency  frontier  gardener  gear  gearbox  gedanken  gender-diff  gender  general-survey  genetics  genomics  germanic  gesture  giants  gibbon  gif  git  gnon  gnosis-logos  gnxp  goodiepal  gotchas  government  gowers  grad-school  great-powers  greek  gregory-clark  group-selection  growth-econ  gt-101  gwern  habit  hanson  hari-seldon  health  heavy-industry  heterodox  heuristic  hi-order-bits  high-dimension  higher-ed  history  hitler  hmm  hofstrader  homo-hetero  horror  howto  hsu  human-capital  hypocrisy  idea  ideas  identity-politics  identity  ideology  ifttt  ikea  image  immune  impact  important  incentives  india  individualism-collectivism  industrial-revolution  inequality  info-dynamics  information-theory  information  infrastructure  innovation  institutions  int  integrity  intelligence  intelligenceamplification  interdisciplinary  interests  interpretability  intervention  interview  intricacy  intuition  investigative-journo  investing  iq  iraq-syria  iron-age  is-ought  isteveish  it  iteration-recursion  japan  jargon  jas  jeffreyscudder  josh  journos-pundits  kayfabe  key  kittens  korea  kumbaya-kult  labor  language  latin-america  law  leadership  leaks  learn  learning  left-wing  legibility  lehman  lens  letters  leviathan  linear-algebra  links  literature  lived-experience  local-global  lol  long-short-run  loops  low-hanging  madisonian  magnitude  malaise  malthus  management  managerial-state  mankiw  map-territory  marginal-rev  markets  martial  math  mathtariat  maxim-gun  measure  measurement  media  medicine  medieval  mediterranean  medium  mena  meta:medicine  meta:prediction  meta:rhetoric  meta:war  metabolic  metabuch  metalepsis  metameta  metaphor  methodology  metonymy  metrics  michael_faraday  micro  microfoundations  microsoft  migrant-crisis  migration  ml  mmm  model-organism  models  modernity  modules  moloch  monetary-fiscal  money  morality  mostly-modern  multi  multiplicative  music  mutation  myth  n-factor  name  narrative  nascent-state  nationalism-globalism  natural-experiment  nature  network-structure  neural-style  neuro-nitgrit  neuro  neurons  new-religion  news  nibble  nietzschean  nlp  no-go  noble-lie  noise-structure  northeast  nutrition  nytimes  occident  oceans  old-anglo  online  ontology  optimate  order-disorder  orfe  org:anglo  org:biz  org:bleg  org:bv  org:edu  org:gov  org:lite  org:mag  org:nat  org:ngo  org:rec  org:sci  organizing  orient  oscillation  outcome-risk  paid  paint  painting  paleocon  parable  paradox  parasites-microbiome  patience  paying-rent  pdf  peace-violence  pedagogy  people  personal  perspective  philosophy  phone  photography  physics  piracy  platform  play  poast  polarization  policy  polisci  political-econ  politics  poll  polynomials  pop-diff  population-genetics  population  populism  pre-ww2  prediction  pro-rata  problem-solving  processing  programming  propaganda  protestant-catholic  pseudoe  psychology  psychometrics  public  putnam-like  q-n-a  qra  qtl  quantum-info  quantum  questions  quotes  race  random  randy-ayndy  rat-pack  rationality  ratty  realness  realpolitik  recent-selection  recipes  red-queen  reddit  redistribution  reduction  reference  reflection  regression-to-mean  regularizer  regulation  relationships  religion  representation  reputation  research  resource  review  reviews  revolution  rhetoric  right-wing  risk  roots  rot  run  russia  ryan_tweney  s:*  sanctity-degradation  sapiens  scale  scaling  science-anxiety  science  scifi-fantasy  scitariat  screen  search  security  selection  self-interest  sex  sexuality  signal-noise  similarity  simile  simplification  sinosphere  size  sketch  smoothness  social-capital  social-science  social-structure  social  society  sociology  socs-and-mops  software  software_development  space  spatial  speaking  spearhead  speculation  speedometer  sports  spreading  starbucks  stats  stigma  stories  study  stylized-facts  substitution  summary  surface  svg  synecdoche  synthesis  talks  tanlin  taxes  tcs  tcstariat  tech  technologies  technology  temperature  terms  text  the-basilisk  the-bones  the-classics  the-great-west-whale  the-trenches  the-world-is-just-atoms  theory-practice  theos  thesis  thick-thin  thiel  thinking  thought  thucydides  time-series  time  tip-of-tongue  tool  tools  track-record  trade  tradeoffs  tradition  trans  traversal  trees  trends  tribalism  trope  trump  trust  truth  turchin  twin-study  twitter  ubiquity  uncertainty  unintended-consequences  universalism-particularism  urban-rural  urban  us-them  usa  user  values  vampire-squid  variance-components  videogame  visual  vocab  vocabulary  volo-avolo  war  wealth-of-nations  wealth  webwriting  west-hunter  westminster  white-paper  wiki  wikipedia  windows  winner-take-all  wire-guided  wisdom  within-without  word  wordpress  words  world-war  world  writing  xenobio  yoga  zeitgeist  zero-positive-sum  🌞  🎩  🐸  👽  🤖 

Copy this bookmark: