Authority   3534

« earlier    

When You Try to Change People That's Not Love, It's Domination | On Being
"In an interview conducted nearly thirty years ago, social visionary bell hooks had this to say about love and domination:
“I want there to be a place in the world where people can engage in one another.”


While hooks was discussing racial and gender representation in film, her statement can be broadly applied to relationships at home, in neighborhoods, in cities, and across whole societies.

To say “I want there to be a place in the world where people can engage in one another’s differences in a way that is redemptive” is to exercise one’s moral, social, and theological imagination. It is to pray and think expansively, imagining a world yet unborn into being. It is to recognize that difference need not be an occasion for brutality, but an occasion for mutual enhancement.

“I want there to be a place in the world” is the line poets, musicians, and storytellers utter before composing and what first-time parents pronounce while staring at their sleeping newborn: the desire to see one’s significant other or child or close friend given the space to flourish as themselves, not as someone else.

Qualifying “I love you” with “In order to love you, I must make you something else” is to use love as a pretext for domination, not as a springboard for generative companionship. To say, “In order to love you, I must make you something else” is to blur the good news that a loving God and community receive us as we are, not as we want to be or pretend to be. Much of Christian preaching and formation emphasizes the latter — the pretending — which feeds the pious-sounding quip:
“God loves you just the way you are, but too much to leave you that way.”


While well-meaning, that statement plays into the assumption that God will love us more as we become something or someone else.

Domination is the attempt to change others, recast them, remake them, possess them, control them. Domination is what took place in the Canadian residential schools. Masterminds of the schools thought they were being loving toward the indigenous people they enrolled, but they were actually practicing a logic of colonialist domination.

Domination is an uncreative, if convincing, imitation of love. Love says, “I receive you as you are and want to imagine a world in which you are received as you are,” exposing domination as a failure of imagination; love is imagination when it is given permission to meditate on endless possibility. Like planting a seed, watering it, and watching it become the tree you always knew it was. The seed isn’t being made into something else, but is living out its fullest potential, the way a sculptor discovers her subject in a block of stone. This is one way of seeing the life of love, or what the Rev. Marcus Halley calls “episodes of grace,” a series of moments in which we are awakened to the unique ways in which we are loved by God; not possessed, recast, or remade by God, but loved.

It is difficult for many of us to discern the difference between love and domination because so much of what we’ve been told was love throughout our lives was actually domination. This was apparent to me in a coffee shop conversation I had with a person who had recently disclosed to their closest family members that they are transgender. After two years of conversations with those family members, that person was given an ultimatum by a sibling:
“We will always love you, but either you allow us to refer to you by the pronouns and name we grew up using for you, or we will be forced to end our relationship with you.”


This friend went on to say that nothing hurt more in that conversation than their sibling’s “but.” “That single word negated every word that preceded it,” they said. The sigh of relief my friend needed to breathe would have come had they heard they are loved and received as they are, full stop. No caveats, fine print, or need to pretend that they are something that they aren’t.

When Christians celebrate and receive the presence of God in the bread and wine of Eucharist, we hear what my friend so desperately wanted to hear from their family. This doesn’t mean that my friend, or any of us, is looking to simply feel good about ourselves, but that we yearn to be fully known, seen, and loved.

Public theology is at its best when it creates the space necessary for people of various gender identities, religious affiliations and non-affiliations, ethnicities, and economic levels to be known as their full selves, not pushed into a mold not meant for them. It is being less concerned about finding surface-level common ground than about holding space for people’s unique experiences of divinity and humanity."
domination  authority  broderickgreer  2017  bellhooks  teaching  relationships  power  brutality  violence  love  colonialism  control  self  humanism  huamnity  diversity  acceptance  inclusivity  gender  transgender  marcushalley  christianity  difference 
yesterday by robertogreco
Why Tech CEOs Seem So Dumb
"But next time you're SHOCKED at a tech CEO saying something that sounds stupid or ignorant, remember: at a lot of tech companies, a CEO's job isn't to change or even understand your world, it's to maintain theirs."
market-worship  authority 
10 days ago by rdormer
letsencrypt/boulder: An ACME-based CA, written in Go.
FOr setting up a private CA with ACME support. Usable for short lived certs?
CA  certificate  authority  software  ACME  protocol  on-premisis  server  PKI  SSL  TLS 
27 days ago by asteroza
The real roots of early city states may rip up the textbooks | New Scientist
Questions the prevailing view that towns presuppose government, power and coersion, suggests it's possible to have towns w little/no central authority
history  culture  anthropology  book  middleeast  africa  grain  government  power  development  debunk  2017  review  authority 
5 weeks ago by csrollyson

« earlier    

related tags

#semrushchat  &  ***  -  1960s  1963  1980  2013  2015  2017  3rd  ability  academia  academic-culture  acceptance  acme  activism  adamgrant  admission  admissions  advertising  advice  africa  agile  agility  airport  alfredostoessner  algorithms  allankaprow  allsorts  alternativefacts  altruism  an  analysis  analytics  and  animalrights  annialbers  annicejacoby  anthonyhuberman  anthropology  api  application  approval  arabspring  archive  arena  argentina  art  artists  arts  artworld  as  attention  augustoroabastos  austrian  authentication  authenticity  authoritarians  authority  automated  autonomy  availability  aws  backlinks  basquecountry  beauty  belief  bellhooks  belonging  best  bible  bitcoin  blackmountaincollege  blackness  bless  blockchain  bmc  bodies  bongjoon-ho  book  books  boycott-divestment  brand  branded  branfordmarsalis  broderickgreer  brutality  buckminsterfuller  building  bundle  business  businesses:  ca  canon  capitalism  care  caring  carlosfuentes  catalonia  catalunya  certificate  certificates  certs  chain  channel  children  chrisjohnson  christianity  christinesunkim  christopheralexander  citation  citations  classideas  client  climatechange  cloudflare  collaboration  collectiveintelligence  collectivism  colleges  colonialism  command  communication  community  compasses  complexity  compliance  compulsory  conflict  conspiracy  constitution  constructionism  constructivism  content  control  correlation  count  courage  craft  create  creativity  credibility  criticaltheory  cruelty  css  cubism  culture  currency  curriculum  cv  data  davidhammons  dc:creator=benjaminwalter  dctagged  debunk  decentralisation  decentralise  decentralization  decisions  decolonization  dehumanisation  democracy  dependence  deschooling  design  development  difference  digitalliteracy  disasters  discipline  discretion  disobedience  distrust  diversity  do  documentary  domain  domains  dominance  domination  donellameadows  e-signature  ebook  ebwhite  economics  edboyden  edg  education  elasticity  elboom  elitism  elvispresley  email  emancipation  emergence  environmentalism  ephemerality  essay  evaluation  everyday  expectations  experimentation  expertise  experts  explanation  exploittion  extroverts  eyeo2017  fabrication  facebook  factor  failure  fake  fakenews  fantasy  fascism  fear  fellini  feminism  finance  financial  flow  flying  followers  followership  football  for  forum  fra  free  freedom  friday  fund  futbol  future  gabrielgarcíamárquez  gafferongamesseries  galleries  game-development  game  gamedev  gender  generosity  geo-topical  georgehein  georgelewis  getitdunn  gifts  globalization  google  google:  government  grace  grain  green  greenhouse  groups  habit  healthcare  helenvendler  help  heterogeneity  hierarchy  hieroglyphics  high  history  homeless  homogeneity  homophobia  honesty  horizontality  how  howto  howwelearn  howweteach  hr  huamnity  humanism  hyperreality  identifiers  image  immigrants  immigration  imperial  imperialism  implosion  improvisation  inclusion  inclusivity  independence  influence  info200  information-seeking  innovation  insiders  instant  institutions  instruction  interdisciplinary  internet  intervention  introverts  invention  invest  invisibility  is  ishmael  italy  ivyleague  jackwhitten  jayforrester  jazz  jean-lucnancy  jeffhowe  jennyodell  jobs  jobsearch  johndewey  johnlennon  joiito  josélezamalima  judithbutler  judychicago  juliocortázar  justice  kant  katherinesilver  kelleydong  kimhye-ri  knowledge  kojinkaratani  korea  labor  language  lapff  latinamerica  launch  law  layout  lcproject  leaders  leadership  leads  learning  learningobjectives  learningoutcomes  lecture  leganord  leslielabowitz  levigahman  lgbt  liberal  libertarian  library  life  linearity  link  linkeddata  linkedopendata  linking  literacy  literature  local  love  lyft  magicrealism  maintenance  making  management  managerialism  marcelduchamp  marcushalley  mariovargasllosa  market-worship  markmanson  material  materials  meaning  mediainterviews  menace  metadata  metrics  middleeast  milesdavis  military  misogyny  mitmedialab  money  moz  multispecies  museums  music  mutiny  nation-state  naval_science  ndl301  neoliberalism  netflix  network  networking  networks  news  noahpurifoy  nonlinear  not  nuclear  nurture  nyc  objectives  of  oil  okj  olvido  omnidisciplinary  on-premisis  ontology  open  openssl  openstudioproject  oppression  organization  organizations  ornettecoleman  outcomes  outsiders  ownership  p2p  page  party  paulofreire  pedagogy  pension  philosophy-of-science  physics  pietrust  pirc  pki  platforms  policing  politics  power  pr  practice  presbyterian  presence  presidency  presidential  prestige  privacy  private  programming  progress  progressive  projectbasedlearning  protocol  psychology  publishing  purpose  race  racism  radicalism  radlib  raid  rajoymariano  ranker  ranking  rankings  rayuela  reading  reality  reciprocity  referendum  relationalauthority  relationality  relationships  remembering  representation  repression  research  reslilience  resources  resumes  retirement  review  revolution  risk  ritual  rocket  rosegold  routine  ruleoflaw  rules  safecast  safeguard  safety  saracwynar  scale  schoolforpoeticcomputation  schooling  schools  science  scripture  search  searchmarketing  security  self-organization  self  semrushchat  seo  separatism  server  sfpc  sfsh  shame  silence  simonsinek  simulation  sites  slow  small  soccer  socialevolution  socialmedia  society  sociology  software  solutions  souls  spain  speculation  spirits  sports  srg  ssl  standards  status  stndardization  structure  study:  stupid  sunaurataylor  susancain  suzannelacy  syllabus  system  systems  systemsthinking  taeyoonchoi  tcsnmy  teaching  teams  technology  ted  teens  textiles  the-great-discontinuity  the  theboom  theloniousmonk  theory  timkeller  tls  to-write-about  to  trading  training  transdisciplinary  transgender  transparency  trickster  trump  trust  truth  tsa  tutorials  tweens  types  ucberkeley  uncertainty  understanding  unitedstates  universities  unlearning  unschooling  us  usa  use  utility  values  video  violence  visibility  vocabularies  volume  vs.  walking  war  weaving  web  what  when  whiteboard  with  women  work  workplace  writing  ya  youth  youtube  zapatistas   

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: